CITATION: ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR NEW SOUTH WALES v FRED FULHAM & ORS [2002] NSWSC 629 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity FILE NUMBER(S): SC 1710/2002 HEARING DATE(S): 26-28/06/2002 JUDGMENT DATE: 19 July 2002 PARTIES :
Attorney General for New South Wales - Plaintiff
Fred Fulham - First Defendant
Charles Kelly - Second Defendant
Evan Lyall Jones - Third Defendant
Peter Flaherty - Fourth Defendant
Godfrey Eugene Priest, Bruce Vanzela and John Thomas Walter Sheehan (As Trustees of the RSL Welfare and Benevolent Institution) - Fifth Defendant
Leukaemia Foundation of New South Wales Incorporated - Sixth Defendant
Sidney Philip Lindeman - Seventh Defendant
Richard James Maher - Eighth Defedant
Kevin Bryan Vance - Ninth Defendant
The Trustees of the Society of St Vincent De Paul (NSW) Incorporated - Tenth Defendant
The Australian Cancer Research Foundation - Eleventh Defendant
Remy Lam Son Bui - Twelfth DefendantJUDGMENT OF: Bryson J at 1
COUNSEL : Ms K.L. Eastman - Pltf
Mr Tudehope (s) - 1D; submitting
Ms A. Williams (s) - 2D - submitting
Mr J.C. Thompson - 3D, 7D, 8D and 9D
Peter Flaherty in Person - 4D
Mr B. Ellicott QC & Mr N. Gye - 5D
Mr R.D. Wilson - 6D
Mr G.M. McGrath - 10D
Mr R. Darke SC - 11D
Mr R.J. d'Apice (s) - 12D
Mr J. Basten QC - Centenary Institute
Ms L. Doust (s) - Vietnam Veterans AssociationSOLICITORS: I V Knight Crown Solicitor - Pltf
O'Hara & Company - 1D
Leslie Caplan & Grunstein - 2D
Connah, Steed & Co - 3, 7, 8 & 9Ds
Peter Flaherty in Person - 4D
Pricewaterhouse Coopers Legal - 5D
Tress Cocks & Maddox - 6D
Murphy & Moloney - 10D
Allens Arthur Robinson - 11D
Makinson & d'Apice - 12D
R.L. Whyburn & Associates - Vietnam Veterans Association.CATCHWORDS: CHARITIES - cy pres scheme - supervening impossibility - power under Charitable Trusts Act 1993 s.10 - Leichhardt - Lilyfield Returned Sailors, Soldiers and Airmen's Memorial Hall Building Trust - AGNSW applied for cy pres scheme where charity owned site of Leichhardt RSL Club - after litigation Club in liquidation and some of Hall Trust Trustees sold land and distributed most of funds to other charities without authority of members and without proceeding to Dissolution in accordance with Constitution - on the facts, cy pres scheme was appropriate because of supervening impossibility and also under s.10 - consideration of practicalities affecting pursuing Recipients for repayment and then distributing according to a scheme devised by the Court - consideration of positions of trustees and other persons related to the Hall Trust - consideration of merits and claims of Recipients and of other charities which intervened - notwithstanding many considerations against doing so, the practicalities favoured adopting a cy pres scheme which in effect ratified the unauthorised distributions which had been made. LEGISLATION CITED: Charitable Trusts Act 1993
Charitable Collections Act 1934
Charitable Fundraising Act 1991
Trustee Act 1925CASES CITED: Attorney-General v Sherborne Grammar School (1854) 18 Beavan 256
Attorney-General for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney General for New South Wales v Fulham and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2002] NSWSC 629
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In Attorney General for New South Wales v Fulham, the dispute involved the Leichhardt-Lilyfield Returned Sailors, Soldiers and Airmen's Memorial Hall Building Trust and the Attorney General for New South Wales. The core of the dispute was the management and disposition of the assets of the Trust, particularly the site of the Leichhardt RSL Club, following the club's liquidation. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
The central legal issues before the Court were whether a cy pres scheme should be implemented for the Trust's assets and whether the Court could ratify the unauthorized distributions made by some of the Trustees to other charities. The Court had to determine if the supervening impossibility of pursuing the original charitable purpose justified the adoption of a cy pres scheme and if the Trustees' actions were permissible under the provisions of the Charitable Trusts Act 1993.
The Court held that a cy pres scheme was appropriate given the supervening impossibility of achieving the original charitable purpose due to the liquidation of the RSL Club. The Court also found that the Trustees had the power under section 10 of the Act to implement a cy pres scheme. Considering the practicalities of pursuing repayment from the recipients and redistributing the funds, the Court concluded that the best course of action was to adopt a cy pres scheme. This decision effectively ratified the unauthorized distributions made by the Trustees, taking into account the positions of the Trustees, related parties, and the merits of the claims from the recipients and other intervening charities.
The Court issued a cy pres scheme that authorised the distribution of the Trust's assets to other charities, effectively ratifying the unauthorized distributions previously made by the Trustees. The scheme was designed to ensure that the funds would be used for purposes that were as close as possible to the original charitable intent of the Trust.
The central legal issues before the Court were whether a cy pres scheme should be implemented for the Trust's assets and whether the Court could ratify the unauthorized distributions made by some of the Trustees to other charities. The Court had to determine if the supervening impossibility of pursuing the original charitable purpose justified the adoption of a cy pres scheme and if the Trustees' actions were permissible under the provisions of the Charitable Trusts Act 1993.
The Court held that a cy pres scheme was appropriate given the supervening impossibility of achieving the original charitable purpose due to the liquidation of the RSL Club. The Court also found that the Trustees had the power under section 10 of the Act to implement a cy pres scheme. Considering the practicalities of pursuing repayment from the recipients and redistributing the funds, the Court concluded that the best course of action was to adopt a cy pres scheme. This decision effectively ratified the unauthorized distributions made by the Trustees, taking into account the positions of the Trustees, related parties, and the merits of the claims from the recipients and other intervening charities.
The Court issued a cy pres scheme that authorised the distribution of the Trust's assets to other charities, effectively ratifying the unauthorized distributions previously made by the Trustees. The scheme was designed to ensure that the funds would be used for purposes that were as close as possible to the original charitable intent of the Trust.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi