official notice
decision of the commissioner of patents
Application : No. 639579 in the name of AUSTOFT INDUSTRIES LTD
Title: Base Cutter Assembly
Action: Opposition by Cameco Industries, Inc. Decision in the opposition following an invitation to provide further evidence.
Decision: Issued .
Abstract: Decision dated 23 November 1995 found there was anticipation by prior use, but gave the parties an opportunity to provide further evidence to definitively establish what was incorporated on the machine of the prior use.
Further evidence considered. Discussion of the principles of benefit of doubt, of the standard of proof required, and of shifting the burden of proof from the opponent to the applicant.The evidentiary burden of proof of the shape of the drive shaft present in the machine of the prior use lay, in the present circumstances, with the applicant.
Majority of claims found to have been anticipated by the prior use. Applicant given an opportunity to amend.
patents act 1990
decision of the commissioner of patents
Re:Patent Application No. 639579 in the name of AUSTOFT INDUSTRIES LTD, opposition thereto by CAMECO INDUSTRIES INC, and consideration of evidence filed as a result of an invitation.
background
In my decision dated 23 November 1995 [reported in (1996) AIPC ¶91-206] I made a number of findings, including a finding that there had been a prior use of the invention before the priority date of the claims. However, there were difficulties with the evidence available. In brief:
the applicant argued its case on the basis that prior use had occurred (arguing that the use should be excluded by way of it being a reasonable trial) without addressing the detail of what in fact was used; and
the opponent’s evidence did not establish what was used at the admitted prior use.
As a result, my decision concluded:
“However, the evidence of exactly what was used on 8 July is far from satisfactory; but given the implicit admission that the use involved some form of the present invention, the balance of the evidence would suggest that the use was of a form of the invention corresponding to Fig 3. However, before making that conclusion I think it is appropriate in all the circumstances to provide both parties an opportunity to provide me with definitive evidence (such as engineering drawings, verifiable photographs) of what was in fact incorporated on the machine for the 8 July use.”
and the parties had until 23 December 1995 to provide any such material. Following a request for further time to provide material, the applicant filed a statutory declaration by their patent attorney accompanied by six exhibits. The opponent considered the material supplied by the applicant to be insufficient, and requested that I make an order for the production of certain documents. In a decision dated 15 February 1996 I refused to make such an order for production. I also gave both parties 14 days to advise whether they wished to be heard on the effect of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Austoft Industries Ltd v Cameco Industries Inc and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1996] APO 26
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Commissioner found that the prior use effectively admitted by the applicant constituted a prior use of the claimed invention. However, the evidence of what was actually present on the machine used in the prior use was poor. The Commissioner found that the cleaning means was in the form of a disk, but the shape of the drive shaft and the location of the cleaning means were uncertain. The Commissioner considered the evidentiary burden of proof of what was used on the machine that day lay with the applicant, as the applicant was in a special position with respect to the prior use. The Commissioner found that the machine used at the prior use had a drive shaft having an hour-glass configuration.
The Commissioner concluded that claims 1 to 6 of the patent application lacked novelty on the basis of the prior use. Claim 7 was found to be novel as the arrangement disclosed in the prior use did not include a deflector plate acting as a cleaning means. Claim 8 was found to be unclear and not fairly based on the specification. The Commissioner allowed the applicant 60 days to propose suitable amendments to overcome the prior use and grant a patent for patentable subject matter not disclosed by the prior use. The Commissioner made no award of costs as neither party attended a hearing in respect of the decision.
This case highlights the importance of providing clear and definitive evidence in patent applications. The Commissioner found that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to establish what was actually used in the prior use, and shifted the burden of proof to the applicant. The Commissioner also considered the standard of proof required in patent opposition proceedings, and found that the balance of probabilities was sufficient to establish novelty or lack thereof. The Commissioner allowed the applicant an opportunity to amend the patent claims to overcome the prior use, and granted the applicant 60 days to propose suitable amendments.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.