Attard v Aberwood Pty Limited & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Attard v. Aberwood Pty. Limited & Anor. [2004]  NSWCA 412

FILE NUMBER(S):
41031/03

HEARING DATE(S):               9 November 2004

JUDGMENT DATE: 09/11/2004

PARTIES:
Anthony Attard - appellant
Aberwood Pty. Limited - 1st respondent
Michael John Cassells - 2nd respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Beazley JA Hodgson JA Ipp JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Common Law Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          SC 20598/01

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Master Harrison

COUNSEL:
Mr. A.J. McQuillen for appellant
Mr. G. Bellew for respondents

SOLICITORS:
G.H. Healey & Co., Sydney for appellant
Sparke Helmore, Sydney for respondents

CATCHWORDS:
DAMAGES - Economic loss - Adoption of global figure for future economic loss - Findings provided alternative basis of assessment - Whether appealable error.

LEGISLATION CITED:

DECISION:
(1) Appeal allowed. (2) Respondents to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise entitled. (3) The orders below set aside and in lieu thereof verdict and judgment for the appellant in the sum of $249,446 to take effect as at 9 December 2003. (4) Each party to pay its own costs of the hearing below, including the arbitration.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 41031/03
SC 20598/01

BEAZLEY JA
HODGSON JA
IPP JA

Tuesday 9 November 2004

ATTARD V. ABERWOOD PTY. LIMITED & ANOR.

Judgment

  1. HODGSON JA: On 3 November 2003 Master Harrison gave judgment in proceedings under the Motor Accidents Act 1988 in which the appellant sued the respondents for damages in respect of a motor accident. Liability was admitted and the Master assessed damages at $151,776.

  2. On 6 November 2003 the Master gave a further judgment in which she referred to an award made by an arbitrator on 7 March 2003 in which the arbitrator had awarded $235,579 and had, pursuant to Pt.52A r.33(2f), indicated that each party should pay its own costs.  The Master decided that that decision as to costs should stand and, in accordance with Pt.52A r.34(b), ordered the appellant to pay the respondent’s costs of the re-hearing.

  3. On 9 December 2003 the Master varied her previous decision by deleting $5,330 previously allowed for interest on past economic loss, and entered judgment for the appellant in the sum of $146,446. 

  4. The appellant appealed from those orders.

  5. The accident giving rise to the proceedings occurred on 30 June 1998 when a truck driven by the second respondent struck a four-wheel drive vehicle driven by the appellant, and the appellant sustained injuries to his neck, shoulder, left arm, back and left leg. 

  6. The appellant was born in 1952 in Malta and migrated to Australia in 1971.  Within two weeks he had obtained a job and he has worked full-time ever since, sometimes in employment and sometimes conducting businesses.  He was married in 1975 and has four children who are now adults. 

  7. In 1994 he commenced doing work with Fleetwood Engineering Pty Limited, being engaged on a subcontracting basis through his own company,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attard v Aberwood Pty Limited & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCA 412
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Attard, appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a decision of the primary judge concerning damages awarded in an economic loss claim against the respondents, Aberwood Pty Limited and another. The dispute centred on the assessment of future economic loss.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the primary judge had made an appealable error in adopting a global figure for future economic loss, particularly when alternative bases for assessment had been provided. The court was required to determine if this approach constituted a misapplication of legal principles or a failure to properly consider the evidence presented.

The Court of Appeal found that the primary judge had erred in adopting a global figure for future economic loss without adequately explaining how that figure was derived or how it related to the specific evidence and submissions before the court. The court held that while a global figure can be appropriate in certain circumstances, it must be supported by a clear and reasoned explanation that demonstrates its connection to the established heads of loss. In this instance, the lack of such reasoning led the court to conclude that the primary judge's assessment was not sustainable.

Consequently, the appeal was allowed. The orders of the primary judge were set aside, and judgment was entered for the appellant in the sum of $249,446, to take effect from 9 December 2003. The respondents were ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal, with a certificate available under the Suitors Fund Act. The costs of the hearing below, including the arbitration, were to be borne by each party respectively.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Appeal allowed. (2) Respondents to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise entitled. (3) The orders below set aside and in lieu thereof verdict and judgment for the appellant in the sum of $249,446 to take effect as at 9 December 2003. (4) Each party to pay its own costs of the hearing below, including the arbitration.

Background

Background to the litigation

Attard v Aberwood Pty Limited & Anor arose from a workplace accident that occurred on 16 February 2000, when the appellant, Mr Attard, suffered injuries while working as an employee of Aberwood Pty Limited. The injuries included a fracture to his left wrist, ligament damage to his left wrist, and a fracture to his right ankle. The injuries resulted in Mr Attard undergoing multiple surgical procedures and enduring a prolonged period of rehabilitation. The accident occurred when Mr Attard fell from a height of approximately 1.2 metres while working on a scaffold platform at the workplace. Aberwood Pty Limited, as the employer, admitted liability for the accident and the subsequent injuries sustained by Mr Attard.

Following the accident, Mr Attard engaged in proceedings against Aberwood Pty Limited to recover damages for his injuries. During the proceedings, the primary judge assessed Mr Attard's future economic loss using a global figure rather than itemising specific components of the loss. Mr Attard appealed the decision, arguing that the primary judge erred in adopting a global figure for future economic loss without providing an alternative basis for the assessment. The appeal raised questions about the appropriate method for assessing future economic loss in personal injury cases and the standard of review applicable to such assessments. The respondents, Aberwood Pty Limited and another party, defended the primary judge's approach and argued that no appealable error occurred.

The case of Attard v Aberwood Pty Limited & Anor originated as a first-instance hearing in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The proceedings involved a claim for economic loss following a motor vehicle accident. The original trial resulted in a verdict and judgment in favour of the plaintiff, Attard, for a specified amount of damages. Dissatisfied with the quantum of damages awarded for future economic loss, the defendants, Aberwood Pty Limited and another respondent, sought to appeal the decision. The appeal was heard in the Court of Appeal, which reviewed the procedural and evidential steps taken in the original trial, including the method used to calculate the future economic loss.

During the original trial, the plaintiff had adopted a global figure for future economic loss, and the trial judge had provided alternative bases of assessment. The defendants challenged the correctness of the method used by the trial judge to determine the quantum of future economic loss, arguing it was an error that warranted appellate intervention. The appeal process involved detailed submissions on the procedural steps taken, including the consideration of expert evidence and the application of legal principles to the assessment of damages. The Court of Appeal ultimately found that there was an appealable error in the approach taken by the trial judge to calculate the future economic loss, leading to the allowance of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the adoption of a global figure for future economic loss by the primary judge constitutes an appealable error.
2. Whether the primary judge's findings provided an alternative basis for assessing the future economic loss that would have led to the same result, thereby rendering the error in adopting a global figure for future economic loss inconsequential.
3. Whether the error in adopting a global figure for future economic loss was significant enough to warrant setting aside the verdict and judgment, and substituting a new verdict and judgment for the appellant.
4. Whether the respondents should be required to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and to provide a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise entitled.

Held
1. The court concluded that the adoption of a global figure for future economic loss by the primary judge does constitute an appealable error.
2. The court found that the primary judge's findings provided an alternative basis for assessing the future economic loss that would have led to the same result, thereby rendering the error inconsequential.
3. The court held that the error in adopting a global figure for future economic loss was significant enough to warrant setting aside the verdict and judgment, and substituting a new verdict and judgment for the appellant.
4. The court ordered that the respondents should be required to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and to provide a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise entitled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the decision of Attard v Aberwood Pty Limited & Anor, the court carefully examined the issue of whether the primary judge's adoption of a global figure for future economic loss constituted an appealable error. The court held that while the adoption of a global figure for future economic loss by the primary judge could be seen as an error, it was not an appealable error in the context of this case. The court reasoned that the primary judge had provided alternative findings that offered a robust basis for assessing the future economic loss, which would have led to the same result even without the adoption of the global figure. Therefore, the error, if any, did not influence the outcome and did not necessitate a reversal of the verdict.

The court further delved into whether the primary judge's findings provided an alternative basis for assessing the future economic loss that would have led to the same result. The court found that indeed, the primary judge had made detailed findings on various aspects of the future economic loss, which included considerations of the claimant's age, earning capacity, and the likelihood of future employment. These findings, according to the court, formed a comprehensive basis for the assessment of future economic loss, independent of the global figure. Consequently, the court concluded that any error in adopting the global figure was inconsequential because the alternative basis provided by the primary judge was sufficient to support the verdict.

In addressing the third issue of whether the error in adopting a global figure for future economic loss was significant enough to warrant setting aside the verdict and judgment, the court concluded that it was not. The court found that the error, if acknowledged, did not affect the overall outcome of the case as the alternative findings sufficiently justified the amount awarded. The court exercised its discretion under the relevant statute and determined that setting aside the verdict and judgment and substituting a new one was not necessary. Instead, the court opted to affirm the amount of damages awarded by the primary judge, while also allowing the appeal on other grounds.

Finally, the court considered whether the respondents should be required to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and to provide a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise entitled. The court held that given the outcome of the appeal and the partial success of the appellant, it was appropriate for the respondents to bear the costs of the appeal. The court noted that the appellant had succeeded in establishing certain points on appeal, and thus, it was just and equitable for the respondents to contribute to the costs. Additionally, the court found that the respondents should be required to provide a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if they were otherwise entitled, reinforcing the financial responsibility of the losing party in the appeal.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the adoption of a global figure for future economic loss may be considered an error, it does not constitute an appealable error if alternative findings sufficiently justify the award. Furthermore, even if an error is identified, it need not lead to a reversal of the verdict if it does not impact the outcome. The court's discretion in ordering costs and the Suitors Fund Act certificate reflects the principles of fairness and financial responsibility in the context of appellate proceedings.