Auslink Golf Course Pty Limited v Zhongsheng Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Auslink Golf Course Pty Limited v Zhongsheng Group Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 397

File numbers: NSD 1030 of 2021
NSD 253 of 2022
Judgment of: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 3 May 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – applications for security for costs – where proceedings are related – whether, because of overlap in the proceedings, to treat the proceedings equally in the making of any orders for security – where plaintiff to the proceeding is ordinarily resident outside Australia – where the respondents to the application are special purpose companies – where respondents to the application have refused to provide information as to their financial position relevant to determining whether any adverse costs order would be satisfied – where impecuniosity of respondents to the application is alleged to have been caused by the applicants – where there are existing restraining orders in place –applications granted  
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 180, 181, 182, 233, 440D, 1335

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 56

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 19.01 subs (2) and subs (3)

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) r 42.21(1)(a)

Cases cited:

Chen v Golden Land Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 985

Monarch Advisory Group Pty Ltd v Puxty [2021] FCA 341

PS Chellaram & Co Ltd v China Ocean Shipping Co (1991) 102 ALR 558; [1991] HCA 36

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 83
Date of hearing: 12 October 2022
Counsel for the Plaintiff in NSD1030/2021: Mr CD Freeman
Solicitor for the Plaintiff in NSD1030/2021: Goodwin & Co Lawyers
Counsel for the Defendants in NSD1030/2021: Mr JP Knackstredt
Solicitor for the Defendants in NSD1030/2021: McLachlan Thorpe Partners
Counsel for the Plaintiffs in NSD253/2022: Mr JP Knackstredt
Solicitor for the
Plaintiffs in NSD253/2022:
McLachlan Thorpe Partners
Counsel for the First, Second, Third and Fourth Defendants in NSD253/2022: Mr CD Freeman
Solicitor for the First, Second, Third and Fourth Defendants in NSD253/2022: Goodwin & Co Lawyers
Solicitor for the Fifth and Sixth Defendants in NSD253/2022: Mills Oakley

ORDERS

NSD 1030 of 2021
BETWEEN:

AUSLINK GOLF COURSE PTY LIMITED ACN 608 877 176

Plaintiff

AND:

ZHONGSHENG GROUP PTY LTD ACN 608 448 755

First Defendant

ZHONGSHENG MANAGEMENT PTY LTD

Second Defendant

YUN LUO (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Defendant

IN THE INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION:

BETWEEN:

ZHONGSHENG GROUP PTY LTD ACN 608 448 755
First Applicant

YUN LUO
Second Applicant

JIALIN LUO

Third Applicant

AND:

AUSLINK GOLF COURSE PTY LIMITED ACN 608 877 176
Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

3 MAY 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The plaintiff is to provide security for the costs of the first, third and fourth defendants by payment into Court or by way of an unconditional bank guarantee in a form acceptable to those defendants as follows:

(a)$100,000 within 28 days of the date of these Orders; and

(b)$340,000 14…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Auslink Golf Course Pty Limited v Zhongsheng Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 397
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Auslink Golf Course Pty Limited v Zhongsheng Group Pty Ltd involved applications for security for costs in proceedings related to the purchase and operation of a property and business. The applicants, Auslink Golf, sought security for the costs of two separate proceedings against the respondents, Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management, which were incorporated for the specific purpose of purchasing the property and business. The applicants argued that the respondents had breached agreements and fiduciary duties, engaged in oppressive conduct, and acted unconscionably. The respondents, who were special purpose companies, had refused to provide information regarding their financial position relevant to the determination of whether any adverse costs order would be satisfied.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether it should treat the two proceedings equally in making any orders for security due to the overlap in the proceedings. The court also considered whether, given that the primary plaintiff was ordinarily resident outside Australia and the respondents had allegedly caused their own impecuniosity, it should grant the application for security for costs. The court further examined the existing restraining orders in place and their relevance to the application.

The court granted the applications for security for costs, noting the difficulty in enforcing Australian judgments in the People's Republic of China where the primary plaintiff was resident. The court found that there was reason to believe that the applicants would be unable to pay the respondents' costs if successful in their defence, particularly in light of the applicants' limited financial resources and the respondents' failure to provide financial information. The court ordered the applicants to provide security for the respondents' costs in both proceedings and set out specific timelines and conditions for the payment of the security. Additionally, the applicants were ordered to pay the respondents' costs of their interlocutory application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiffs are to provide security for the costs of the first, second, third and fourth defendants by payment into Court or by way of an unconditional bank guarantee in a form acceptable to the first, second, third and fourth defendants as follows:

(a) $100,000 within 28 days of the date of these Orders; and

(b) $199,000 14 days after the date of the conclusion of any mediation, if unsuccessful, or 12 weeks prior to the commencement of any final hearing, whichever is the earlier.

2. In the event that the security in Order 1(a) and/or (b) above is not provided within the time specified, the proceeding be stayed until further order.

3. Liberty to apply on three days’ notice.

4. The plaintiffs are to pay the first, second, third and fourth defendants’ costs of their interlocutory application filed on 15 June 2022.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I will address each of the applications for security for costs in turn below. Before doing so it is convenient to set out the background to both proceedings and the applicable legal principles.BACKGROUND Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management were incorporated in 2015. Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management respectively were to purchase, and in May 2016 did purchase, the property at 1 Arundel Place, Arundel, Queensland (Property) and the business known as Arundel Hills Country Club (Business) which operated on the Property. The purchase price for the Property and the Business was $13.5 million. Mr Luo and Ms Luo are each 40% shareholders in Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management and Auslink Golf holds the remaining 20% of shares in each of those companies. Mr Luo has been a director of Zhongsheng since 25 September 2015 and a director of Zhongsheng Management since 8 June 2017 and Ms Luo has been a director of Zhongsheng since 15 June 2018 and a director of Zhongsheng Management since 22 June 2018. It was not in dispute that Mr Luo and Ms Luo are both resident in the People’s Republic of China (PRC). The current directors of Auslink Investment and Auslink Golf are Ms Chen and Mr Lin. The current shareholders of Auslink Investment are Ms Chen as to 60% and Mr Lin as to 40% and the current shareholders of Auslink Golf are Ms Chen as to 30%, Mr Lin as to 20%, Lingli Ou as to 30% and Yanli Ou as to 20%.The Auslink Proceeding The Auslink Proceeding was commenced in this Court on 5 October 2021. Auslink Golf seeks relief under s 233 of the Corporations Act against, relevantly, the Zhongsheng Parties. At the time it commenced the Auslink Proceeding, and it seems for some time thereafter, Auslink Golf was unaware of the commencement of the Zhongsheng Proceeding in the Supreme Court of New South Wales (see below). At a very high level, by its amended statement of claim filed in the Auslink Proceeding on 2 May 2022 Auslink Golf alleges that:(1)in September 2015 Ms Chen and Mr Luo agreed to form special purpose companies to purchase the Property and the Business and agreed the terms on, and manner in, which those companies would operate, including in relation to the making, and repayment, of loans by their shareholders to the companies (Agreement); (2)Zhongsheng purchased the Property and Zhongsheng Management purchased the Business;(3)in accordance with the Agreement $2,815,355.70 was advanced to Zhongsheng and $249,892 was advanced to Zhongsheng Management by or on behalf of Auslink Golf; (4)it was an implied term of the Agreement that each of the parties would act in good faith in the performance of it;(5)Mr Luo and Ms Luo, as directors of Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management, are under a fiduciary duty to act in good faith and for the benefit of the shareholders of each of Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management; (6)Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management have engaged in conduct which is oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to, or unfairly discriminatory against, Auslink Golf; (7)Mr Luo and Ms Luo are, by permitting or directing certain conduct of Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management, in breach of the Agreement and the implied term of good faith; (8)Mr Luo and Ms Luo have acted in breach of their fiduciary duties; and (9)the conduct of Mr Luo and Ms Luo is unconscionable in contravention of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), being Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Ng’s estimate of the quantum of the Zhongsheng Parties’ likely costs has not been challenged by Auslink Golf and, despite the fact that she discounts her estimate of total costs by reference to an assessment procedure rather than taxation, which is the process adopted in this Court, there is no reason not to accept the estimate provided.Conclusion It follows from the above that an order should be made that Auslink Golf is to provide security for the Zhongsheng Parties’ costs in the sum of $440,000.THE ZHONGSHENG PROCEEDINGThe Auslink Parties’ application for security for costs The Auslink Parties seek security for their costs of the Zhongsheng Proceeding in the sum of $468,845.38. The Auslink Parties submitted that the Zhongsheng Proceeding is substantially for Mr Luo’s benefit and he lives in the PRC. The Auslink Parties noted two things: first, that courts have observed that enforcement of Australian judgments in the PRC is ineffective, citing among others, Chen v Golden Land Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 985 at [81] (Parker J); and secondly, that their solicitors asked McLachlan Thorpe whether it was conceded that Mr Luo had no assets in Australia but received no response. The Auslink Parties contended that once they establish that Mr Luo is overseas, this enlivens the Court’s jurisdiction to make an order for security and provides a good reason for an order to be made. In relation to Zhongsheng, the Auslink Parties submitted that it was only after the filing of an interlocutory application in the Auslink Proceeding that unaudited financial statements of Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management were produced. They observed that Zhongsheng had a net deficiency of assets for the financial years ended 30 June 2020 and 30 June 2021 and that the financial statements do not record the loans from Auslink Golf at their full value. The Auslink Parties submitted that the failure by Zhongsheng to respond to a request to provide financial information or to establish its financial position when asked to do so should lead the Court to infer that such information would not establish that Zhongsheng would be able to meet an order for costs against it or, in the alternative, that the absence of evidence as to its financial position would permit an inference that such evidence would not assist its case. The Auslink Parties submitted that in all the circumstances the Court would be satisfied that there is reason to believe that Zhongsheng will be unable to meet a costs order if they are successful in their defence because of its financial position as recorded in the latest financial statements coupled with the significant understatement of moneys owing to Auslink Golf and the fact that it does not trade. Zhongsheng and Mr Luo submitted that the evidence does not establish that there is reason to believe that Zhongsheng will be unable to meet an adverse costs order. They say this is so because Zhongsheng is an asset rich company. At the time of the hearing of the application for security Zhongsheng had entered into an option agreement to sell its major asset and there are orders in place preventing Zhongsheng: from paying any money outside Australia to Mr Luo or Ms Luo, or its shareholders; and from repaying any relating party loans, save on terms agreed in writing between the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Auslink Golf submitted that the following factors weigh against the exercise of the Court’s discretion to order payment for security of the Zhongsheng Parties’ costs:(1)Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management were the cause of the commencement of the Auslink Proceeding because they would not give an undertaking to retain money in Australia from the sale of the Property and the Business; (2)Auslink Golf has had to bring the proceeding in order to obtain basic financial information and confirmation that moneys it has advanced would be repaid; (3)the Zhongsheng Parties’ application was not brought promptly;(4)regard should be had to the strength and bona fides of Auslink Golf’s case; (5)Auslink Golf’s impecuniosity has been caused by Zhongsheng’s conduct and the fact that it has not repaid the sum of $2,815,335.70; (6)the continuing obstructive behaviour of the defendants to the Auslink Proceeding; and (7)the failure of the directors of Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management to give any evidence.Consideration The Zhongsheng Parties principally rely on s 1335 of the Corporations Act as a basis for seeking security. That being so, the threshold question to be answered and which enlivens the Court’s discretion is whether I am satisfied by credible testimony that there is reason to believe that Auslink Golf will be unable to pay the Zhongsheng Parties’ costs if they are successful in their defence. Having regard to the evidence before me I am so satisfied. According to Juliana Ng Liah Nah, a solicitor in the employ of McLachlan Thorpe Partners, the solicitors for the Zhongsheng Parties: (1)Auslink Golf does not hold any real property in Queensland or New South Wales;(2)Auslink Golf’s position, based on an exchange of correspondence between McLachlan Thorpe and Goodwin & Co, its solicitors, is that Auslink Golf will have sufficient funds to pay any legal costs incurred in the Auslink Proceeding from the $2,815,355.70 advanced to Zhongsheng; and(3)it is anticipated that the damages claim against Auslink Golf in the Zhongsheng Proceeding will likely exceed $2,815,355.70. In answer to an initial request from the Zhongsheng Parties, Auslink Golf did not provide any financial documents showing its current financial position. The Zhongsheng Parties served a notice to produce on Auslink Golf in response to which Auslink Golf produced unsigned financial reports for the financial years ended 30 June 2020 and 30 June 2021 and some bank statements. Auslink Golf’s only assets are the loans from it to Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management. It has no cash at bank and, based on the bank statements produced by it in answer to the Zhongsheng Parties’ notice to produce, it appears to be funding its legal costs in this proceeding by advances of funds to its bank account variously described as a “Legal Fee Loan”, “Loanto Auslinkgolf” or similar. Auslink Golf has no other source of income and, as is evident from the financial statements in evidence before me, it funded the loans to Zhongsheng and Zhongsheng Management by way of corresponding borrowings from Ms Chen, Mr Lin and Ms Ou. Further, as I have already observed, Zhongsheng Management is in administration and, I was informed, is subject to a deed of company arrangement (DOCA). There was no evidence before me as to what, if any, dividend may be payable to Auslink Golf pursuant to the DOCA.