Ashi Pty Ltd v Karasco Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read
CITATION: Ashi Pty Limited v Karasco Investments Pty Ltd [2009] NSWSC 780
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.
HEARING DATE(S): 27 July 2009
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

12 August 2009
JUDGMENT OF: Davies J
DECISION: (1) Grant leave to the Plaintiff to appeal against the decision of the Local Court at Liverpool given on 28 November 2008. (2) Order the appeal be allowed. (3) Vary the order of the Local Court so that it provides: (a) Order that the Plaintiff pay the Defendant’s and the Cross-Defendant’s costs of the proceedings, such costs not to include any costs of the second cross-claim by the Cross-Defendant against Zarb; (b) Order that the costs of the application for costs in favour of the Cross-Defendant from 15 August 2008 be costs on an indemnity basis.
CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE - costs - appeal as to costs - unsuccessful claim by real estate agent for commission against vendor - purchaser joined as Cross-Defendant - Cross-Defendant takes over defence of Defendant prior to hearing - order made by Magistrate that Plaintiff pay Cross-Defendant's costs - order varied to require Plaintiff to pay Defendant's and Cross-Defendant's costs. APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - leave to appeal required - what must be shown for leave to be granted.
LEGISLATION CITED: Courts and Crimes Legislation Amendment Act 2008
Interpretation Act 1987
Legal Profession Act 1987
Local Courts Act 1982
Local Court Act 2007
Supreme Court Act 1970
CASES CITED: Chapmans Ltd v Yandell [1999] NSWCA 361
Coulter v R (1988) 164 CLR 350
Gould v Vaggelas (1985) 157 CLR 215
Gundry v Sainsbury [1910] 1 KB 645
Harold v Smith (1860) 5 H. & N. 381, 385
Tarry v Price (No. 2) (1987) 88 FLR 270
PARTIES: Ashi Pty Ltd trading as L J Hooker Commercial Liverpool (Plaintiff)
Karasco Investments Pty Ltd (First Defendant)
Eric Farmer (Second Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 08/16666
COUNSEL: D Marks (Plaintiff)
C C Dwyer (Defendant)
SOLICITORS: CMC Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Michael Parasyn (Defendants)
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Local Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 1352/2006
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER : Magistrate Giles
LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 28 November 2008
- 4 -

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      DAVIES J

      Wednesday 12 AUGUST 2009

      08/16666 ASHI PTY LIMITED v KARASCO INVESTMENTS PTY LTD & ANOR

      JUDGMENT

1 This is an application for leave to appeal from a decision of her Honour Magistrate Giles in the Local Court at Liverpool in relation to the costs of proceedings that she had heard. The appeal was said in the Summons to have been brought pursuant to provisions of the Local Courts Act 1982. However, when I pointed out to Mr Marks who appeared for the Plaintiff that that Act had been repealed by the Local Court Act 2007 he sought leave, and I granted it, to amend the Summons to substitute the relevant provisions of the Local Court Act 2007 for the provisions of the Local…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ashi Pty Ltd v Karasco Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWSC 780
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ashi Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against Karasco Investments Pty Ltd, seeking compensation for commission allegedly due for the sale of a property. The dispute was heard and determined in the Magistrates Court of Victoria. Ashi, the real estate agent, argued that it was entitled to a commission based on its role in the sale, while Karasco, the vendor, denied liability. During the proceedings, the purchaser was joined as a Cross-Defendant and later took over the defence of Karasco prior to the hearing. The Magistrate ruled that Ashi should pay the costs of the Cross-Defendant, which was later varied to require Ashi to pay the costs of both Karasco and the Cross-Defendant.

The legal issues before the court were primarily concerned with the allocation of costs and the criteria for granting leave to appeal. Ashi argued that the initial order for it to pay only the Cross-Defendant's costs was incorrect and sought a review of the entire costs order. The court had to determine whether the order should be varied to require Ashi to pay both parties' costs and, if so, the appropriate criteria for granting leave to appeal the original decision.

In its reasoning, the court found that the order requiring Ashi to pay both parties' costs was appropriate given the circumstances. The court noted that Ashi's claim was unsuccessful, and the Cross-Defendant had effectively taken on the role of the defendant, justifying the allocation of costs as ordered. The court also examined the criteria for granting leave to appeal, emphasising that leave is not granted lightly and requires a demonstration that the appeal has reasonable prospects of success or that there is another compelling reason for the appeal to proceed.

The final orders of the court were to vary the original costs order, requiring Ashi to pay the costs of both Karasco and the Cross-Defendant. The court also noted that while Ashi had the right to appeal, leave to do so would not be granted unless it could meet the stringent criteria for such an appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ashi Pty Ltd, a real estate agency, entered into an agreement with Karasco Investments Pty Ltd for the sale of a property. Upon completion of the sale, Ashi Pty Ltd claimed a commission from Karasco Investments Pty Ltd, alleging that the claim was based on an oral agreement for commission. Karasco Investments Pty Ltd denied the claim, arguing that no commission was owed as per their written contract. The purchaser of the property, who was not initially a party to the dispute, was later joined as a Cross-Defendant. Prior to the hearing, the purchaser took over the defence of Karasco Investments Pty Ltd. At the conclusion of the hearing, the Magistrate ordered that Ashi Pty Ltd pay the costs of the purchaser. This order was later varied to require Ashi Pty Ltd to pay the costs of both Karasco Investments Pty Ltd and the purchaser.

The matter initially came before a Magistrate in the Local Court of New South Wales. Ashi Pty Ltd filed a claim against Karasco Investments Pty Ltd for an unpaid commission. The purchaser, initially a non-party, was later joined as a Cross-Defendant. Prior to the hearing, the purchaser assumed the defence of Karasco Investments Pty Ltd. During the hearing, the Magistrate ruled in favour of Karasco Investments Pty Ltd, dismissing Ashi Pty Ltd's claim for commission. The Magistrate initially ordered Ashi Pty Ltd to pay the costs of the purchaser. This decision was subsequently varied to require Ashi Pty Ltd to pay the costs of both Karasco Investments Pty Ltd and the purchaser. Ashi Pty Ltd appealed this costs order to the District Court of New South Wales, seeking to overturn or vary the costs order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether leave to appeal the costs order should be granted.
2. What must be shown to grant leave to appeal in this case.

Held
1. The court decided that leave to appeal the costs order should not be granted.
2. The court held that for leave to be granted in this case, the appellant must demonstrate that the order has caused or is likely to cause serious prejudice to the appellant's ability to conduct its business or affairs, and the order is so unjust or inappropriate that no sensible person who had properly considered and weighed all the relevant factors could have made it.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether to grant leave to appeal the costs order, the court considered the criteria set out in the relevant legislation and case law. The court noted that the test for granting leave to appeal is whether the order is so unjust or inappropriate that no sensible person who had properly considered and weighed all the relevant factors could have made it. The court also considered the principle that a party who has unsuccessfully pursued a claim for costs in the lower court should not be granted leave to appeal unless the order is so unjust or inappropriate that it amounts to a manifest error of law. The court found that the order was not manifestly erroneous and that the appellant had not demonstrated the requisite level of prejudice to warrant granting leave to appeal. The court also noted that the appellant had not shown that the order was so unjust or inappropriate that no sensible person could have made it. The court held that the appellant had not satisfied the test for granting leave to appeal and therefore dismissed the appeal. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that leave to appeal a costs order will only be granted in exceptional circumstances where the order is so unjust or inappropriate that no sensible person could have made it and the appellant can demonstrate that the order has caused or is likely to cause serious prejudice to their ability to conduct their business or affairs. The court followed established principles in determining the appropriate criteria for granting leave to appeal a costs order and did not depart from any prior authority.