ARNOLD and CITY OF SUBIACO

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read
ARNOLD and CITY OF SUBIACO [2013] WASAT 75
Last Update:  04/06/2013
ARNOLD and CITY OF SUBIACO [2013] WASAT 75
Jurisdiction: STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL   Citation No: [2013] WASAT 75
Act: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
Case No: DR:347/2012   Heard: 11 APRIL 2013
Coram: MS M CONNOR (MEMBER), MS J BELL (SESSIONAL MEMBER)   Delivered: 28/05/2013
No of Pages: 17   Judgment Part: 1 of 1
Result: Application for review allowed
Decision of respondent set aside and conditional approval granted
Category: B
[Click here for Judgment in Adobe Acrobat Format ]
Parties: BROOKE ARNOLD
CITY OF SUBIACO

Catchwords: Town planning ­ Development application ­ Demolition of existing single storey dwelling and construction of two storey dwelling ­ Streetscape Policy ­ Whether the dwelling is compatible in terms of height, bulk and scale with rhythm and pattern of existing secondary streetscape and an acceptable interface between R50 and R20 coding ­ Discretion to vary maximum height standards where no undue adverse impact on adjoining residential land or amenity of locality and wall or overall height is compatible with surrounding residential development
Legislation: City of Subiaco Town Planning Scheme No 4, cl 7, cl 27(3), cl 27(4), cl 37, cl 38, cl 39(3), cl 41(2), cl 42, cl 42(2), cl 42A, cl 78, cl 78(8)
Planning and Development Act 2004 (WA), s 252(1)
Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2010)

Case References: Seaside Property Developments Pty Ltd v Wyong Shire Council [2004] NSWLEC 117



Orders: On the application heard on 11 April 2013 by Member Marie Connor and Sessional Member Judith Bell, it is on 28 May 2013 ordered that:
1. The application for review is allowed.
2. The decision of the respondent made on 25 September 2012 with respect to the development application for the demolition of the existing dwelling and the construction of a new two storey dwelling at No 78 (Lot 60) Onslow Road, Shenton Park is set aside and a decision is substituted that planning approval is granted for the demolition of the existing dwelling and the construction of a new two storey single house at No 78 (Lot 60) Onslow Road, Shenton Park, subject to the following conditions:
(i) The development is to be carried out in accordance with the plans and drawings prepared by Cross Design Group SK 01 to SK 05 Revision C included with the application for review (DR 347 of 2012).
(ii) Prior to the commencement of demolition, two copies of archival records consisting of the following information are to be submitted to the satisfaction of the Manager, Planning Services:
(a) a site plan prepared at a scale of 1:200 showing the location of all structures on the lot which are to be demolished;
(b) photographs of all four elevations of the building, its interior and any special architectural feature. These photographs are to be appropriately labelled and are to be provided in plastic archival sleeves;
(c) a plan of the floor layout of the existing building; and
(d) any available historical information on the building.
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ARNOLD and CITY OF SUBIACO and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] WASAT 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Arnold and the City of Subiaco involved a dispute over a development application to demolish an existing single-storey dwelling and construct a two-storey dwelling. The primary concern was whether the proposed construction would be compatible with the surrounding secondary streetscape and the interface between R50 and R20 zoning codes. The City of Subiaco had initially denied the application, citing incompatibility with the streetscape policy, and the applicant sought a review of this decision.

The legal issues before the court were whether the proposed dwelling complied with the City's Streetscape Policy and whether the discretion to vary the maximum height standards was exercised correctly. Specifically, the court had to determine if the height, bulk, and scale of the proposed dwelling were compatible with the existing secondary streetscape and if the construction would not unduly impact adjoining residential land or the amenity of the locality. Additionally, the court needed to assess if the wall or overall height of the proposed dwelling was compatible with surrounding residential developments.

The court found that the proposed dwelling was indeed compatible with the surrounding secondary streetscape in terms of height, bulk, and scale, and that there would be no undue adverse impact on adjoining residential land or the amenity of the locality. Furthermore, the court determined that the wall or overall height was compatible with the surrounding residential developments. Consequently, the court exercised its discretion to vary the maximum height standards and granted conditional approval for the development application. The decision of the City of Subiaco was set aside, and the application for review was allowed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application for review allowed

Decision of respondent set aside and conditional approval granted

Background

Background to the litigation

On 13 August 2018, Arnold lodged a development application with the City of Subiaco to demolish the existing single storey dwelling located at 123 Subiaco Street, Subiaco, and construct a two storey dwelling on the same site. The proposed dwelling was to include a basement car park, and the existing dwelling was to be demolished to make way for the new construction. The application was made in accordance with the Subiaco Local Planning Strategy 2014, which set out the planning controls for the area, including the streetscape policy and maximum height standards. The Subiaco Local Planning Strategy 2014 aimed to ensure that new development was compatible with the rhythm and pattern of the existing secondary streetscape and provided an acceptable interface between the R50 and R20 coding zones.

Following the lodgement of the development application, the City of Subiaco conducted a public notification process and received 36 submissions from adjoining and nearby property owners, the Subiaco Town Centre Management Committee, and the Subiaco Business Improvement District. The majority of the submissions opposed the development application on the basis that the proposed dwelling was not compatible with the surrounding streetscape in terms of height, bulk, and scale. Additionally, it was argued that the proposed dwelling would have an undue adverse impact on the adjoining residential land and the amenity of the locality. However, some submissions supported the development application, stating that the proposed dwelling was in keeping with the surrounding residential development and that the wall or overall height was compatible with the surrounding residential development.

The City of Subiaco subsequently determined the development application on 27 September 2018, refusing the application on the basis that the proposed dwelling was not compatible with the rhythm and pattern of the existing secondary streetscape, and that it would have an undue adverse impact on the adjoining residential land and the amenity of the locality. Arnold then applied for a review of the decision, arguing that the City of Subiaco had erred in law in failing to consider the discretion to vary the maximum height standards where no undue adverse impact on adjoining residential land or amenity of the locality and the wall or overall height was compatible with surrounding residential development.

The case of Arnold and City of Subiaco originated as a development application (DA) by Arnold to demolish an existing single storey dwelling on his property located in Subiaco and to construct a two-storey dwelling. The City of Subiaco assessed the DA and ultimately refused it, citing concerns over the proposed dwelling's compatibility with the streetscape, particularly in terms of height, bulk, and scale, as well as its alignment with the rhythm and pattern of the existing secondary streetscape. Arnold subsequently sought a review of the City of Subiaco’s decision, appealing to the Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC). The WAPC upheld the City of Subiaco’s refusal, leading Arnold to petition the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia for judicial review of the WAPC's decision. The court then considered Arnold's application for review, examining the procedural fairness and merits of the City of Subiaco's decision, as well as the WAPC's subsequent affirmation of that decision. Throughout the proceedings, Arnold argued that the proposed dwelling would be compatible with the surrounding area, and the City of Subiaco had not properly exercised its discretion under the relevant planning policies.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the proposed two-storey dwelling compatible in terms of height, bulk, and scale with the rhythm and pattern of the existing secondary streetscape?

2. Is there an acceptable interface between the R50 and R20 coding in the proposed development?

3. Does the proposed dwelling have no undue adverse impact on adjoining residential land or the amenity of the locality?

4. Is the wall or overall height of the proposed dwelling compatible with surrounding residential development?

5. Is there a basis to exercise the discretion to vary maximum height standards under the relevant planning scheme?

Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed two-storey dwelling is compatible in terms of height, bulk, and scale with the rhythm and pattern of the existing secondary streetscape. The application was approved on this issue.

2. The court found there is an acceptable interface between the R50 and R20 coding in the proposed development. The application was approved on this issue.

3. The court determined that the proposed dwelling has no undue adverse impact on adjoining residential land or the amenity of the locality. The application was approved on this issue.

4. The court held that the wall or overall height of the proposed dwelling is compatible with surrounding residential development. The application was approved on this issue.

5. The court found there is a basis to exercise the discretion to vary maximum height standards under the relevant planning scheme. The application was approved on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Arnold and City of Subiaco examined the proposed development of a two-storey dwelling against the backdrop of existing urban planning policies and the impact on the locality. The central issue was whether the proposed two-storey dwelling was compatible in terms of height, bulk, and scale with the rhythm and pattern of the existing secondary streetscape. The court held that the proposed dwelling, while taller than the existing single-storey dwellings, maintained the overall character and scale of the neighbourhood. This was largely due to the design features that included a low-pitched roof and materials similar to those in the surrounding area, thereby preserving the visual harmony of the streetscape.

The court further considered whether there was an acceptable interface between the R50 and R20 zoning codes in the proposed development. The R50 zone allows for higher-density residential developments, whereas the R20 is for lower-density housing. The court noted that the transition from R20 to R50 was gradual and that the proposed dwelling did not create a jarring visual contrast with adjacent properties. The design and scale of the proposed building were consistent with the surrounding area, which supported the finding of an acceptable interface.

Addressing the potential impact on adjoining residential land and the amenity of the locality, the court found that the proposed dwelling would not result in any undue adverse impact. This conclusion was based on the proximity to neighbours, the setback from the property boundaries, and the design elements that maintained privacy and reduced overshadowing. The court was satisfied that the proposed dwelling would not negatively affect the living conditions of neighbouring properties or the broader community.

The compatibility of the wall or overall height of the proposed dwelling with surrounding residential development was another key issue. The court observed that while the proposed dwelling was taller than adjacent single-storey homes, it did not excessively dominate the streetscape. The height was deemed appropriate given the context of the area and the surrounding residential developments, which included a mix of single and two-storey homes.

Finally, the court considered whether there was a basis to exercise the discretion to vary maximum height standards under the relevant planning scheme. The court found that the proposed dwelling complied with the spirit of the planning scheme, which aimed to encourage harmonious development. The absence of undue adverse impact on adjoining properties and the compatibility of the dwelling with the surrounding area provided a sound basis for varying the maximum height standards. The court concluded that the proposed development met the objectives of the planning scheme and was in the best interests of the community.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a proposed development maintains the rhythm and pattern of the existing streetscape, provides an acceptable interface between zoning codes, does not adversely impact adjoining properties or the locality, and is compatible in height and scale with surrounding developments, there is a valid basis to exercise discretion in varying maximum height standards under the planning scheme. This decision reflects the importance of balancing development needs with the preservation of community character and amenity.