Au and Le and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2020] AATA 1996 (30 June 2020)
Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION
File Number(s): 2019/1531 & 2019/1849
Re:Xuong Au and Mai Le
APPLICANT
AndRepatriation Commission
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Senior Member Linda Kirk
Date:30 June 2020
Place:Sydney
The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction in this matter and accordingly dismisses the application for review.
..............................[sgd]..........................................
Senior Member Linda Kirk
CATCHWORDS
VETERANS’ AFFAIRS – service pension – overpayment – rate of payment – obligation to notify Commission of certain event or change of circumstances – question of jurisdiction – Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review the decision – application dismissed
LEGISLATION
Social Security Act 1947 (Cth)
Social Security Act 1991 (Cth)
Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) – ss 56B, 57, 57(1)(b), 57(2), 57A, 57A(1), 57B, 205, 205(1), 205(8), 205(1A) and 175
CASES
Gault and Repatriation Commission [2016] AATA 622
Moretti and Repatriation Commission [2008] AATA 1067
Nelson and Repatriation Commission (2007) 94 ALD 418
Rayfield and Repatriation Commission [2014] AATA 772
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member Linda Kirk
30 June 2020
Mr Xuong Dich Au and his wife, Ms Mai Le (‘the Applicants’), have been in receipt of the service pension pursuant to the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (the Act) since 2009. One of the obligations imposed on them by the Act is to inform the Repatriation Commission (‘the Respondent’) of changes in their income or assets.
On 13 March 2018, the Respondent reduced the Applicants’ service pensions under section 56B of the Act with effect from 27 March 2018 following the lodgement by them of a Review of Personal and Financial Circumstances Form on 21 December 2017.[1] In this Form, the Applicants provided updates in relation to their business and employment income as well as amounts held in their superannuation and bank accounts.[2] On the same date, the Applicants were advised of this reduction to their service pensions and informed that their case was being referred for investigation of a possible overpayment.[3]
[1] T8, 86-94.
[2] T7, 70-85.
[3] T9, 95.
On 1 August 2018, a delegate of the Respondent retrospectively reduced the Applicants’ service pensions with effect from 31 October 2013 up to and including 16 July 2018 (‘the relevant period’).[4] This reduction was to reflect increases in their employment and business income and other financial and non-financial assets which the delegate found were not notified to the Respondent. Records obtained from financial institutions and the Australian Taxation Office confirmed that the Applicants’ actual account balances and business income were higher than that contained in the data held by the Respondent which had previously been provided to it by the Applicants.[5] On the same date, the Applicants were notified that a debt of $11,014.98 had been raised against each of them for the overpayment of the service pension during the relevant period.[6]
[4] T20.
[5] T20.
[6] T20, 180-185.
In an email to the Respondent dated 31 August 2018, the first named Applicant requested a review of the delegate’s decision…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Au and Le and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlement... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] AATA 1996
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it possessed the jurisdiction to review the Respondent's decisions regarding the calculation and recovery of service pension overpayments. This question hinged on the interpretation of relevant provisions within the *Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986* (Cth), specifically sections 57, 57B, and 175(2), and how they applied to decisions made by the Commission following an internal review under section 57B.
The Tribunal, applying the principles established in previous decisions, notably *Nelson and Repatriation Commission* (2007) 94 ALD 418, distinguished between two aspects of decision-making in overpayment cases. The first aspect concerns the basis for the overpayment, such as a change in the rate of pension, which is generally reviewable. The second aspect, which was the subject of the Applicants' review, relates to the calculation of the overpayment and the decision to recover the consequent debt. The Tribunal reasoned that decisions to raise and recover service pension overpayments, particularly when arising from a failure to notify of changes in circumstances, are not typically subject to internal review under section 57A or external review by the Tribunal under section 175(2). This is because such decisions are often considered self-executing and not the type of decision contemplated by section 57 for review.
Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that it lacked jurisdiction to review the Respondent's decisions concerning the calculation and recovery of the service pension overpayments. Accordingly, the application for review was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Tribunal’s power to review decisions in respect of service pensions is provided for in Part X of the Act. The general power to seek a review by the Tribunal of decisions of the Respondent is set out in s 175 of the Act. Sub-section 175(2) provides:Where the Commission, under section 57B, affirms a decision of the Commission referred to in section 57 or sets it aside and substitutes another decision for it, a person may apply to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for a review of the decision so affirmed or substituted.CONSIDERATION AND REASONS Previous Tribunal decisions have recognised two distinct aspects of the decision-making process in relation to the overpayment of a service pension. The most comprehensive outline of this distinction, and of the Tribunal's powers with respect to these two aspects, is contained in Deputy President Forgie’s decision in Nelson and Repatriation Commission (2007) 94 ALD 418 (‘Nelson’). As DP Forgie recognised in Nelson, the first aspect of the decision-making process is that which deals with the basis on which the overpayment is raised which, in this case, is a change to the rate at which service pension is paid to the Applicants. Such a decision may be the subject of review by both the Respondent and the Tribunal. The second aspect of decision-making in overpayment cases is the calculation of the overpayment and the decision to recover the consequent debt. It is this aspect of the decision-making process in relation to which the Applicants seek review by the Tribunal. In this case, there is what appears to be a decision made by the Respondent following an internal review under section 57B with respect to the calculation of the service pension overpayments and their recovery under section 205 of the Act. Whether this is an accurate description of the Respondent’s actions depends upon the interpretation of section 57B and the operation of section 57 of the Act. As outlined above, section 57 sets out the circumstances in which persons dissatisfied with decisions of the Respondent may seek a review of the decision. It lists a variety of decisions which are capable of being made the subject of an internal review. These do not include decisions to raise and recover service pension payments alleged to have been overpaid. The decisions cannot therefore be the subject of an application for internal review under s 57A, nor can they be the subject of an application to the Tribunal for a review pursuant to s 175(2) of the Act. Accordingly, the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review the overpayment decisions, including the calculation of the overpayments. This finding is consistent with earlier determinations of the Tribunal. In Nelson, DP Forgie concluded as follows in relation to overpayment decisions:In all the cases in which it was considered, the Tribunal concluded that it did not have jurisdiction to review a decision to raise and recover an overpayment. Whether it had jurisdiction to review whether the pensioner had been in breach of the notification requirements or the rate of pension that would have been payable during the relevant period is a different matter. On their face, the vast majority of the cases have decided that the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review a decision to raise and or recover an overpayment of service pension when there has been a failure to comply with an obligation to notify of certain events. In giving their reasons they have, in essence, based their conclusion on the view that s 56B is a self-executing or self-operating provision. That conclusion is the basis of their further conclusion that a decision under s 56B is not a decision of the sort described in s 57 and so cannot be a decision reviewed by the Commission under s 57B and reviewable by the Tribunal under s 175.