Aucare Dairy (Aust) Pty Ltd v Huang (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Aucare Dairy (Aust) Pty Ltd v Huang (No 5) [2021] FCA 739 

File number(s):

VID 674 of 2016

Judgment of:

DAVIES J

Date of judgment:

2 July 2021

Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – application for compensation by non‑party – provision in Court orders for application to be made if certain pre-conditions met – pre-conditions not met – construction of court order – causal connection between claimed loss and final orders not established – application dismissed

Cases cited:

Aucare Dairy (Aust) Pty Ltd v Huang (No 3)

[2019] FCA 412

Division:

General Division

Registry:

Victoria

National Practice Area:

Commercial and Corporations

Sub-area:

Corporations and Corporate Insolvency

Number of paragraphs:

26

Date of last submission/s:

29 April 2021

Date of hearing:

10 March 2021 to 11 March 2021

14 April 2021 to 15 April 2021

29 April 2021

Counsel for Grandtra Investments Pty Ltd:

Mr C Robinson

Solicitor for Grandtra Investments Pty Ltd:

Tahota Law

Counsel for Yanfeng Bai:

Mr C Munt

Solicitor for Yanfeng Bai:

Xiao Lawyers

ORDERS

VID 674 of 2016

BETWEEN:

AUCARE DAIRY (AUST) PTY LTD

First Applicant

YANFENG BAI

Second Applicant

AND:

YUNLING HUANG

First Respondent

ZHIXIN GUO

Second Respondent

GREAT VISION AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

IN THE INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION:

BETWEEN:

GRANDTRA INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

Applicant

AND:

AUCARE DAIRY (AUST) PTY LTD

First Respondent

YANFENG BAI

Second Respondent

order made by:

DAVIES J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 july 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The interlocutory application filed by Grandtra Investments Pty Ltd be dismissed.

2.        Subject to argument, Grandtra Investments Pty Ltd, China Global Investments Pty Ltd, Global Fortune Investment Group Pty Ltd, Global Fortune Investment Ltd and Yuting Huang (Grandtra parties) to pay the costs of the second applicant (second respondent to this application) of the interlocutory application.

3.        If there is to be an argument about costs, the Grandtra parties are to file and serve submissions of no more than 3 pages by 9 July 2021.

4.        The second applicant (second respondent to this application) to file and serve submissions in response by 16 July 2021.

5.        The question of costs is to be determined on the papers.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

DAVIES J:

  1. On 9 April 2019, the Court made final orders giving effect to the reasons for decision in Aucare Dairy (Aust) Pty Ltd v Huang (No 3) [2019] FCA 412 (the primary judgment).  The orders (see Annexure 1) included proprietary relief against the seventh respondent, Nutritional Choice Australia Pty Ltd (NCA) (orders 11 and 13).  The orders also included provision for a non‑party, Grandtra Investments Pty Ltd (Grandtra), NCA’s majority shareholder, upon the later of four weeks from the date of the order and the occurrence of “the Compensation Event”, to seek an order for compensation payable by the applicants, Aucare Dairy (Aust) Pty Ltd (Aucare) and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aucare Dairy (Aust) Pty Ltd v Huang (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 739
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Aucare Dairy (Aust) Pty Ltd and Yanfeng Bai (the applicants) sought compensation from Grandtra Investments Pty Ltd (Grandtra), the majority shareholder of Nutritional Choice Australia Pty Ltd (NCA), on the basis of a Court order that allowed Grandtra to seek compensation in certain circumstances. Grandtra sought compensation from Mr Bai only, as Aucare was in liquidation. Mr Bai opposed Grandtra’s application. The primary issue for the Court was whether the pre-conditions for Grandtra to make the application for the compensation order were met, and if so, what the effect of that order was. The secondary issue was whether Grandtra could seek compensation from Mr Bai alone.

The Court found that the pre-conditions to Grandtra’s application for compensation were not met, as the Compensation Event had not occurred. The Court also found that order 16.2 did not provide for compensation to be paid by Mr Bai to Grandtra and the minority shareholders it represented. The Court found that the compensation order could only be made in Grandtra’s own interest and on behalf of the minority shareholders, and not on behalf of NCA’s majority shareholder, IUIM Pty Ltd. The Court found that the compensation order was limited to the amount of $2,000,000 and could only be sought if the Compensation Event occurred. The Court found that the Compensation Event had not occurred, as there was no causal connection between the claimed loss and the final orders made in the primary judgment. The Court also found that the compensation order did not provide for compensation to be paid to Grandtra and the minority shareholders it represented, as the order was limited to the amount of $2,000,000 and could only be sought in Grandtra’s own interest and on behalf of the minority shareholders. The Court dismissed Grandtra’s application for compensation. The Court ordered that Grandtra and the other Grandtra parties pay the costs of the second respondent to this application, subject to argument, and that they file and serve submissions of no more than 3 pages by 9 July 2021. The Court further ordered that the second respondent to this application file and serve submissions in response by 16 July 2021, and that the question of costs be determined on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application filed by Grandtra Investments Pty Ltd be dismissed.

2. Subject to argument, Grandtra Investments Pty Ltd, China Global Investments Pty Ltd, Global Fortune Investment Group Pty Ltd, Global Fortune Investment Ltd and Yuting Huang (Grandtra parties) to pay the costs of the second applicant (second respondent to this application) of the interlocutory application.

3. If there is to be an argument about costs, the Grandtra parties are to file and serve submissions of no more than 3 pages by 9 July 2021.

4. The second applicant (second respondent to this application) to file and serve submissions in response by 16 July 2021.

5. The question of costs is to be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 9 April 2019, the Court made final orders giving effect to the reasons for decision in Aucare Dairy (Aust) Pty Ltd v Huang (No 3) [2019] FCA 412 (the primary judgment). The orders (see Annexure 1) included proprietary relief against the seventh respondent, Nutritional Choice Australia Pty Ltd (NCA) (orders 11 and 13). The orders also included provision for a non‑party, Grandtra Investments Pty Ltd (Grandtra), NCA’s majority shareholder, upon the later of four weeks from the date of the order and the occurrence of “the Compensation Event”, to seek an order for compensation payable by the applicants, Aucare Dairy (Aust) Pty Ltd (Aucare) and Yanfeng Bai (Mr Bai), for an amount not exceeding AUD$2,000,000.00 “in its own interests and on behalf of the minority shareholders, excluding IUIM Pty Ltd and Xiaoyu Zhang, paid for the acquisition of shares in [NCA]” (order 16.2). That application has been made by Grandtra which seeks an order that Mr Bai pay compensation to it and the minority shareholders it represents (the Grandtra parties) in the amount of $2 million. Grandtra seeks compensation from Mr Bai only, as Aucare is now in liquidation. Mr Bai disputes that Grandtra has any entitlement to an award of compensation from him and opposed Grandtra’s application. In issue is whether the precondition to make the application for the compensation order – ie the occurrence of “the Compensation Event” – was met and, if so, the construction and effect of order 16.2. NCA was one of eight respondents sued by the applicants arising out of a joint venture between Aucare and the fourth respondent, Noyier Dairy Pty Ltd (Noyier) (a company owned and controlled by the first respondent Yunling Huang (Ms Huang) and the second respondent, Zhixin Gu (Mr Guo)) entered into in 2013 for the construction of a milk powder manufacturing plant and the manufacture of infant milk powder for export to China. The joint venture vehicle was Australia Pure Dairy Pty Ltd (APD), the directors of which were Mr Bai (until January 2014), Mr Bai’s daughter, Ms Haolin Bai (Ms Bai), Ms Huang and Mr Guo (until January 2014). APD contracted with the third respondent, Great Vision Australia Pty Ltd (GVA), also owned and controlled by Ms Huang, to construct the factory and supply and install the necessary plant and equipment. It was a term of the joint venture contract that Aucare and Noyier were each to contribute $3 million for a total investment of $6 million. In about April 2014, after most of the plant and equipment had been delivered and installed in APD’s factory premises at Dandenong South, a dispute arose between Aucareand Noyier about their investment contributions. That dispute culminated in Ms Huang arranging for the plant and equipment installed at APD’s factory premises to be removed and re-installed in a factory at a new location at Carrum Downs. Other steps taken by Ms Huang at or around the time of removing the plant and equipment included:(a) the incorporation of four companies, all controlled by her: the fifth respondent, CFM Associates Pty Ltd (CFM), to acquire the plant and equipment from GVA; the sixth respondent, Australia Green Dairy Pty Ltd (AGD), as the lease holding company; NCA as the operating company of the infant milk powder business; and NCA’s majority shareholder, IUIM Pty Ltd (IUIM);(b) the leasing of the Carrum Downs factory by AGD;(c) the sub leasing of the Carrum Downs factory by NCA from AGD;(d) the sale of the plant and equipment by GVA to CFM (asset sale agreement); and(e) the licencing of the plant and equipment by CFM to NCA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established