Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2009] FCA 997

INDUSTRIAL LAW - application for interim injunction - s 39 of Building Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) - whether industrial action is occurring or threatened, impending or probable - Order made by Fair Work Australia similar in substance to the terms of the interim injunction sought - application dismissed  

Building Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) s 36(1)(a), s 36(1)(d), s 36(1)(g)(i), s 37, s 38,  s 39, s 39(1), s 39(2), s 39(3), s 39(3)(a), s 39(3)(b), s 39(3)(c), s 49(1)(a), s 49(1)(b), s 49(1)(c), s 49(5), s 76
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1324, s 1324(4)
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Mauer-Swisse Securities Limited (2002) 42 ACSR 605
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Parkes (2001) 38 ACSR 355
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Sweeney [2001] NSWSC 114
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Triton Underwriting Insurance Agency Pty Ltd (2003) 48 ACSR 249
Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380

AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER v CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION and JOSEPH MCDONALD

WAD 142 of 2009

BARKER J
2 SEPTEMBER 2009
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

WAD 142 of 2009

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER
Applicant

AND:

CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION
First Respondent

JOSEPH MCDONALD
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

BARKER J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 SEPTEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application for an interlocutory injunction be dismissed.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

WAD 142 of 2009

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER
Applicant

AND:

CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION
First Respondent

JOSEPH MCDONALD
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

BARKER J

DATE:

2 SEPTEMBER 2009

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

APPLICATION FOR INTERIM INJUNCTION

  1. By application dated 21 August 2009, the applicant, the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner (Commissioner) seeks final relief as follows:

    ·Declarations.

    ·Injunctive relief, pursuant to s 39(1) and s 49(1)(c) of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) (the Act) to restrain contraventions by the respondents of s 38 of the Act.

    ·Orders pursuant to s 49(1)(a) of the Act, for the imposition of pecuniary penalties for such contraventions.

    ·Orders pursuant to s 49(1)(b) of the Act, for the respondents to pay compensation for damage suffered by reason of such contraventions.

    ·Orders pursuant to s 49(5) of the Act that the pecuniary penalties sought be paid to the Commonwealth.

    ·Orders pursuant to s 49(1)(b) of the Act that the compensation sought be paid to Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd (Probuild).

  2. The Commissioner's application also claims "interlocutory relief" in the following terms:

    1.Until determination of this application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construc... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 997
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Building and Construction Commissioner brought proceedings against the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) seeking an interim injunction to prevent unlawful industrial action. Probuild, a construction company, had reported issues with blocked toilets on their construction site, leading to a workforce stoppage. The Commissioner argued that this stoppage constituted unlawful industrial action, potentially threatening further disruptions. The CFMEU, on the other hand, maintained that the stoppage was justified due to health and safety concerns arising from the blocked toilets.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the circumstances warranted the grant of an interim injunction to prevent further unlawful industrial action. The court had to determine if the stoppage of work constituted unlawful industrial action under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and if such action was occurring, threatened, impending, or probable. The court also needed to consider the principles governing the grant of injunctions, including whether the usual tests for such relief applied in this statutory context.

The court concluded that an interim injunction could only be granted if unlawful industrial action was either occurring or threatened, impending, or probable, as per section 39(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The court emphasised that the statutory power to grant an injunction was contingent upon the presence of unlawful industrial action and not merely on the potential for substantial damage or the defendant’s past conduct. The court noted that while it could grant an injunction under certain circumstances outlined in section 39(3), these were not independent grounds for relief but rather exceptions to the usual equitable principles.

After considering the evidence and submissions, the court decided not to grant the interim injunction. The court found that while the stoppage constituted unlawful industrial action, the specific circumstances did not justify the immediate intervention of an injunction. The court also highlighted that the main action would continue, leaving open the possibility of seeking further relief if circumstances changed.

The final order of the court was to dismiss the application for an interlocutory injunction, allowing the main action to proceed without the immediate imposition of an injunction.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for an interlocutory injunction be dismissed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Senior counsel for the Commissioner called Darren Michael Wolf, Project Director for Probuild to give vive voce evidence in support of the notice of motion. An order made by Fair Work Australia on Friday 21 August 2009 was received into evidence. The respondents put into evidence an affidavit of Graham Pallot, Assistant Secretary of the first respondent, the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU). Mr Pallot was available for cross examination, but was not required by the Commissioner. Following submissions by counsel on behalf of the parties, I dismissed the notice of motion and gave short reasons, indicating that I would provide more detailed reasons later. These are the reasons for dismissing the notice of motion.FACTS Darren Michael Wolf was called by the Commissioner to give evidence in support of the notice of motion for interlocutory relief. In examination in chief, Mr Wolf gave evidence to the following effect:·Probuild is in the business of project management and construction management of commercial constructions, ranging from apartments through to office buildings in various retail projects. It is currently involved in the project management of a construction called One40 William Street, at 140 William Street, Perth Western Australia.·He answers to the State Manager, Eric Meyerowitz.·At approximately 9am on Thursday 20 August 2009, while on the construction site, he was advised by Marcus Gordon, the site manager for Probuild, that there was a problem with the toilets on the Wellington building, which is part of the project site, but that it was currently being rectified by plumbers engaged by Probuild.·Soon after being advised of this problem by Marcus Gordon, Mr Gordon received a telephone call concerning the current situation in relation to the toilets as a result of which he left the meeting he was engaged in with Mr Wolf in order to meet the plumbing supervisor.·At approximately 10am, Marcus Gordon advised Mr Wolf that the second respondent, Joe McDonald, was currently on site and had been on site from approximately 9.30am, and that the situation in relation to the toilets was rectified and the toilets had been cleaned and disinfected by approximately 9.45am.·Mr Wolf was advised by Marcus Gordon that Mr McDonald had conducted a meeting with workers at smoko, at approximately 10am, and had a discussion in relation to the issue of the amenities (that is to say, the toilets). The smoko at 10am was a normal smoko break, that lasted approximately 20 minutes, held on site at facilities within the Wellington building called a crib hut.·After 10am, he (Mr Wolf) personally met with Joe McDonald. The meeting came about because he was advised by Marcus Gordon that Mr McDonald had indicated that the site had chosen to withdraw their labour from site and Mr McDonald wished to have a conversation and discussion with him, Marcus Gordon and the site representative, Jim Reid. The meeting took place at about 10.15am.·At that stage, Mr Wolf had limited specific knowledge about the exact events. At the meeting, the participants went through the situation. Mr Wolf asked Joe McDonald and Marcus Gordon to explain what the actual situation was regarding the toilets and why the actual workforce had left the site when there were additional alternative amenities in place that the site crew had been made aware of. He understood that the workforce had left by the time that meeting commenced.·At the meeting, Joe McDonald put the position that he felt there was an immediate risk to health and safety in relation to the amenities that had become blocked. The Probuild representatives at the meeting went through a discussion process where Mr Wolf was informed by Marcus Gordon that the amenities were actually operational and had been cleaned. Joe McDonald acknowledged in the meeting and discussion that he was aware of that, that the amenities had been re‑established. He also acknowledged that there were alternative amenities on site which Marcus Gordon had had discussions with him about prior to the meeting, advising that there were alternative amenities on site that were suitable to be utilised. He (Mr Wolf) asked Mr McDonald, at that stage, to clarify why he believed there was an immediate risk to health and safety. He said that Mr McDonald advised him that was his opinion.·There had been two earlier instances over a 24 month period of difficulties with the toilets, but each had been dealt with and the interruption would have been less than an hour and no industrial action had taken place in relation to those problems.·Probuild had established alternative amenities in the B1 basement area because they were planning to shut down the amenities in which the blockage had occurred, over the weekend of 22 and 23 August 2009, and relocate to the alternative amenities in B1 basement area, which had been completed and established and were suitable for use. Also there are a number of toilet facilities throughout the building structure that are used on a daily basis that were not affected by the blockage. There were also amenities that are used by staff personnel within the office component of the site establishment which Probuild offered for use while the blockage was being dealt with.·The amenities affected by the blockage comprised approximately 14 toilets and two urinals. Throughout the remainder of the site, there were approximately 19 toilet facilities available and one urinal. Altogether there were 19 alternative toilets for use.·In his (Mr Wolf's) opinion there were sufficient toilets for a workforce of 300 on the site, other than the 14 blocked toilets.·At the meeting he had with Mr McDonald, Mr McDonald highlighted that members raised a motion to not return to work until Monday morning (that is to say Monday 24 August 2009).·Following the meeting, Probuild instructed its lawyers to cause an application to be made to Fair Work Australia under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) on behalf of Probuild for an urgent hearing in relation to the issue.·A hearing was conducted by Commissioner Williams of Fair Work Australia on this very day, 21 August 2009, and an order was made against the CFMEU which had been served on the Union by Probuild this very afternoon. He had attended the Fair Work Australia hearing.·That morning, prior to leaving the construction site at 140 William Street in order to attend the Fair Work hearing, he (Mr Wolf) had seen Mr McDonald on the site, he requested him to leave the site, which Mr McDonald subsequently did.·While a number of workers on the site engaged by Probuild, or on behalf of its contractors, were or are members of the CFMEU, a number were members of the ETU (Electrical Trades Union) and the CEPU (Communications Electrical and Plumbing Union).·As of 21 August 2009, this very day, notwithstanding the resolution of workers of 20 August 2009, a limited few CFMEU members had chosen to return to work. About 60 in total (out of 300) had returned. Perhaps about eight were CFMEU members, the rest being ETU or CEPU members. He (Mr Wolf) was notified electronically while he was at the Fair Work Australia hearing that Mr McDonald had returned to the site and was requesting and having discussions with the personnel that were attending work and "trying to coerce them into leaving the site". He had been requested to leave by the Project Manager, Jason Ball, on a number of occasions, which he had refused to do. He believed that another 20 workers had left the site following Mr McDonald's visit, leaving approximately 40 workers still on the site.·Probuild has a collective agreement with the CFMEU that does not expire, he believes, until August 2011. Approximately 95% of Probuild's sub‑contractors have agreements with the CFMEU. He has not been made aware of any of those agreements being due to expire. ·The stoppage by workers on the Probuild site will have a direct effect in relation to critical path works associated with the structure and Probuild services. In this particular situation, the stoppage has had an additional effect associated with critical works "that we had scheduled for the installation of the HV (high voltage cable) services by Western Power, which has taken a substantial effort to have coordinated and scheduled for this weekend. It is very difficult to get the actual work crews that Western Power have allocated to those works because there is only certain work crews that can do those HV terminations and those crews are actually in quite significant demand at the moment". As the result of the stoppage, the work would not go ahead this weekend and will have to be rescheduled.·Due to the interruption suffered and certain permits and criteria that need to be put in place, it was unable to be put in place and due to uncertainty at the outcome of the hearing in Fair Work Australia today, Western Power had decided to reallocate their resources to alternative works. However, Probuild's electrical subcontractor was trying to coordinate the rescheduling of the work at the moment.·So far as the critical path works are concerned, they are the structure and certain elements of the services and façade and all of those items have been affected by the last two days. The delay of the critical path means that time wasted cannot be regained.·There was also an issue about an Alimak, which is a temporary lift system, utilised for the movement of services and men and material up and down the project between floors. The Alimak is scheduled to be removed on the weekend of 22 and 23 August 2009 to facilitate a section of counter‑levered structure that needs to be put in place on level 16 of the tower. Currently at this stage, Probuild are aware that this is still going ahead based on the decision that has been handed down by Fair Work Australia today. Probuild has been able to ensure that those works are carried out this weekend.·He is aware that certain officials of the CFMEU hold permits to enter the site for occupational health and safety and other reasons. However, Joe McDonald is not a person who holds such a permit. He (Mr Wolf) understands that Mr McDonald is an official of the CFMEU.·A letter dated 17 October 2008 was sent by Probuild's lawyers to Mr McDonald requiring Mr McDonald to comply with Probuild's protocols for entry to a site. That letter was received into evidence as Exhibit B. The order made by Fair Work Australia on 21 August 2009 was received into evidence as Exhibit A.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BARKER J
Taking all these factors into account, in my discretion I would refuse to grant an interim injunction.CONCLUSION AND ORDER For these reasons I dismiss the application for an interim injunction. The main action remains on foot and, of course, if circumstances should develop in some other way, there might be fresh grounds for interim relief to be sought.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BARKER J

Counsel for the respondents was permitted, in the circumstances in which the evidence in re‑examination had developed in relation to visits by Mr McDonald to the work site, to ask some further questions. He confirmed that in January 2009, Probuild commenced proceedings in the Industrial Relations Commission (as it then was) alleging unlawful industrial action and sought s 496 orders as a result of Mr McDonald's conduct. However, he could not recall instituting proceedings in respect of the February 2009 incident and did not believe that proceedings had been instituted in respected of the June 2009 incident.CONSIDERATION OF APPLICATION FOR INTERIM INJUNCTION The application for an interim injunction is made by the Commissioner pursuant to s 39 of the Act. Section 39(1) provides that:(1)If, on application by the ABC Commissioner or any other person, an appropriate court is satisfied that unlawful industrial action is:(a)occurring; or(b)threatened, impending or probable;then the court may grant an injunction in such terms as the court considers appropriate. Section 39(2) permits the Court to grant an "interim injunction" pending determination of an application under subs (1). Section 39(3) makes it plain that the power of the Court to grant an injunction restraining a person from engaging in conduct may be exercised:(a)whether or not it appears to the court that the defendant intends to engage again, or to continue to engage, in conduct of that kind; and(b)whether or not the defendant has previously engaged in conduct of that kind; and(c)whether or not there is an imminent danger of substantial damage to any person if the defendant engages in conduct of that kind. In my view it is clear that an injunction, including an interim injunction of the type here sought, is a statutory injunction that may only be granted under s 39 on the application of the Commissioner if unlawful industrial action is either occurring or threatened, impending or probable. While the Court may grant an injunction whether or not the circumstances described in s 39(3)(a), (b) or (c) exist, the circumstances in s 39(3) are not of themselves sources of power that justify the grant of an injunction. Rather, they empower the Court to grant an injunction in circumstances where the usual principles governing the grant of injunctions at equity might suggest an injunction should not be granted: Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380 (Cardile). For example, whereas at equity the grant of a quia timet injunction, to prevent threatened harm, might on some tests only be granted if harm is imminent, s 39(3) modifies any such requirement. As to the circumstances in which a quia timet injunction might go, see Spry, The Principles of Equitable Remedies, (7th ed, Lawbook Co., 2007) pp 377 – 382. In other words, the touchstone for the Court's power to grant an injunction under s 39 is satisfaction that unlawful industrial action is occurring or threatened, impending or probable as set out in s 39(1).