Austin BMI Pty Ltd v Deputy Premier (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

 Austin BMI Pty Ltd v Deputy Premier (No 2) [2023] QSC 162

PARTIES:

In Matter No 2105 of 2022

AUSTIN BMI PTY LTD (ACN 164 204 308)

(applicant)

V

DEPUTY PREMIER, MINISTER FOR STATE DEVELOPMENT, LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND PLANNING AND MINISTER ASSISTING THE PREMIER ON OLYMPICS INFRASTRUCTURE

(first respondent)

AND

WANLESS RECYCLING PARK PTY LTD (ACN 623 407 081)

(second respondent)

AND

IPSWICH CITY COUNCIL

(third respondent)

In Matter No 2198 of 2022 

VEOLIA ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 051 316 584) AND (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 100 535 751) trading as TI-TREE BIO-ENERGY (ABN 67 450 387 919) an unincorporated joint venture

(applicant)

V

DEPUTY PREMIER, MINISTER FOR STATE DEVELOPMENT, LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND PLANNING AND MINISTER ASSISTING THE PREMIER ON OLYMPICS INFRASTRUCTURE

(first respondent)

AND

WANLESS RECYCLING PARK PTY LTD (ACN 623 407 081)

(second respondent)

AND

IPSWICH CITY COUNCIL

(third respondent)

In Matter No 2192 of 2022

CAROL ASHWORTH

(first applicant)

AND

CORNELIA TURNI

(second applicant)

AND

ROSEMAREE THOMASSON

(third applicant)

AND

KERRY MAREE BUTLER

(fourth applicant)

AND

KERRI ANNE LYNCH

(fifth applicant)

AND

MARK MEIER

(sixth applicant)

V

DEPUTY PREMIER, MINISTER FOR STATE DEVELOPMENT, LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND PLANNING AND MINISTER ASSISTING THE PREMIER ON OLYMPICS INFRASTRUCTURE

(first respondent)

AND

WANLESS RECYCLING PARK PTY LTD (ACN 623 407 081)

(second respondent)

AND

IPSWICH CITY COUNCIL

(third respondent)

FILE NOS:

2105 of 2022; 2192 of 2022; 2198 of 2022

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Applications 

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court

DELIVERED ON:

21 July 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

JUDGE:

Freeburn J

ORDERS:

1.   In proceeding No. 2105 of 2022:

a.   the applicant pay the costs of the first and second respondents;

b.   the third respondent pay the costs of the second respondent, but limited to 10% of those costs;

2.   In proceeding No. 2198 of 2022:

a.   the applicant pay the costs of the first and second respondents;

b.   the third respondent pay the costs of the second respondent, but limited to 10% of those costs;

3.   In proceeding No. 2192 of 2022 the applicant pay the costs of the second respondent.

CATCHWORDS:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – COSTS – where the proceeding involved three separate applications – where applicants in two of the three proceedings conducted the litigation jointly – where the applications were dismissed – where the joint applicants argue that they should not pay both of the successful respondents costs on the basis that there was duplication in the way the litigation was conducted –  whether the applicants should pay the costs of two respondents – whether it was reasonable for the respondents to be at arm’s length during the litigation

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – COSTS – where the third respondent to the proceeding supported the applicants – where one of the successful respondents seeks cost against the third respondent – where the third respondent argues that their role in the proceedings was limited – whether the third respondent should pay the costs of the successful respondent in full…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Austin BMI Pty Ltd v Deputy Premier (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QSC 162
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Austin BMI Pty Ltd v Deputy Premier (No 2) involved three separate applications, with Austin BMI Pty Ltd and another party jointly conducting the litigation in two of the proceedings. The respondents in these two proceedings were successful, and they sought costs from the applicants. The applicants argued that they should not be liable for the costs of both respondents, as the litigation was conducted jointly and there was duplication in the process. The third respondent supported the applicants in one of the proceedings, but one of the respondents sought costs against the third respondent. The third respondent claimed its involvement in the proceedings was limited.

The court was required to determine whether the applicants should pay the costs of both respondents, considering the joint conduct of the litigation and the principle of avoiding duplication. The court also needed to decide whether it was reasonable for the respondents to remain at arm's length during the litigation and whether the third respondent should pay any costs to the successful respondent.

The court held that the applicants should pay the costs of the first and second respondents in two of the proceedings, while the third respondent should pay the second respondent's costs in those proceedings, but limited to 10% of those costs. The court found that there were less reasons for the third respondent to remain at arm's length from the Minister, as both were public entities. In the third proceeding, the court ordered the applicants to pay the costs of the second respondent.

The final orders included that in proceeding No. 2105 of 2022, the applicants should pay the costs of the first and second respondents, and the third respondent should pay the costs of the second respondent, limited to 10% of those costs. In proceeding No. 2198 of 2022, the applicants should pay the costs of the first and second respondents, and the third respondent should pay the costs of the second respondent, limited to 10% of those costs. In proceeding No. 2192 of 2022, the applicants should pay the costs of the second respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In proceeding No. 2105 of 2022:

a. the applicant pay the costs of the first and second respondents;

b. the third respondent pay the costs of the second respondent, but limited to 10% of those costs;

2. In proceeding No. 2198 of 2022:

a. the applicant pay the costs of the first and second respondents;

b. the third respondent pay the costs of the second respondent, but limited to 10% of those costs;

3. In proceeding No. 2192 of 2022 the applicant pay the costs of the second respondent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A recent case that bears some similarity to the present case is the Victorian Court of Appeal’s decision in Waterfront Place Pty Ltd v Minister for Planning (No 2).[19] In that case the court made orders refusing the applicant leave to appeal against the decision of the trial judge, which concerned the validity of the Minister’s exercise of his ‘call in’ power in respect of an application for a planning permit. Both the Minister and the third respondent (Ports Corporation) sought their costs of the appeal on the standard basis. The unsuccessful applicant accepted that it was appropriate for the court to make an award of costs against it but submitted that the costs should be limited to a single set of costs, being the costs of the Minister.[20][19][2019] VSCA 166. This case is relied on by Wanless.[20][2019] VSCA 166 at [1]-[2]. The Victorian Court of Appeal resolved the costs issue by reference to the second proviso in Statham, namely: ‘circumstances in which, although the defendants were united in their opposition to the plaintiff, their relationship to each other might be such that they would be acting reasonably in remaining at arm’s length during the general course of litigation’.[21] The second proviso was activated because:The Ports Corporation submits that in the circumstances of this case and more generally, its relationship with the Minister is such that it had to remain at arm’s length during the course of the litigation: it is a public entity established under the Transport Integration Act 2010 but does not represent the Crown; its statutory objects and functions are to manage and develop Station Pier and it has announced the Station Pier Redevelopment Project adjacent to the development that was the subject of the Minister’s ‘call in’; upon exercising his ‘call in’ power, the Minister became the decision maker in relation to a permit application to which the Ports Corporation was an objector, and to which it continues to object…The Ports Corporation has an interest in how the applicant’s land is to be developed. It has its own plans for the development of adjacent land under its management and control. It had, and continues to have, an interest in the applicant’s permit application, in respect of which the Minister is now the decision maker and to whom the Ports Corporation will be obliged to make submissions on the merits of the permit application. In the trial division, the Ports Corporation was recognised to be a proper party to the appeal from the Tribunal and no opposition was recorded to an award of costs in its favour.[22][21][2019] VSCA 166 at [5].[22][2019] VSCA 166 at [6]-[7]. The Joint Applicants sought to distinguish Waterfront Place Pty Ltd v Minister for Planning [No 2] on the grounds that the Ports Corporation had to remain at arm’s length because of its status as a separate public entity. However, it seems to me that this case is a more compelling case than Waterfront Place. There are many reasons why Wanless, a private corporation, should remain at arm’s length from the Minister. There are less reasons for the Ports Corporation, a statutory corporation, to remain at arm’s length from the Minister. Both are public entities.