Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v McKellar

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v McKellar [2019] QSC 92

PARTIES:

ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(applicant)

v
ADAM CLIFFE MCKELLAR

(respondent)

FILE NO:

No 9745 of 2013

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

DELIVERED ON:

9 April 2019
Orders made 18 December 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

18 December 2018

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDER:

Orders made 18 December 2018:

THE COURT being satisfied to the requisite standard that the respondent, Adam Cliffe McKellar, has contravened requirements of the supervision order made by Justice Mullins on 24 November 2014 and amended by Justice Brown on 12 June 2017, ORDERS THAT:

1.   The respondent, Adam Cliffe McKellar, be released from custody and continue to be subject to the supervision order made by Justice Mullins on 24 November 2014 and amended by Justice Brown on 12 June 2017 with the following amendments:

(a)     amend order (1) by omitting the words “24 November 2019” currently in the order and inserting the following underlined words to read:

(1)         The respondent be subject to the following conditions until 24 November 2020.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – SENTENCE – SENTENCING ORDERS – ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS – DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDER – GENERALLY – where a supervision order was made with respect to the respondent under Division 3 of Part 2 of the Dangerous Prisoners (Sexual Offenders) Act 2003 (Qld) (‘the Act’) – where it was alleged that the respondent had contravened requirements of the supervision order – where a warrant was issued for the arrest of the respondent pursuant to the Act and the respondent was detained in custody – where the applicant sought orders with respect to the respondent under s 22 of the Act – where the contraventions were admitted by the respondent – where the applicant had not committed any further serious sexual offences – where the court considered whether the supervision order should be extended and how the extension is calculated – whether the adequate protection of the community could, despite the contravention of the order, be ensured by the existing supervision order

Dangerous Prisoners (Sexual Offenders) Act 2003 (Qld) s 3, s 5, s 13, s 13A, s 14, s 15, s 16, s 20, s 22, s 23, s 24

Attorney-General v Francis [2007] 1 Qd R 396, cited

Attorney-General v Lawrence [2010] 1 Qd R 505, cited

Attorney-General v Phineasea [2013] 1 Qd R 305, cited

Attorney-General v Van Dessel [2007] 2 Qd R 1, cited

Attorney-General v Yeatman [2019] 1 Qd R 89, cited

Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v Ellis [2012] QCA 182, cited

Attorney-General (Qld) v Fardon [2013] QCA 64, cited

Attorney-General (Qld) v Foy [2014] QSC, cited

Attorney-General (Qld) v Sands [2016] QSC 225, cited

Attorney-General (Qld) v Yeo [2008] QCA 115, cited

Fardon v Attorney-General (Qld) (2004) 223 CLR 575, cited

Kynuna v Attorney-General (Qld) [2016] QCA 172, cited

LAB vAttorney-General

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v McKellar and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v McKellar involved the respondent, Adam Cliffe McKellar, who was subject to a supervision order under Division 3 of Part 2 of the Dangerous Prisoners (Sexual Offenders) Act 2003 (Qld). The Attorney-General sought orders in relation to the respondent under section 22 of the Act, alleging that McKellar had contravened the conditions of his supervision order. McKellar admitted to the contraventions, and a warrant for his arrest was issued under the Act, resulting in his detention. The central issue before the court was whether the supervision order should be extended and, if so, how it should be calculated, considering the respondent's contraventions and the risk he posed to the community.

The court was tasked with determining whether the adequate protection of the community could be ensured by releasing McKellar back into the community under a supervision order, despite his contraventions. The legal question hinged on whether the supervision order would render the risk of McKellar committing a serious sexual offence at an acceptable level. The court considered psychiatric evidence indicating that McKellar's risk of sexual re-offence, while high, could be reduced to moderate or low with continued supervision.

The court reasoned that if the supervision order could ensure the adequate protection of the community, it should be preferred over an order for continuing detention. The court noted that the primary concern was not whether McKellar would breach the supervision order, but rather whether the risk of him committing a serious sexual offence could be managed through supervision. Based on the psychiatric evidence and the overall circumstances, the court concluded that the adequate protection of the community could indeed be ensured by releasing McKellar back into the community under the supervision order, albeit with certain amendments. Consequently, the court ordered the release of McKellar from custody and continued his supervision under the amended supervision order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Orders made 18 December 2018:

THE COURT being satisfied to the requisite standard that the respondent, Adam Cliffe McKellar, has contravened requirements of the supervision order made by Justice Mullins on 24 November 2014 and amended by Justice Brown on 12 June 2017, ORDERS THAT:

1. The respondent, Adam Cliffe McKellar, be released from custody and continue to be subject to the supervision order made by Justice Mullins on 24 November 2014 and amended by Justice Brown on 12 June 2017 with the following amendments:

(a) amend order (1) by omitting the words “24 November 2019” currently in the order and inserting the following underlined words to read:

(1) The respondent be subject to the following conditions until 24 November 2020.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue under s 22 of the Act is not whether there is an unacceptable risk that the respondent will breach the supervision order. The issue is whether there is an unacceptable risk that he will commit a serious sexual offence.[21][21] Attorney-General (Qld) v Francis [2012] QSC 275 at [64]-[67]. Background to the present application The respondent is an indigenous man who was born on 18 July 1990. He is currently 28 years of age and was 27 years old at the time of the contraventions the subject of the present application. On 19 January 2006, the respondent was convicted as a juvenile of property offences, dishonesty offences and possession of dangerous drugs in the Cunnamulla Childrens Court. He was detained but the detention was ordered to be served by way of a conditional release order.[22] [22] Criminal history: Affidavit of Kimberley Alison Thies, filed 6 September 2018, CFI 92, exhibit KAT-2 at 3. In March 2008, the respondent was convicted of one count of rape in the District Court at Beenleigh, which was committed in 2006 when he was 16 years old.[23] He was sentenced to detention for 966 days, but taking account of pre-sentence custody he was released. In July 2008, the respondent was convicted and sentenced to probation for 12 months in the Magistrates Court at Charleville for property and weapons offences and obstructing a police officer.[24] In November 2008, the respondent was convicted and sentenced to both a suspended sentence of imprisonment and a sentence of imprisonment in the Magistrates Court at Cunnamulla, with immediate release on parole for further property offences.[25] [23] At 3.[24] At 3–4.[25] At 4. On 12 March 2010, the respondent was convicted of five counts of indecent treatment of children and two counts of supplying dangerous drugs to minors. He was sentenced to a term of imprisonment on some counts and probation on others.[26] Pre-sentence custody was declared and he was released on probation on the day of sentence.[27] On 22 March 2011, the respondent was sentenced to four years’ imprisonment for break and enter and rape.[28][26] Such a sentence is open as explained in R v Hood [2005] 2 Qd R 54.[27] At 4.[28] At 4–5. It was the conviction for rape on 22 March 2011 (the index offence) which brought the respondent within the provisions of the Act. On that occasion he digitally penetrated the vagina of a sleeping woman. At the time of the commission of the offence the respondent was under the influence of some substance and the offending was opportunistic. The supervision order The Attorney-General applied for orders under the Act on 16 October 2013.[29] Margaret Wilson J made preliminary orders pursuant to s 8 of the Act for the respondent to be interviewed by psychiatrists (the s 8 application).[30] [29] Originating application, filed 16 October 2013, CFI 1.[30] Order of Margaret Wilson J, 7 November 2013, CFI 16. On the s 8 application a preliminary issue arose as to whether the respondent came within the meaning of “prisoner” in the Act.[31] It was submitted for the respondent that the offence for which he was serving a sentence (the index offence) was not a serious sexual offence because it did not involve violence.[32] Reliance was sought to be made on Attorney-General v Phineasea[33] and Tilbrook v Attorney-General[34] but that argument was unsuccessful. [31] Defined by s 5, and referred to at [2] of the reasons.[32] Outline of submissions on behalf of the respondent, filed 31 March 2014, CFI 21.[33] [2013] 1 Qd R 305.[34] [2012] QCA 279.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent pleaded guilty in the Magistrates Court at Richlands on 23 July 2018 to the contravention and to possessing methylamphetamine.[68] The Magistrates Court activated the suspended sentence imposed for the eighth contravention and sentenced the respondent to three months imprisonment for the possession of the dangerous drug methylamphetamine and five months imprisonment for the contraventions, with eligibility for parole set at 24 September 2018.[69][68] Transcript: Affidavit of Stephanie Nicole Hunter, filed 6 September 2018, CFI 100, exhibit SNH-1 at 6. [69] At 12. The psychiatric evidence In the course of the breach proceedings, evidence was obtained from two psychiatrists, Dr Andrew Aboud and Dr Scott Harden, and a psychologist Dr Michele Andrews. Dr Andrews has been treating the respondent and reported progress. She opined that the respondent could be managed in the community on a supervision order.[70] Prior to the contravention, the respondent had been coping well even though he failed to attend his appointment on 7 June 2018, about two weeks before the contravention.[71] [70] Affidavit of Michele Andrews, filed 14 November 2018, CFI 108, pages 25-26. [71] At 11–12. Dr Aboud diagnosed the respondent with Antisocial Personality Disorder with prominent psychopathic traits. He opined that the respondent also harboured emotionally unstable personality traits (fear of rejection and abandonment) and dependant personality traits with evidence to support diagnoses of alcohol dependence and cannabis abuse and more recently stimulant abuse. Dr Aboud viewed the respondent’s unmodified risk of sexual offending as between moderate and high but on a supervision order considered the risk to reduce to be between moderate and low. Dr Harden considered that the respondent met the criteria for Antisocial Personality Disorder. He thought the respondent suffered from poly substance abuse in remission because of incarceration. Dr Harden opined that the respondent may have met the criteria for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder earlier in his life but did not meet the criteria for the diagnosis at this point. As to risk, Dr Harden thought that the respondent’s future risk of sexual re-offence is high but a supervision order would decrease risk to moderate or low. Both doctors recommended release of the respondent back into the community on the supervision order.The real issue As already observed, the central question under s 22(7) of the Act is not whether there is an unacceptable risk that the respondent will breach the supervision order. Rather, the question is whether the respondent has satisfied the court that the adequate protection of the community can be ensured by releasing him back on a supervision order. In context, “adequate protection of the community” means that the supervision order renders the risk of the respondent committing a serious sexual offence at an acceptable level. As already observed, if supervision can ensure the adequate protection of the community then a supervision order ought to be preferred over an order for continuing detention.[72][72] Attorney-General v Francis [2007] 1 Qd R 396 at [39]; Attorney-General (Qld) v Yeo [2008] QCA 115; Attorney-General v Lawrence [2010] 1 Qd R 505; LAB v Attorney-General [2011] QCA 230; Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v Ellis [2012] QCA 182; Attorney-General (Qld) v Fardon [2013] QCA 64.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established