Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing v Expense Reduction Analysis Group

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing v Expense Reduction Analysis Group [2013] NSWSC 1702
Hearing dates:15/11/2013
Decision date: 15 November 2013
Jurisdiction:Equity Division - Commercial List
Before: McDougall J
Decision:

Order for further informal discovery; directions for evidence.

Catchwords: PRACTICE & PROCEDURE - Practice Note SC Eq 11 - discovery - where discovery ordered prior to commencement of Practice Note SC Eq 11 - where numerous additional potentially relevant documents located after commencement of Practice Note - whether party obliged to provide discoverable documents
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing Pty Ltd (First plaintiff)
Armstrong Consulting Pty Ltd (Second plaintiff)
Ken Armstrong (Third plaintiff)
Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd (First defendant)
ERA Insurance Services Pty Ltd (Second defendant)
Expense Reduction Analysts Australasia Pty Ltd (Third defendant)
Stuart Roy Michael (Fourth defendant)
Ronald Clucas (Fifth defendant)
Charles Frederick Marfleet (Sixth defendant)
Eragics Limited (Seventh defendant)
Expenses Reduction Analysts International Ltd (Eighth defendant)
Keith John Chapman (Ninth defendant)
Anthony Frederick Dormer (Tenth defendant)
Representation: Counsel:
CN Bova (Plaintiffs)
EAJ Hyde (Fourth, fifth, sixth, ninth and tenth defendants)
JK Dormer (Solicitor)(First and third defendants)
Solicitors:
Marque Lawyers (Plaintiffs)
Norton Rose Australia (Fourth, fifth, sixth, ninth and tenth defendants)
Kresdon Dormers (First and third defendants)
File Number(s):2011/76919

Judgment (ex tempore - revised 15 NOvember 2013)

  1. HIS HONOUR: The procedural history of this matter could be taken to suggest that the parties have paid less attention to the provisions of s 56 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) than they have to the process of seeking to grind each other into the dust. Whether or not that is a correct summary of what has happened would depend upon a further investigation of the procedural history, which is a course that is not necessary to take for present purposes. Nonetheless, although I cannot express a concluded view on that point, I have a very uncomfortable impression that I am not far from the truth.

  1. Be all that as it may, the matter is before me today because the parties, it might be thought unsurprisingly, are in dispute as to how the matter is to be moved forward towards a hearing.

  1. Relevantly, an order for, in effect, general discovery was made on 22 July 2011. Rather than being for general discovery in the old sense, it was for discovery of documents limited to documents relevant to a fact in issue. The parties gave, or purported to give, discovery accordingly and that was completed some time in October 2011, by a process that included the exchange of verified lists of documents.

  1. Unfortunately, the process of preparation has been derailed because a subsidiary but time-consuming and no doubt expensive dispute broke out over what the "individual defendants" say was the inadvertent discovery by them of privileged documents. For reasons that I find hard to follow, that apparently simple issue required the consideration of a Judge…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing v Expense Reduc... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWSC 1702
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing v Expense Reduction Analysis Group was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing (Armstrong) sought to enforce an order for discovery that was made prior to the commencement of the Supreme Court Practice Note SC Eq 11. The dispute arose after Armstrong located numerous additional documents that were potentially relevant to the proceedings following the commencement of the Practice Note. Armstrong argued that Expense Reduction Analysis Group (ERAG) was obliged to provide these additional documents as part of the discovery process.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether ERAG was required to disclose documents that were discovered after the commencement of Practice Note SC Eq 11, despite the discovery order being made prior to the Practice Note's introduction. The court needed to determine the scope of the obligations under the discovery process and whether the new Practice Note imposed additional duties on the parties. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the Practice Note altered the obligations that arose from the original discovery order.

The Supreme Court held that the obligations imposed by the discovery process were not retrospective. The court found that the introduction of Practice Note SC Eq 11 did not impose additional duties on ERAG concerning documents that were already subject to a discovery order made before the Practice Note's commencement. The court reasoned that the Practice Note was intended to provide guidance and procedural clarity for future litigation, but it did not alter the obligations that had already crystallised under the original discovery order. Therefore, ERAG was not obliged to provide the additional documents located after the Practice Note came into effect.

As a result, the Supreme Court dismissed Armstrong's application for an order compelling ERAG to provide the additional documents. The court emphasised that parties should not be penalised for changes in procedural rules after the commencement of litigation, provided that they had complied with the orders in place at the time of discovery. The court's decision clarified the interaction between existing discovery orders and subsequent procedural changes, providing guidance for future cases involving similar issues.

Background

Background to the litigation

Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing (Armstrong) engaged Expense Reduction Analysis Group (ERA) to undertake a review of Armstrong's expenses. Following the review, ERA provided a report detailing potential savings. Armstrong was dissatisfied with the outcome and sought to recover legal costs from ERA. Armstrong subsequently initiated proceedings against ERA for professional negligence. During the discovery process, Armstrong identified additional documents that were potentially relevant to the case. However, these documents were located after the commencement of the Practice Note SC Eq 11, which sets out rules for discovery in Supreme Court Equity Division proceedings. Armstrong argued that ERA was required to provide these additional documents under the discovery order. ERA contended that it was not obliged to provide these documents as they were found post the Practice Note's commencement.

The matter initially came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in the Equity Division. Armstrong filed a claim against ERA for professional negligence. Discovery was ordered in accordance with the Practice Note SC Eq 11. After the discovery period, Armstrong located additional documents that they argued should have been disclosed by ERA. Armstrong applied to the court to compel ERA to provide these documents. ERA opposed the application, arguing that the additional documents were not subject to the discovery order. The court heard arguments from both parties and reserved its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the discovery order issued prior to the commencement of the Practice Note SC Eq 11 requires a party to provide documents located after the Practice Note's commencement.
2. Whether the party is obliged to provide discoverable documents that were not initially identified but were located post the commencement of the Practice Note SC Eq 11.

Held
1. The court held that a party is not required to provide documents located after the commencement of Practice Note SC Eq 11 if the discovery order was issued prior to the Practice Note's commencement.
2. The court held that the party is not obliged to provide discoverable documents that were not initially identified but were located post the commencement of Practice Note SC Eq 11.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the applicability of the discovery order issued prior to the commencement of Practice Note SC Eq 11. The court noted that the discovery order, being in effect prior to the commencement of the Practice Note, was governed by the rules that were in force at the time the order was issued. Given this, the court determined that the scope of the discovery order was fixed as of the date it was issued and did not extend to documents located after the commencement of Practice Note SC Eq 11.

Further, the court considered whether the party was obliged to provide documents that were not initially identified but discovered after the Practice Note's commencement. The court found that the Practice Note SC Eq 11 introduced new obligations for parties in relation to the discovery of documents but did not retroactively alter the obligations of parties with respect to documents identified and ordered to be discovered prior to its commencement. The court emphasised that the obligation to provide documents is tied to the time the discovery order was made and not to subsequent changes in procedural rules.

In reaching its decision, the court relied on the principle that procedural rules do not apply retroactively unless expressly stated. The court also highlighted that the Practice Note SC Eq 11, while introducing stricter obligations for the discovery of documents, did not aim to alter existing legal obligations that had already crystallised prior to its commencement. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that discovery obligations are determined by the rules in force at the time the discovery order is made, and subsequent changes in procedural rules do not retroactively affect those obligations. The court distinguished between the temporal application of discovery orders and the prospective application of new procedural rules, thereby clarifying the scope and limitations of Practice Note SC Eq 11 in relation to pre-existing discovery orders.