Attorney-General (Cth) v Colonial Sugar Refining Company Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
17 CLR 644

from June 1873 to December 1909 may be stated as follows:--- The subsidy has amounted to £183,409, of which £115,684 has been carried to profit and loss account and £67,725 to reserve account. The profit and loss account for the whole period shows a net loss of £321. In the period before the subsidy commenced there was a profit amounting to nearly £1,500. In the period Co. (LTD.)

during which the subsidy was discontinued there were losses amounting to £18,200 or thereabouts. In other years there has sometimes been a considerable profit in addition to the subsidy, and sometimes a heavy loss notwithstanding the subsidy. The Company has never paid a dividend even in the most prosperous years, it being feared that if they did SO the continuance of the subsidy might be jeopardized. The reserve has been employed in extending the Company's business.

The majority of the Company's shareholders are and have always been graziers who derive an indirect benefit from the Company's operations. There are, however, and apparently always have been, shareholders who are not graziers, and whose interest is that the Company should earn and pay dividends. The appellant in the present proceedings is one of such last- mentioned shareholders, and his case against the Company and its directors is that the business of the Company is not being carried on with a view to earning dividends for distribution among its shareholders, but with a view to keeping up the price of sheep for the benefit of such members of the Company as are graziers. He asks for a declaration that the Company and its directors are not entitled SO to carry on the Company's business, and for an injunction on the footing of such declaration.

The first question which their Lordships have to determine is, therefore, a question of fact. Has the business of the Company been carried on, and is it being carried on, not with a view to earning dividends for the shareholders generally but in order to benefit indirectly such of its shareholders as are graziers ? Are the interests of the shareholders, as such, being sacrified for the indirect benefit of such of them as desire to keep up the price of stock ?

The plaintiff relies chiefly on certain circulars and letters sent out by the Company to graziers and stock agents, and certain

17 CLR 645

advertisements published in the local papers. These circulars, letters, and advertisements state, either expressly or by implica- tion, that the primary object of this Company is not to earn profit for division among the shareholders in dividends, but to relieve the fat stock market in times of glut-in other words, to keep up the price of stock.

Further, the directors, in their reports to the shareholders, frequently refer to the Company's operations as having contri- buted to the maintenance of the high values of stock or prevented a serious fall in prices.

On the other hand, the defendants at the trial…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General (Cth) v Colonial Sugar Refining Company Lim... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1913] UKPCHCA 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case, Attorney-General (Cth) v Colonial Sugar Refining Company Limited, involved a dispute regarding the validity of the Royal Commissions Act 1902-1912. The Attorney-General for the Commonwealth sought to compel the Colonial Sugar Refining Company Limited and its directors to comply with a Royal Commission's demands for information. The legal issues centered on whether the Royal Commissions Acts were ultra vires the Commonwealth Parliament and whether the Royal Commission could compel answers to questions or order the production of documents.

The court examined the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Australia, particularly sections 51, 107, and 128. It concluded that the Royal Commissions Acts were ultra vires the Commonwealth Parliament and void insofar as they purported to enable a Royal Commission to compel answers generally to questions or to order the production of documents. The court found that the Commonwealth Parliament did not possess the power to legislate for the purpose of obtaining information on existing matters which might form the subject of amendments to the Constitution. The court also determined that the Royal Commissions Acts did not extend to inquiry into the internal or domestic management of the affairs of a company created under State laws.

As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the High Court was varied. The respondents were not bound to attend the meetings of the Commission or give evidence or produce documents. This ruling clarified the limits of the Commonwealth Parliament's powers and emphasized the importance of adhering to the federal principle established by the Australian Constitution.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established