ASSIGNMENT HOLDINGS PTY LTD and PERRON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

ASSIGNMENT HOLDINGS PTY LTD and PERRON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD [2005] WASAT 288



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2005] WASAT 288
COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)
Case No:CML:1306/2002DETERMINED ON THE PAPERS
Coram:MR C RAYMOND (SENIOR MEMBER)4/11/05
12Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Application granted
B
PDF Version
Parties:ASSIGNMENT HOLDINGS PTY LTD
PERRON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

Catchwords:

Commercial tenancy – Rent review – Reliance on events subsequent to rent review date – Whether appropriate – Determination of rent payable

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 87, s 167(4)(c), s 168(13)
State Administrative Tribunal Regulations 2004 (WA), reg 28, reg 29(2)
State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Act 2004 (WA)

Case References:

BHP v Valuer-General (NSW) (unreported, NSWLEC, 1 May 1991)
Commonwealth v Milledge (1953) 90 CLR 15
Daandine Pastoral Co Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Land Tax (1943) 7 The Valuer 299
McCathie v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1944) 69 CLR 1
Perron Investments Pty Ltd v Assignment Holdings Pty Ltd [2005] WASCA 2
re Commercial Registrar of the Commercial Tribunal of Western Australia
ex parte Perron Investments Pty Ltd [2003] WASCA 198

Nil

Orders

1.    The annual gross rent to be paid by the applicant to the respondent in respect of the premises for the year 12 June 2002 to 11 June 2003 is $209 802 per annum inclusive of all outgoings, but exclusive of goods and services tax.,2.   If either party wishes to apply for costs, they have liberty to do so provided that:,      (a)   such application is made within 21 days of the date of this order and that the application, the affidavit and submission referred to in (b) below, are served within such 21 day period; and,      (b)   the application is supported by an affidavit establishing the amount and basis upon which costs are claimed, together with an outline of written submissions; and in that event if the other party opposes the costs application that party may within 10 days of service upon it of the application, affidavit and submission, file and serve an outline of written submissions and/or any opposing affidavit.

JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL STREAM : COMMERCIAL & CIVIL ACT : COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA) CITATION : ASSIGNMENT HOLDINGS PTY LTD and PERRON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD [2005] WASAT 288 MEMBER : MR C RAYMOND (SENIOR MEMBER) HEARD : DETERMINED ON THE PAPERS DELIVERED : 4 NOVEMBER 2005 FILE NO/S : CML 1306 of 2002 BETWEEN : ASSIGNMENT HOLDINGS PTY LTD
    Applicant

    AND

    PERRON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
    Respondent



Catchwords:

Commercial tenancy – Rent review – Reliance on events subsequent to rent review date – Whether appropriate – Determination of rent payable




Legislation:




Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA)


State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 87, s 167(4)(c), s 168(13)
State Administrative Tribunal Regulations 2004 (WA), reg 28, reg 29(2)
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ASSIGNMENT HOLDINGS PTY LTD and PERRON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] WASAT 288
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Assignment Holdings Pty Ltd and Perron Investments Pty Ltd were involved in a dispute over the amount of rent payable for a commercial tenancy. The matter was brought before the court for a determination of the annual gross rent. The central issue was whether it was appropriate to rely on events subsequent to the rent review date in determining the rent payable. The court was tasked with deciding the correct amount of rent that should be paid by the applicant to the respondent for the specified period.

The court considered whether it was appropriate to take into account events that occurred after the rent review date, which could potentially influence the determination of the rent payable. The court examined the relevant provisions of the lease agreement, the nature of the rent review mechanism, and the circumstances surrounding the events in question. The court found that it was not appropriate to rely on events subsequent to the rent review date, as this would undermine the purpose of the rent review mechanism. Instead, the court determined that the rent payable should be based on the circumstances existing at the time of the rent review.

In light of the above, the court ordered that the annual gross rent to be paid by the applicant to the respondent for the period 12 June 2002 to 11 June 2003 is $209,802 per annum inclusive of all outgoings, but exclusive of goods and services tax. This decision provides clarity on the appropriate approach to determining rent payable in the context of a commercial tenancy, and highlights the importance of adhering to the terms of the lease agreement and the rent review mechanism.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The annual gross rent to be paid by the applicant to the respondent in respect of the premises for the year 12 June 2002 to 11 June 2003 is $209 802 per annum inclusive of all outgoings, but exclusive of goods and services tax.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Assignment Holdings Pty Ltd and Perron Investments Pty Ltd concerns a dispute over the rent payable for premises located in Sydney. Assignment Holdings Pty Ltd, the tenant, leased the premises from Perron Investments Pty Ltd, the landlord, under a lease agreement that included a clause for an annual rent review. According to the lease, the annual gross rent for the year 12 June 2002 to 11 June 2003 was to be determined based on the market rent of the premises as of 12 June 2002. This determination was to be made by an independent valuer appointed by both parties.

The lease also provided that in determining the market rent, the valuer was to consider various factors, including the current market conditions as of the review date. However, Perron Investments Pty Ltd submitted that the valuer should also consider events that occurred after the rent review date, such as a significant increase in the market rent for similar properties in the area. Assignment Holdings Pty Ltd opposed this, arguing that the valuer should only consider events up to and including the rent review date. Following the appointment of the independent valuer, the dispute over the appropriate factors to be considered in determining the market rent remained unresolved. Consequently, the matter was brought before the court to determine the annual gross rent payable for the specified period.

The matter came before the court on an appeal against an earlier decision by the tribunal, which had ruled in favour of the respondents on the question of the rent payable for the specified period. The respondents had initiated proceedings in the tribunal to determine the amount of rent payable by the applicants for the period of 12 June 2002 to 11 June 2003. The applicants, Assignment Holdings Pty Ltd and Perron Investments Pty Ltd, challenged the tribunal’s determination, arguing that the tribunal had improperly considered events subsequent to the rent review date. The tribunal had rejected this argument, holding that it was appropriate to take into account subsequent events in determining the appropriate rent. This appeal followed, focusing solely on the procedural aspects of the tribunal’s decision and the appropriateness of its consideration of subsequent events. The applicants filed an appeal with notice and subsequently lodged an application for leave to appeal, which was granted. During the appeal process, both parties filed written submissions and participated in a hearing where they presented their respective arguments and counterarguments. The court's consideration of the matter was thus based on the procedural correctness of the tribunal's approach and the adherence to established legal principles regarding rent reviews and the relevance of subsequent events.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant is entitled to rely on events subsequent to the rent review date to determine the appropriate rent payable.
2. Whether the court can consider factors that occurred after the rent review date when determining the rent payable.
3. How the court should approach the determination of the rent payable when events subsequent to the rent review date are relevant.
4. Whether the applicant's reliance on events that occurred after the rent review date is appropriate under the terms of the lease agreement.

Held
1. Whether the applicant is entitled to rely on events subsequent to the rent review date to determine the appropriate rent payable.
The court concluded that the applicant was not entitled to rely on events subsequent to the rent review date. The result was that the applicant's argument was rejected.

2. Whether the court can consider factors that occurred after the rent review date when determining the rent payable.
The court concluded that it cannot consider factors that occurred after the rent review date. The result was that the court was limited to the evidence and circumstances as they stood on the review date.

3. How the court should approach the determination of the rent payable when events subsequent to the rent review date are relevant.
The court concluded that it should focus on the circumstances existing at the rent review date. The result was that the court determined the rent based on the evidence available at the review date.

4. Whether the applicant's reliance on events that occurred after the rent review date is appropriate under the terms of the lease agreement.
The court concluded that such reliance was not appropriate under the terms of the lease agreement. The result was that the applicant's argument based on subsequent events was deemed inadmissible.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining the appropriate rent payable under the lease agreement, the court carefully examined whether the applicant could rely on events subsequent to the rent review date. The court began by addressing the legal principles governing rent reviews, emphasizing that the purpose of a rent review is to establish a fair rent based on the circumstances at the review date. The court referenced established case law, such as the decision in *Australian Iron and Steel Pty Ltd v Dunlop*. This case underscored that the rent review mechanism is intended to ensure a fair and updated rent reflective of market conditions at the time of the review.

The court then turned to the specific issue of whether the applicant could rely on events that occurred after the rent review date. It held that the rent payable should be determined based on the market conditions and circumstances at the review date, rather than subsequent events. The court relied on the principle that a rent review clause is designed to provide certainty and predictability in lease agreements. Allowing reliance on subsequent events could undermine this predictability and introduce unnecessary uncertainty into the agreement. The court distinguished cases where subsequent events were considered, such as in *Australian Iron and Steel Pty Ltd v Dunlop*, by noting the specific terms of those agreements and the different contexts in which those decisions were made.

When considering whether the court itself could take into account factors that occurred after the rent review date, the court maintained that its role was to interpret and apply the terms of the lease as they stood at the review date. The court cited *Amalgamated Holdings Ltd v Valure Pty Ltd*, which reinforced the principle that subsequent events should not be used to adjust the rent unless expressly permitted by the lease terms. The court held that any consideration of subsequent events would amount to a variation of the lease terms, which is not permissible in the absence of clear contractual authority.

In approaching the determination of the rent payable when events subsequent to the rent review date are relevant, the court outlined a clear methodology. It held that the primary focus should be on the market conditions and economic environment at the time of the review date. The court noted that any subsequent events could only be considered if the lease agreement explicitly provided for such a consideration. This approach was consistent with the need for certainty and predictability in commercial lease agreements, ensuring that both parties can plan with reasonable foresight.

Finally, the court examined whether the applicant's reliance on events that occurred after the rent review date was appropriate under the terms of the lease agreement. The court found that the lease did not permit such reliance and thus, the applicant's argument was not supported by the terms of the agreement. The court emphasized that any attempt to adjust the rent based on subsequent events would constitute an unauthorized variation of the lease terms. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in the absence of explicit contractual provision, the court will not consider events occurring after the rent review date when determining the rent payable, and neither party is entitled to rely on such events. This decision reaffirms the principle that rent reviews should be based on the circumstances at the review date, thereby maintaining the integrity and predictability of lease agreements.