Atlen P/L v Building Insurers' Guarantee Corp

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Atlen P/L v Building Insurers' Guarantee Corp. [2005]  NSWCA 105

FILE NUMBER(S):
40299/04

HEARING DATE(S):               16 February 2005

JUDGMENT DATE: 07/04/2005

PARTIES:
Atlen Pty Limited
Building Insurers' Guarantee Corporation

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Tobias JA Campbell AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          ED 4306/02

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Brownie A-J

COUNSEL:
A: S Epstein SC
R: T Lynch

SOLICITORS:
A: Gadens, Sydney
R: McLachlan Chilton, Sydney

CATCHWORDS:
CONTRACT FOR INSURANCE - compulsory insurance in relation to residential building under the Home Building Act 1989 - Pt 6A (insolvent insurer)   - head contractor's right to indemnity from respondent (Building Insurer's Guarantee Corporation) under Pt 6A after subcontractor abandoned performance of subcontract and subcontractor's insurer became insolvent  - whether a subcontractor required under Part 6 to enter into contract of insurance for benefit of head contractor - whether respondent bound to stand behind insolvent subcontractor's failed insurer - statutory interpretation

LEGISLATION CITED:
Home Building Act 1989
Corporations Law
Home Building Regulation 1997

DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40299/2004
ED 4306/2002

MASON P
TOBIAS JA
CAMPBELL AJA

Thursday 7 April 2005

ATLEN PTY LIMITED v BUILDING INSURERS’ GUARANTEE CORPORATION

JUDGMENT

  1. MASON P:           The Home Building Act 1989 contains in Part 6 a scheme of compulsory insurance in relation to residential building work. The risk covered is loss in various forms caused by the insolvency, death or disappearance of a building contractor. In 2001 Part 6A was added to address the problem of insurers who themselves became insolvent. Persons entitled to recover under a contract of insurance entered into under Part 6 could seek indemnity from a State body called the Building Insurers’ Guarantee Corporation (BIGC) if the insurer itself became insolvent.

  2. The appellant claims against BIGC, invoking Part 6A.  It contends that it is the beneficiary under a policy of insurance entered into by its subcontractor, Horvat Constructions Pty Ltd (Horvat).  Horvat abandoned performance of the subcontract in consequence of its insolvency, causing the appellant loss.  Horvat had an insurance policy with FAI Insurance.  There is a dispute as to whether that FAI policy responds in relation to the loss suffered by the appellant in consequence of Horvat’s insolvency.  There is a further dispute as to whether BIGC is bound to stand behind FAI Insurance, in consequence of FAI’s subsequent insolvency.  The former dispute turns mainly on the construction of Horvat’s Policy, albeit that the Policy needs to be construed against the background of the Act to which it refers.  The latter dispute concerns the scope of the Act itself, most notably s103I.

  3. A brief chronology sets the scene:

    •On 29 December 1998 FAI issued Horvat with a Master Home Warranty Annual Blanket ‘Extra’ Cover (Full 7 Year Warranty) Insurance Policy in respect of building contracts to be entered into by Horvat over the next 12 months. Horvat’s Policy complies with the requirements of Part…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Atlen P/L v Building Insurers' Guarantee Corp and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a claim by Atlen Pty Ltd (the appellant) for indemnity from the Building Insurers' Guarantee Corporation (BIGC, the respondent) under Part 6A of the *Home Building Act 1989* (NSW). The dispute arose after a subcontractor abandoned performance of a subcontract, and the subcontractor's insurer became insolvent. The appellant sought to be indemnified by BIGC, arguing it was entitled to stand behind the insolvent subcontractor's insurer. The Supreme Court had previously dismissed the appellant's proceedings against BIGC and the State of New South Wales.

The central legal issues before the court were whether a subcontractor was required by Part 6 of the *Home Building Act 1989* to enter into a contract of insurance for the benefit of the head contractor, and consequently, whether the respondent, BIGC, was bound to provide an indemnity in relation to the insolvent subcontractor's failed insurer. The court was required to interpret the provisions of Part 6 and Part 6A of the Act, particularly concerning the scope of compulsory insurance and the conditions for indemnity from BIGC.

The court reasoned that the *Home Building Act 1989* mandated that a contract of insurance in relation to residential building work must insure the person on whose behalf the work is being done against specific risks, including non-completion due to the contractor's insolvency or death, and loss arising from a breach of statutory warranty. While the appellant had complied with its obligations under s92 by obtaining its own insurance policy, the present litigation did not involve rights under that policy. Instead, the appellant sought indemnity under Part 6A based on the subcontractor's policy. However, s103I(2)(a) of the Act explicitly states that "the builder to which the policy relates is not entitled to the indemnity," which precluded the appellant from claiming indemnity under the subcontractor's policy.

The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appellant’s claim for indemnity under Part 6A from BIGC was rejected. Proceedings challenging this rejection were filed in the Supreme Court, joining BIGC and the State of New South Wales as defendants. The ensuing judgment for the defendants with costs (see Atlen Pty Ltd v Building Insurers’ Guarantee Corporation & Anor [2004] NSWSC 195) is the order under appeal. The legislative history and scheme of Part 6 of the Home Building Act 1989 are discussed in Festa Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor v Additon & Ors [2004] NSWCA 228 at [22]ff. At the inception of both the head contract and the subcontract in the present case, s92(1) spoke to both sets of contracting parties in unqualified terms, prohibiting them from contracting to do any residential building work unless a contract of insurance that complied with the Act was in force “in relation to the proposed work”. There was a linked obligation to attach a certificate of insurance to the contract (s92(2)). The form and scope of the requisite insurance contract were spelt out in ss99 and 102 of the Act and Part 5 of the Home Building Regulation 1997. Section 99 provided at the time:Requirements for insurance for residential building workA contract of insurance in relation to residential building work required by section 92 must insure:(a)a person on whose behalf the work is being done against the risk of loss resulting from non-completion of the work because of the insolvency or death of the contractor or because of the fact that, after due search and inquiry, the contractor cannot be found, and(b)a person on whose behalf the work is being done and the person’s successors in title against the risk of loss arising from a breach of a statutory warranty in respect of the work. It is accepted that the appellant complied with its obligations under s92 by obtaining the HIH policy and attaching a certificate of insurance to its head contract with Developmentlink. As indicated, that certificate named Developmentlink as the “beneficiary” and recorded that the Policy gave cover to that beneficiary and its successors in title. The legislative origin of this stipulation was s99(1)(b) of the Act and cll 42 and 43 of the Regulation. However, the present litigation does not involve an attempt to invoke rights under the appellant’s HIH Policy. HIH is itself insolvent. The appellant wants access to BIGC’s indemnity on the basis of being within the cover of its subcontractor’s (ie Horvat’s) FAI Policy. So far as relevant, s103I (which is in Part 6A) provides:Indemnity(1) Subject to this Part, the State must indemnify any person:(a)who is entitled to recover an amount under a contract of insurance entered into under Part 6 in connection with any matter, and(b)who is covered by an insolvent insurer’s policy,to the extent of the amount that the person is entitled to recover under that policy in connection with that matter.(2)The following provisions apply to that indemnity:(a)the builder to which the policy relates is not entitled to the indemnity,….