IN THE FEDERIIL, COURT OF AUSTR.aIA 1
1
| rm SOUTH WALES DISTRICT | REGISTW ) | No. G:% | of 1386 |
)
| GENERAL DIVISION | ! | I |
| l | ||
| : |
| . - | i ! |
| 1 |
| EETGEEN: | M | . | .S G. LEHEE | BR0THEP.C | FTY. | LIEIITE33 |
l
Applicant
| C3LTEX OIL (AUSTPALIA) FTY. LIMITED | ! | ||
| i | |||
| I | |||
| Respondent |
| ||
| , |
| Judqe making order: Eeaumont, J. | I . |
| , - I , I |
| Date order made: | 3 July 1386 |
!
| Where | made : | Sydney |
1
i
| 1 | - | C0W.T | THE | ORDERS THAT: |
| 1. | Note that the applicant renews | its undertaking as |
| to damages. | ||
| -. |
| _. flote | that | the | respondent | renews | its | e:iistln+ |
. undzrtaking to the Court until further order.
3. Reserva liberty to apFl7 cn txo days' notice.
| 1. |
| |||
|
LJote: Zettlement and entry of ardsrz 13 dealt Yith in
| ilrder 36 of the Federal Court Rules. | j |
| r |
| . | !' |
I
I
tJOT FOR GENERAL DISTRIBUTION
i
| IB THE FDERAL C0UF.T OF AUSTEALIA | ) | I |
| 1 | !. |
| P J E W SOUTH WLES DISTRICT REGISTRY | 1 | Hp. C258 of 1986 |
| 1 | ||
| GENERAL DIVISION | ) |
._
!
I I
| BETWEEN | : | M. Si G . WEHBE BROTHERS PTY. LIMITED | 1 |
| Applicant | I | ||
| i | |||
| ! |
| i | m&N | : | CALTEX OIL (AUSTRALIA) FTP. LIMITED | . | I |
| ! | |||||
| Respondent |
| COPAM: | Beaumont , J. |
* - .
| DATED: S July 1986 | l | i |
REASONS FOR JUDC-IWNT
| The applicant seeks interlocutory relief that, pending | i |
the final hearing of these proceedings, the respondent continue
t
| to deliver | to | the applicant petroleum Droducts to the retail |
| outlet conducted by the respondent | at the premises altuated .at |
| 110 Canterbury Road, Bankstown. |
| In his affidavit sworn 29 June 1986. | Mr. M.N. lqehbe, a |
| director | of the applicant, says that in early May | 1386, | the | I |
respondent offered to enter into a Reseller Supply Ccntract and Collateral Agreement for the supply of petroleum products. This
| contract | and | thls | agrsement | yere | intended | to | renew | similar |
| previous arrangements which xere about to esplre | by effluxion of |
| I | I |
| \ | 7 | I |
| b . |
| I | I |
| I . |
| time. | On 13 May 1986. the applicant executed a counterpart of |
| these agreements which were to subsist for | a period of one year |
I
| at least. However, by letter dated 16 June 1986. the respondent | : |
| informed the applicant that it did not propose to renew the |
| existing supply arrangements. - | - |
| The applicant’s case | 1s th&t | the respondent | has- | engaged | ! |
| in misleadmg or deceptive conduct within the meaning of | 5 - 5 2 of |
| _ - |
| 1974 | (the | Act). | Alternatively, | the |
applicant seeks to invoke the accrued jurisdiction of the Court
| and | claims | under | the | general | law | an order | for | specific |
| performance | of | what | It alleges to | be | a contract | to | supply | ! |
petroleum products.
!
| The matter is urgent | and, accordingly, | I have arranged |
| for it to be heard, on | a final basis, on 21 July. | Since I will |
fie…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ascic v Australian Federal Police and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1986] FCA 260
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the respondent's conduct, taken as a whole, was likely to mislead the applicant, and whether the applicant had raised the matter of jurisdiction in bad faith. The court acknowledged the future nature of the representations relied upon by the applicant but found that a serious question to be tried arose regarding the respondent's conduct. The court also examined the respondent's discretionary defences, including the suggestion that the applicant was involved in dealing in stolen petrol and the nature of the relief sought, which might require the court's continuous supervision.
After considering the arguments and the balance of convenience, the court held that there was at least a serious question to be tried on both the misleading or deceptive conduct and the specific performance claims. The court also noted that the respondent had not provided any evidence to support its claim that the applicant was involved in dealing in stolen petrol. Therefore, the court granted interim relief to maintain the status quo. The court made orders noting the undertakings of both parties as to damages, reserving the liberty to apply on two days' notice, and ordering that the costs of the interim application be costs in the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi