DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Atem v Commissioner of Police [2024] QDC 117
PARTIES:
ATEM GAK ATEM
(appellant)
v
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE(respondent)
FILE NO/S:
3777/23
DIVISION:
Appellate
PROCEEDING:
Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
Pine Rivers Magistrates Court
DELIVERED ON:
31 July 2024
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
15 July 2024
JUDGES:
Dearden DCJ
ORDER:
(1) Appeal granted.
(2) Set aside all sentences imposed at the Pine Rivers Magistrates Court on 24 November 2023.
(3) In respect of each of the offences of sexual assault and stalking, substitute sentences of 3 months imprisonment, concurrent.
(4) On all other charges, order that the appellant be convicted and not further punished.
(5) Declare the period of 316 days between 13 January 2023 and 24 November 2023 as time served in respect of each of the orders of imprisonment.
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – where the appellant pleaded guilty to one count of unlawful stalking, one count of sexual assault and other summary offences – where the appellant was sentenced to 18 months’ imprisonment suspended after serving 316 days for an operational period of 5 years for the unlawful stalking charge and 9 months’ imprisonment concurrently for the sexual assault charge – whether the sentence was manifestly excessive in all of the circumstances.
LEGISLATION:
Child Protection (Offender Reporting and Offender Prohibition Order) Act 2004 (Qld) ss.5 and 9, sch 1
Summary of Offences Act 2005 (Qld) s.15Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) s.144
CASES:
Jenkins v Commissioner of Police [2021] QDC 289
House v The King [1936] 55 CLR 499
R v Pham (2015) 256 CLR 550
R v Morse [1979] 23 SASR 98
R v SDF [2018] QCA 136
R v Sherwin [1998] QCA 463
DMS v Commissioner of Police [2020] QDC 345
R v GAW [2015] QCA 166
R v Oliver [2018] QCA 348
R v Cox [2016] QCA 251
R v Bunton [2019] QCA 214
Hili v The Queen (2010) 242 CLR 520R v Nagy [2004] 1 Qd R 63
COUNSEL:
A Beard (sol) for the appellant
J Coghlan (sol) for the respondentSOLICITORS:
Legal Aid Queensland for the appellant
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent
Introduction
The appellant, Atem Gak Atem, pleaded guilty in the Pine Rivers Magistrates Court on 27 November 2023 to the following charges:
(1) Sexual assault (22 November 2022);
(2) Unlawful stalking (22 November 2022);
(3) Breach of bail condition (9 December 2022);
(4) Breach of bail condition (9 December 2022);
(5) Breach of bail condition (16 December 2022-13 January 2023);
(6) Breach of bail condition (22 December 2022);
(7) Breach of bail condition (13 January 2023);
(8) Possession of implements that was being or about to be used in relation to particular offences (Summary of Offences Act 2005 (Qld)) (13 January 2023).
The appellant was sentenced to 18 months’ imprisonment, suspended after serving 316 days (which was declared) with an operational period of five years for the stalking charge. In respect of the sexual assault charge,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Atem v Commissioner of Police and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] QDC 117
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the sentences imposed by the acting magistrate were manifestly excessive, particularly in light of the disproportionate sentences given for the stalking and sexual assault charges. The court also had to consider whether the acting magistrate failed to have regard to the impact of the appellant becoming a reportable offender. The court examined the nature of the offences, the impact on the complainant, and the need for denunciation and risk assessment and management in the community.
The court found that the inconsistency between the sentences for the stalking and sexual assault charges was inexplicable, inconsistent, disproportionate, clearly unfair, and constituted manifest error. The court also found that the acting magistrate had not considered the impact of the appellant becoming a reportable offender, which was another error. These errors indicated that the sentencing discretion had miscarried, and the sentences should be set aside and the appellant re-sentenced. The court substituted sentences of 3 months imprisonment, concurrent, for the stalking and sexual assault charges, and declared the period of 316 days as time served.
The court granted the appeal, set aside all sentences imposed by the Pine Rivers Magistrates Court, and substituted sentences of 3 months imprisonment, concurrent, for the stalking and sexual assault charges. The court also declared the period of 316 days as time served and ordered that the appellant be convicted and not further punished on all other charges.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Appeal granted.
(2) Set aside all sentences imposed at the Pine Rivers Magistrates Court on 24 November 2023.
(3) In respect of each of the offences of sexual assault and stalking, substitute sentences of 3 months imprisonment, concurrent.
(4) On all other charges, order that the appellant be convicted and not further punished.
(5) Declare the period of 316 days between 13 January 2023 and 24 November 2023 as time served in respect of each of the orders of imprisonment.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appellant’s outline has also helpfully summarised the learned acting magistrate’s sentencing remarks:[6][6]Exhibit 1 – appellant’s outline of submissions [7.9].“7.9In sentencing the appellant, the [learned acting] magistrate noted the following features of the sentence:7.9.1The pleas of guilty;7.9.2The period of time spent in custody, being 316 days inclusive of the date of the sentence;7.9.3His previous criminal history;7.9.4His disadvantaged childhood, prospects of rehabilitation and employment prospects;7.9.5The facts of the offences, and noted that they were ‘disgusting … and concerning’, an invasion of the complainant’s privacy, and that it involved grabbing the complainant’s buttock and persistence in seeking sex;7.9.6The effect on the complainant and her family has been longstanding;7.9.7People, inclusive of young women, were entitled to feel safe when in public, or utilising train services;7.9.8The comments made to police about wishing to apologise to the complainant were attempts at minimising the seriousness of the conduct;7.9.9The appellant’s behaviour needed to be denounced;7.9.10In all the circumstances, a sentence of imprisonment of between three and six months would not reflect the seriousness of the conduct; and7.9.11The nature of the offences required risk assessment and management in the community, but due to the uncertainty of release, a lengthy operational period was required on a suspended sentence.” (Citations deleted)Consideration The most significant penalty imposed by the learned acting magistrate was the sentence of 18 months’ imprisonment, suspended after 316 days, with a declaration of 316 days (approximately 10 months) as time served, and subject to an operational period of five years, for the stalking charge. The imposition of that sentence in respect of the stalking charge, in comparison to a sentence of nine months’ imprisonment imposed in relation to the sexual assault charge, is, with respect, utterly inexplicable. The stalking charge effectively overlaps with the particulars of the sexual assault, and might be thought, at the most, to frame that latter charge. However, it is not possible to discern how the stalking charge could be considered to have been so much more serious than the sexual assault, that it justified not only the imposition of a sentence of 18 months, suspended after 316 days’ time served (i.e., double the sentence on the sexual assault charge), but further, be subject to the longest possible operational period of five years.[7][7]Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) s.144(6)(b). It is notable that the learned acting magistrate was not assisted by any authority whatsoever. The appellant has identified a number of decisions in respect of sexual assault which, on their face, clearly indicate that the sentence imposed on the sexual assault charge in this appeal was substantially out of step with penalties imposed for similar or analogous conduct. For example, in R v SDF [2018] QCA 136, a sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment, suspended after four months, for two counts of sexual assault by the appellant on his granddaughter, involving firstly a massage of her lower back, and a rubbing of her vagina, which was skin on skin and by a person with a familial relationship, was found to be manifestly excessive, and a sentence of eight months’ imprisonment suspended after time served (two months and four days) was substituted.