ATIOLA (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

ATIOLA (Migration) [2017] AATA 1032 (23 June 2017)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Mr Alifeleti Atiola

CASE NUMBER:  1513787

DIBP REFERENCE(S):  CLF2015/64703

MEMBER:Katie Malyon

DATE:23 June 2017

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Temporary Work (Long Stay Activity) (Class GB) visa.

Statement made on 23 June 2017 at 10:34 am

Migration Act 1958, ss 65, 351

Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2, cl 401.211(b)(ii), Schedule 3, Criterion 3004

CASES
Su & Ors v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2007] FMCA 318
Secretary, Department of Social Security v Secara & Ors (1998) 89 FCR 151

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration on 21 September 2015 to refuse to grant the visa applicant, Mr Alifeleti Atiola, a Temporary Work (Long Stay Activity) (Class GB) visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. Mr Atiola applied for the visa on 3 August 2015. At the time of application, Class GB contained one Subclass: Subclass 401 (Temporary Work (Long Stay Activity)). The criteria for a Subclass 401 visa are set out in Part 401 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations).  Applicants seeking to satisfy the primary criteria must meet the ‘Common criteria’ as well as the criteria of one of the 4 alternative visa streams: the Exchange stream; the Sport stream; the Religious Worker stream; or, the Domestic Worker (Executive) stream.  

  3. In the present case, Mr Atiola is seeking the visa in the Sport stream. This stream enables the entry of sportspersons to participate in sporting activities or engage in competition with Australian residents. The delegate refused to grant the visa because Mr Atiola did not meet cl.401.211(b)(ii) of Schedule 2 to the Regulations as he did not meet criterion 3004 of Schedule 3. Essentially, the delegate was not satisfied that Mr Atiola’s delay in lodging his visa application until more than 2½ months after expiry of his first Subclass 401 visa was due to factors beyond his control.

  4. Mr Atiola appeared before the Tribunal on 27 February 2017 to give evidence and present arguments.  The Tribunal also received oral evidence from Mr Brian Macauley, the current President of Woy Woy Rugby Club (the Club).  The Club is Mr Atiola’s sponsor for his Subclass 401 visa.  The Tribunal also received oral evidence from Mr Stuart McGoldrick, now the Club’s Secretary and a former President of the Club.   

  5. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.

    CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

  6. Departmental records show that the last substantive visa held by Mr Atiola was a Subclass 401 visa sponsored by the Club.  That Subclass 401 visa ceased on 9 May 2015.  When Mr Atiola lodged his application for a further Subclass 401 visa on 3 August 2015 his former…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ATIOLA (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1032
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Atiola against the Tribunal's decision to affirm the refusal of his application for a Temporary Work (Long Stay Activity) (Class GB) visa, Subclass 401 (Sport stream). Mr Atiola had lodged his application after his previous substantive visa had expired, rendering him an unlawful non-citizen at the time of application. The central dispute revolved around whether Mr Atiola met the Schedule 3 criteria, specifically criterion 3004, which is a prerequisite for applicants who do not hold a substantive visa at the time of their application.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr Atiola satisfied Schedule 3 criteria 3002, 3003, 3004, and 3005, as mandated by clause 401.211(b) of Schedule 2 of the Migration Regulations 1994. The primary focus of the Tribunal's assessment was criterion 3004, which requires the Minister to be satisfied that the applicant is not holding a substantive visa due to factors beyond their control, that there are compelling reasons for granting the visa, and that the applicant has substantially complied with visa conditions.

The Tribunal found that while Mr Atiola relied on his sponsoring club to lodge his visa application, this reliance was not a factor beyond his control. Despite the club's assurances and subsequent acknowledgement of its failings, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Atiola was aware of the need to lodge a new visa application before his existing one expired and could have taken steps to verify lodgement, such as contacting the Department or seeking professional advice. Therefore, criterion 3004 was not satisfied. Although the Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the Subclass 401 visa, it noted that the Schedule 3 criteria could be waived for a pending Partner Subclass 820 visa application if compelling reasons were demonstrated, and indicated that such documentation would likely be provided.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Departmental records show that the last substantive visa held by Mr Atiola was a Subclass 401 visa sponsored by the Club. That Subclass 401 visa ceased on 9 May 2015. When Mr Atiola lodged his application for a further Subclass 401 visa on 3 August 2015 his former substantive visa had already expired and he had been an unlawful non-citizen for just over 2½ months. The issue in this case is whether Mr Atiola satisfies Schedule 3 and thereby meets cl.401.211 of Schedule 2 of the Regulations.Schedule 3 criteria A Subclass 401 visa applicant who is not the holder of a substantive visa at the time of application must meet 2 requirements in order to satisfy cl.401.211 of Schedule 2 of the Regulations. Firstly, the last substantive temporary visa held by the applicant must not be one of the visas set out in cl.401.211(a) of Schedule 2 of the Regulations. Secondly, they must satisfy Schedule 3 criteria 3002, 3003, 3004 and 3005 of the Regulations: cl.401.211(b) of Schedule 2. It is not in dispute that Mr Atiola did not hold a substantive visa at the time of application. Based on the evidence before it, the Tribunal is satisfied that the last substantive visa held by Mr Atiola was not one of those mentioned in cl.401.211(a) of Schedule 2 of the Regulations. Accordingly, the Tribunal has considered whether Mr Atiola satisfies Schedule 3 criteria 3002, 3003, 3004 and 3005. These criteria are set out in the Attachment to this decision. Criterion 3002 is met because the visa application was lodged within 12 months of Mr Atiola’s period of stay that expired on 9 May 2015. Criterion 3003 applies only to applicants who have not, on or after 1 September 1994, held a substantive visa and on 31 August 1994 was either an illegal entrant or the holder of an entry permit that was not valid beyond that date. The Tribunal is satisfied that Mr Atiola was not such a person and, accordingly, criterion 3003 does not apply. Criterion 3005 prevents a repeated reliance on Schedule 3 criteria for a visa grant if an applicant does not hold a substantive visa. There is no evidence Mr Atiola has previously relied on Schedule 3 criterion and so criterion 3005 is not applicable in relation to him. Criterion 3004 Criterion 3004 applies to applicants who ceased to hold a substantive or criminal justice visa on or after 1 September 1994, or who entered Australia unlawfully on or after 1 September 1994 and have not subsequently been granted a substantive visa. It requires that the Minister be satisfied that the applicant is not the holder of a substantive visa because of factors beyond his or her control, that there are compelling reasons for granting the visa, and that the applicant has complied substantially with the conditions applicable to the last of any substantive visas and any subsequent bridging visa held by the applicant (emphasis added). In addition, the Minister must be satisfied that: the applicant would have been able to be granted the visa if the applicant had applied on the day he or she last held a substantive or criminal justice visa, or would have satisfied the criteria when he or she last entered Australia unlawfully: the applicant intends to comply with any conditions of the visa; and, if the last visa held (if any) by the applicant was a transitional (temporary) visa, that visa was not subject to a condition that the holder would not, after entering Australia, be entitled to be granted an entry permit, or further entry permit, while the holder remained in Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Whilst in connection with Mr Atiola’s Subclass 401 visa application this Tribunal has found that he does not satisfy criterion 3004 of Schedule 3 to the Regulations, the Tribunal notes that, although the same criterion must be met by an applicant for a Partner Subclass 820 visa, the Regulations nonetheless provide for a waiver of this requirement in circumstances where the Minister is satisfied that there are compelling reasons for not applying those criteria: cl.820.211(2)(d)(ii) of Part 820 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations. The Tribunal is satisfied that Mr Atiola, his wife and the Club will provide to the Department requisite documentation to address the compelling reasons why Mr Atiola’s failure to meet criterion 3004 should be waived in the context of his Subclass 820 visa application. In this regard, the Tribunal notes Mr Macauley’s signed statement on behalf of the Club referred to above as well as the letters in support from Australian Rugby Union Limited, Tonga Rugby Union and other supporters referred to in paras [18] and [19] above. Mr Macauley, in particular, observes in his statement that Mr Atiola has:·added great value to the Club - he has helped bring it back from folding (that is, being wound up) to a vibrant community-based club; ·proactively been involved with junior schools’ clinics where use of his skill sets and willingness to participate has increased numbers and made for a more enjoyable participation in games for the juniors; ·attracted the local Polynesian community including rugby players;·through his activities, resulted in the Club has become stronger and more successful thereby attracting sponsors and new committee members. Mr Atiola’s activities have resulted in one sponsor donating a 22 seat bus to the Club. It is used for both seniors and juniors. Subsequently, the Club has allowed the local surf club (Ocean Beach Surf Club) and other community groups access to its bus for the wider community. ·been involved in activities that have resulted in the Club becoming more than just a rugby club. By way of example, the Club now reaches out to a wider local community and to underprivileged children offering a joint scholarship with the KARI for Year 12 students at the local Woy Woy high school.[4] KARI is an aboriginal service provider, supporting indigenous families and communities through foster care, child and youth programs, education and family support; and, ·had a positive impact as a role model on youth who might otherwise analyse or graffiti community property by giving them a role model to aspire to.[4] >In the context of Mr Atiola’s pending Subclass 820 visa application and having regard to the Ministerial Guidelines referred to above, the Tribunal is satisfied that this is not an appropriate case to refer to the Minister. DECISIONThe Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Temporary Work (Long Stay Activity) (Class GB) visa.Katie MalyonMemberATTACHMENT- Extracts from the Migration Regulations 1994Schedule 2 - Provisions with respect to the grant of some classes of visas Subclass 401 - Temporary Work (Long Stay Activity)401.211 If the applicant was in Australia at the time of application: (a) at that time, the applicant held a substantive temporary visa that was not: (i) a Subclass 403 (Temporary Work (International Relations)) visa in the Domestic Worker (Diplomatic or Consular) stream; (ii) a Subclass 426 (Domestic Worker (Temporary) - Diplomatic or Consular) visa; or (iii) a Subclass 771 (Transit) visa; or (iv) a special purpose visa; or (b) if the applicant did not hold a substantive visa at that time: (i) the last substantive temporary visa held by the applicant was not a visa mentioned in paragraph (a); and (ii) the applicant satisfies Schedule 3 criteria 3002, 3003, 3004 and 3005.Schedule 3 - Additional criteria applicable to unlawfully non-citizens and certain bridging visa holders3001(1) The application is validly made within 28 days after the relevant day (within the meaning of subclause (2)). (2)For the purposes of subclause (1) and of clause 3002, the relevant day, in relation to an applicant, is: (a) if the applicant held an entry permit that was valid up to and including 31 August 1994 but has not subsequently been the holder of a substantive visa—1 September 1994; or (b) if the applicant became an illegal entrant before 1 September 1994 (whether or not clause 6002 in Schedule 6 of the Migration (1993) Regulations applied or section 195 of the Act applies) and has not, at any time on or after 1 September 1994, been the holder of a substantive visa—the day when the applicant last became an illegal entrant; or (c) if the applicant: (i)ceased to hold a substantive or criminal justice visa on or after 1 September 1994; or (ii)entered Australia unlawfully on or after 1 September 1994; whichever is the later of: (iii)the last day when the applicant held a substantive or criminal justice visa; or (iv)the day when the applicant last entered Australia unlawfully; or (d) if the last substantive visa held by the applicant was cancelled, and the Tribunal has made a decision to set aside and substitute the cancellation decision or the Minister’s decision not to revoke the cancellation—the later of:(i)the day when that last substantive visa ceased to be in effect; and(ii)the day when the applicant is taken, under sections 368C, 368D and 379C of the Act, to have been notified of the Tribunal’s decision.3002The application is validly made within 12 months after the relevant day (within the meaning of subclause 3001(2)).3003If: (a) the applicant has not, on or after 1 September 1994, been the holder of a substantive visa; and (b) on 31 August 1994, the applicant was either: (i)an illegal entrant; or (ii)the holder of an entry permit that was not valid beyond 31 August 1994; the Minister is satisfied that: (c) the applicant last became an illegal entrant, or, in the case of a person referred to in subparagraph (b)(ii), last became a person in Australia without a substantive visa, because of factors beyond the applicant’s control; and (d) there are compelling reasons for granting the visa; and (e) the applicant has complied substantially with the conditions that apply or applied to:(i)the last of any entry permits held by the applicant (other than a condition of which the applicant was in breach solely because of the expiry of the entry permit); and(ii)any subsequent bridging visa; and(f) the applicant would have been entitled to be granted an entry permit equivalent to a visa of the class applied for if the applicant had applied for the entry permit immediately before last becoming an illegal entrant or, in the case of a person referred to in subparagraph (b)(ii), if the applicant had applied for the entry permit on 31 August 1994; and (g) the applicant intends to comply with any conditions subject to which the visa is granted; and (h) the last entry permit (if any) held by the applicant was not granted subject to a condition that the holder would not, after entering Australia, be entitled to be granted an entry permit, or a further entry permit, while the holder remained in Australia. 3004If the applicant: (a) ceased to hold a substantive or criminal justice visa on or after 1 September 1994; or (b) entered Australia unlawfully on or after 1 September 1994 and has not subsequently been granted a substantive visa; the Minister is satisfied that: (c) the applicant is not the holder of a substantive visa because of factors beyond the applicant’s control; and (d) there are compelling reasons for granting the visa; and (e) the applicant has complied substantially with:(i)the conditions that apply or applied to:(A)the last of any entry permits held by the applicant (other than a condition of which the applicant was in breach solely because of the expiry of the entry permit); and(B)any subsequent bridging visa; or(ii)the conditions that apply or applied to:(A)the last of any substantive visas held by the applicant (other than a condition of which the applicant was in breach solely because the visa ceased to be in effect); and(B)any subsequent bridging visa; and(f) either: (i)in the case of an applicant referred to in paragraph (a)—the applicant would have been entitled to be granted a visa of the class applied for if the applicant had applied for the visa on the day when the applicant last held a substantive or criminal justice visa; or (ii)in the case of an applicant referred to in paragraph (b)—the applicant would have satisfied the criteria (other than any Schedule 3 criteria) for the grant of a visa of the class applied for on the day when the applicant last entered Australia unlawfully; and (g) the applicant intends to comply with any conditions subject to which the visa is granted; and (h) if the last visa (if any) held by the applicant was a transitional (temporary) visa, that visa was not subject to a condition that the holder would not, after entering Australia, be entitled to be granted an entry permit, or a further entry permit, while the holder remained in Australia. 3005A visa or entry permit has not previously been granted to the applicant on the basis of the satisfaction of any of the criteria set out in: (a) this Schedule; or (b) Schedule 6 of the Migration (1993) Regulations; or (c) regulation 35AA or subregulation 42(1A) or (1C) of the Migration (1989) Regulations.Note: Section 10 of the Act provides that a child who was born in the migration zone and was a non‑citizen when he or she was born shall be taken to have entered Australia when he or she was born. oOOo

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Former Club President (now Club Secretary) Mr McGoldrick told the Tribunal that, while he acknowledged there were some things that Mr Atiola could have done, the Club had relied on local MP Mrs Wicks’ office to assist both the Club and Mr Atiola. He explained that Mr Atiola’s confidence in relying on the Club was justified because the Club, in turn, was relying on the local MP whose office had indicated they were in touch with the Department. The Tribunal put to Mr McGoldrick it appeared shortcomings in the Club’s corporate governance and risk management processes had led to the situation Mr Atiola currently faces. He agreed. He added the Club does need to have better corporate governance as well as risk minimization policies and procedures in place. Mr McGoldrick said that lessons have been learned such that this will never happen again. He apologised to the Tribunal, and to Mr Atiola, that the Club has let Mr Atiola down. Consideration of claims and findings The specific issue to be determined in this case is whether Mr Atiola meets criterion 3004(c) of Schedule 3 of the Regulations, that is, not being the holder of a substantive visa because of factors beyond his control. Each of Mr Atiola, Mr McGoldrick and Mr Macauley all presented as credible witnesses. The Tribunal accepts that Mr Atiola made initial enquiries of the Club in March 2015 regarding his future with the Club prior to expiry of his former Subclass 401 visa. Further, it accepts that he relied absolutely on advice received from the Club that it would do the right thing by him and progress renewal of his Subclass 401 visa sponsored by the Club in a timely way and sort out a Bridging visa pending the outcome of that application. The Tribunal accepts that the Club acknowledges its responsibility for the situation in which Mr Atiola finds himself. Because of the Club’s reassurances, the Tribunal accepts Mr Atiola did not make enquiries of the Department regarding lodgement of a new Subclass 401 visa application, request evidence of lodgement of the visa application from the Club and nor did he seek independent legal advice. However, Mr Atiola admits that he could - and with the benefit of hindsight, should - have done all of these things Having regard to the dicta of Smith FM in the decision of Su & Ors v Minister for Immigration & Anor referred to above, the Tribunal has considered the particular situation of Mr Atiola and whether an event caused by the conduct and actions of those at the Club tasked with lodging his new Subclass 401 visa application was ‘beyond his control’ as well as whether it was within his capacity to appreciate what was needed and to perform an action which would have avoided the event occurring. The Tribunal is not satisfied that handing the responsibility of applying for a new Subclass 401 visa to the Club was beyond Mr Atiola’s control. Not only did he contemplate the Club lodging the Subclass 401 visa application on his behalf but he also did not actively pursue evidence of lodgement to satisfy himself that the new Subclass 401 visa application had, in fact, been lodged. It is clear that, based on his evidence to the Tribunal, Mr Atiola was aware of the need to lodge a new visa application on or before 9 May 2015. The Tribunal is of the view that Mr Atiola could have spoken with the Club to satisfy himself that his visa application had been lodged before his initial Subclass 401 visa ceased and requested some sort of evidence of lodgement. He could also have contacted the Department to check that all was in order, or he could have obtained professional immigration advice. The Tribunal acknowledges that there would be costs associated with obtaining advice from a registered migration agent. However, in the Tribunal’s opinion, it would have been open for Mr Atiola to contact the Department at no cost for confirmation that the Club had lodged his Subclass 401 visa application and, if it had not been done, then rectify the situation himself. The Tribunal is of the opinion that, having appreciated the need to lodge a new visa application on or before 9 May 2015, Mr Atiola’s reliance on the Club was inappropriate because it was within his control to ensure that his visa application was lodged.