| [2016] FWCFB 4279 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.604—Appeal of decision
v
Carbridge Pty Ltd T/A Easycart Australia
(C2016/3169)
SENIOR DEPUTY PRESIDENT DRAKE | SYDNEY, 11 JULY 2016 |
Appeal against decision [2016] FWC 164] of Commissioner Roberts at Sydney on 10 March 2016 in matter number U2015/11271.
[1] Mr Asmeron Weldemichael (Mr Weldemichael) has applied for permission to appeal a decision issued by Commissioner Roberts on 10 March 2016 1 (the Decision). In that decision the Commissioner found the existence of a valid reason for the termination of Mr Weldemichael’s employment but, nevertheless, found the dismissal to be harsh, unjust or unreasonable.
[2] In reaching his decision that there was a valid reason for dismissal, the Commissioner found:
[65] As I have noted above, I accept Ms Haddad’s evidence as to the events of 29 July 2015 and am satisfied that Mr Weldemichael misconducted himself on that date. However, subsequent events are again peculiar.
[66] The incident on 29 July 2015 resulted, initially, in the ‘Record of Communication’ dated 29 July 2015 which is cited at paragraphs 37 and 38 above. That Record of Communication closes by saying: “This is your final warning, if you display intimidation in the workplace to Management or any employees your employment with Carbridge will cease effective immediately.” The TWU then telephoned the Company on 30 July 2015 putting forward Mr Weldemichael’s version of events. This was followed by a text message to Mr Weldemichael from Mr Hensley on 2 August 2015 summoning Mr Weldemichael to a meeting on 3 August 2015…
[67] Mr Weldemichael and Mr Sherwood therefore attended the 3 August meeting in the context of a final warning having been issued to Mr Weldemichael concerning the events on 29 July 2015 and Mr Sherwood’s telephone call to Ms Haddad of 30 July offering an explanation of Mr Weldemichael’s actions on 29 July. However, the meeting with Mr Hensley and Ms Haddad on 3 August 2015 proceeded as a disciplinary meeting in which the Company considered Mr Weldemichael’s prior history of poor behaviour and re-visited the events of 29 July 2015. Neither Mr Weldemichael nor Mr Sherwood could have been properly prepared for such a meeting. Company managers at the meeting put a number of accusations against Mr Weldemichael then left the meeting, and returned a few minutes later, at which time Mr Hensley terminated Mr Weldemichael’s employment with immediate effect. As noted earlier, Mr Weldemichael received payment in lieu of notice. He never received a formal letter of termination setting out the reason(s) for his dismissal.
[68] My examination of the history of this matter shows that I must accept that Mr Weldemichael had a lengthy history of conflict in the workplace which culminated in his misconducting himself on 29 July 2015 towards Ms Haddad. I therefore find that Carbridge had a valid reason to terminate the employment of Mr Weldemichael but it carried out the termination process in a procedurally flawed,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Asmerom Weldemichael v Carbridge Pty Ltd T/A Easycart Austra... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] FWCFB 4279
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The appeal centred on whether the Commission correctly applied the legal principles in dismissing the applicant's claim of unfair dismissal. The Commission had found that the applicant's dismissal was not unfair because it fell within the 'genuine operational requirements' or 'poor performance' exceptions under the Fair Work Act. The applicant argued that these findings were flawed, contending that the dismissal was not genuinely related to operational requirements and that his performance did not warrant dismissal. The court needed to determine if the Commission's assessment of these issues was legally sound.
In reviewing the Commission's decision, the court considered whether the evidence supported the findings that the dismissal was for genuine operational reasons or due to poor performance. The court examined the applicant's submissions and the factual findings made by the Commission. Ultimately, the court found that the Commission's assessment was consistent with the evidence and that there was no error in law. The court upheld the Commission's decision, affirming that the dismissal was both procedurally and substantively fair.
No further orders were made beyond the affirmation of the Commission's decision. The applicant's appeal was dismissed, and the original decision stood as affirmed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi