Ashton v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Ashton v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited [2023] NSWPICMP 402
CLAIMANT: Scott Ashton
INSURER: QBE
REVIEW PANEL
MEMBER: Gary Victor Patterson
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Dawn Piebenga
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Lauren Alach
DATE OF DECISION: 21 August 2023
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – The claimant suffered injury on 2 July 2018; the dispute related to whether 0 – 49 hours per week of domestic care at the claimant’s remote property is reasonable and necessary; claimant wheelchair-bound with extensive co-morbidities; Held – 15 hours per week of domestic assistance at claimant’s remote property reasonable and necessary; original certificate revoked.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE

The Review Panel revokes the certificate dated 21 September 2022 and issues a new certificate determining that:

The following treatment and care:
  • 0 – 14 hours per week of domestic care at the Mogo Creek property.
  • 16 – 49 hours per week of domestic care at the Mogo Creek property
IS NOT REASONABLE AND NECESSARY in the circumstances.
The following treatment and care:
  • 15 hours per week of domestic care at the Mogo Creek property
IS REASONABLE AND NECESSARY in the circumstances.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. Scott Ashton, (the claimant), was 48 years old at the time of the motor accident. The claimant is divorced. He divides his time between his single-storey residence at Mogo Creek, an isolated location some 10 kilometres from Buckety, and his mother’s home at North Turramurra. The claimant has an adult daughter who lives separately. He weighs more than 180 kilograms and utilises a wheelchair periodically.

  2. The claimant has a history of Diabetes Mellitus Type II, hypertension, sleep apnoea and kidney stones. He suffers from obesity.

  3. In 1989, he was involved in a motorcycle accident in which he sustained a concussive brain injury and a broken jaw. He was hospitalised for a month.

  4. In April 2012, he slipped and fell at Macquarie Centre, sustaining a Weber B fracture to his right ankle. He underwent open reduction and external fixation of the fracture. Hardware was removed in April 2013.

  5. The claimant had a high-speed motorcycle accident on 19 July 2015 in which he suffered the following injuries:

    ·        Open book pelvic fracture.

    ·        Right sacroiliac diastasis and displaced right ileum.

    ·        Left femur fracture.

    ·        Left ankle dislocation.

    ·        Fractured lateral malleolus.

    ·        Right L2 transverse process fracture.

    ·        Bilateral 12th rib fractures.

    ·        Pain radiating down the right side.

    ·        Torn TP tendon in right foot.

    ·        Concussion.

    ·        Right foot drop.

    ·        Right intertrochanteric femur fracture (secondary).

    ·        Burns/abrasion to lower back.

    ·        Psychological (PTSD, Anxiety, Depression, Shock).

    The motorcycle accident caused peripheral nerve damage resulting in a permanent foot drop. The claimant had a tibialis posterior tendon transfer surgery to assist in managing the foot drop. That surgery was performed on 2 May 2016.

  6. The claimant returned to work after the 2015 motor accident. He was not in a wheelchair. He says he was able to walk and work normally.

  7. On 2 July 2018, the claimant was driving a work utility…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ashton v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICMP 402
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ashton v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited concerned a dispute over the reasonable and necessary level of domestic care required for a claimant who was wheelchair-bound with extensive co-morbidities, following a motor accident on 2 July 2018. The claimant sought to have the insurer provide 0 to 49 hours per week of domestic assistance for tasks including transport to and from medical and therapy appointments, self-care, indoor domestic tasks and associated essential power and supplies at his remote property in Mogo Creek. Assessors Alach and Piebenga were instructed to assess the claimant’s needs on 30 May 2022.

The legal issues in the case centred around whether the claimant’s need for domestic assistance was reasonable and necessary, and if so, what the appropriate amount of such assistance should be. The claimant argued for 0 to 49 hours per week, while the insurer contested that less than 14 hours per week was sufficient. The Panel was tasked with forming its own opinion on the matter, based on the current assessment of the claimant’s needs rather than previous assessments, which could be outdated.

The Panel concluded that the previous certificate issued by Assessor Davidson should be revoked due to its outdated nature and the need for a current assessment of the claimant’s capacities. The Panel found that 15 hours per week of domestic assistance at the claimant’s remote property was reasonable and necessary. This decision was based on the claimant's current medical condition, including his immobility and co-morbidities, and the practicalities of providing care in a remote setting. A new certificate reflecting this assessment was issued.

The final orders included the revocation of the original certificate and the issuance of a new certificate providing for 15 hours per week of domestic assistance.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The claimant was seen by Assessors Alach and Piebenga on 30 May 2022 at his Mogo Creek property. He told the assessors that he was not living there at the time.. The Assessors’ findings and report is set out below:“Background1.There is a dispute between the claimant and the insurer about:• Whether 0 to 49 hours per week of domestic care for transport to and from medical and therapy appointments and to and from the Mogo Creek property, self-care, indoor domestic tasks and associated essential power and the supplies is reasonable and necessaryCare Disputes to be assessed2.The following care disputes were referred by the Personal Injury Commission for further[LA4] assessment:Treatment Type: Domestic assistance – reasonable and necessary.Treatment Description: 13 hours per week of domestic care at the Mogo Creek property.Treatment Type: Domestic assistance – reasonable and necessary.Treatment Description: 0 – 12 hours per week of domestic care at the Mogo Creek property.Treatment Type: Domestic assistance – reasonable and necessary.Treatment Description: 14[DP5] – 49 hours per week of domestic care at the Mogo Creek property.REASONS HISTORY The Panel conducts a new assessment of all the matters with which the medical assessment is concerned.[5] The Panel adopts the extensive reasons of the joint assessment findings of Assessor Alach and Assessor Piebenga[5] Section 7.26(6) of the MAI Act. The Panel is not required to choose between competing opinions and is required to form its own opinions.[6] The two assessors have explained the basis of their assessment which are different from those provided by other occupational therapists. The assessment of the claimant’s necessary and reasonable care needs, arising from the motor accident, is undertaken at the time of the examination. In that respect, the previous assessments are outdated and may not reflect the claimant’s current capacities found upon assessment.[6] Insurance Australia Group Limited v Keen [2021] NSWCA 287 and Insurance Australia Limited v Marsh [2021] NSWCA 31. For these reasons, the Panel concludes that the Certificate issued by Assessor Davidson should be revoked. The new Certificate is attached at the commencement of this reasons.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.