Armit v Jeminex Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Armit v Jeminex Limited [2011] FCA 990

Citation: Armit v Jeminex Limited [2011] FCA 990
Parties: MADONNA ANNE ARMIT v JEMINEX LIMITED
File number: NSD 1744 of 2010
Judge: ROBERTSON J
Date of judgment: 22 August 2011
Corrigendum: 30 August 2011
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Discovery –  proceedings under Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and for negligent misrepresentation, breach of contract and under the Contracts Review Act 1980 (NSW) – parties’ categories of discovery disputed – claim that categories too broad – claim for legal professional privilege – various categories accepted, amended and rejected as insufficiently related to the issues between the parties on the pleadings
Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Contracts Review Act 1980 (NSW)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Cases cited: Austral Dutch Kaolin Pty Ltd v Hanjin P&C Co Ltd [2011] FCA 638 distinguished
Date of hearing: 22 August 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 65
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr G Adelstein of Diamond Conway Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms N Bearup
Solicitor for the Respondent: Sachs Gerace Lawyers

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Armit v Jeminex Limited [2011] FCA 990

CORRIGENDUM

1.In paragraph 64 of the Reasons for Judgment, in the last sentence at line 5, the word “be” should be omitted.

2.In paragraph 65 of the Reasons for Judgment, in the first sentence at line 1, the word “the” should be inserted between “to” and “costs”.

I certify that the preceding two (2) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Corrigendum to the Reasons for Judgment herein of the Honourable Justice Robertson

Associate:

Dated:        30 August 2011


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1744 of 2010

BETWEEN:

MADONNA ANNE ARMIT
Applicant

AND:

JEMINEX LIMITED
Respondent

JUDGE:

ROBERTSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 AUGUST 2011

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

On or before 4 October 2011, the respondent give discovery to the applicant of the following categories of documents:

1. All documents brought into existence on or before 31 March 2008 recording or evidencing the acquisition of the ISAS business, including but not limited to: –

(i)The sales or acquisition agreements referred to in paragraph 16 of the Statement of Claim;

(ii). . .

(iii)Documents recording the negotiations in respect of the applicant's sale of shares in ISAS to the respondent, including any terms and conditions of the ISAS acquisition or sale of business;

(iv) . . .

(v) . . . .

2.Any document evidencing or recording any of the alleged representations which are in issue on the pleadings.

3.All documents recording or evidencing: –

(i) . . .

(ii)The employment contract with the applicant;

(iii). . .

(iv). . .

4.All documents recording or evidencing communications in respect of Firesistex, Quantum Guard or other products in development by ISAS in the period 14 March 2008 through to 2 April 2009.

5.All documents recording or evidencing the performance of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Armit v Jeminex Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 990
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Armit v Jeminex Limited involved a dispute between the parties regarding the scope and extent of discovery of documents in proceedings under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and for negligent misrepresentation, breach of contract and under the Contracts Review Act 1980 (NSW). The parties contested various categories of documents, with the applicant resisting certain categories on grounds such as relevance and legal professional privilege. The court was required to determine which categories of documents should be ordered for discovery and whether subpoenas should be issued to third parties.

The court analysed each category of documents proposed for discovery, accepting some categories as sufficiently related to the issues on the pleadings, rejecting others as too broad or not relevant, and ordering amendments where necessary. The court rejected the applicant’s claim for legal professional privilege regarding certain advice received. Regarding subpoenas, the court indicated an unwillingness to issue them to third parties where the material was at least in part within the possession or control of one of the parties. The court also addressed the issue of costs, determining that costs of both applications be costs in the cause, excluding the costs relating to the application to issue subpoenas.

The court ordered the parties to give discovery of specific categories of documents by a specified date, either electronically or in the case of one category, by way of a list. The court also made orders regarding the issuance of subpoenas, which were to be reconsidered after the discovery and inspection process. The final orders specified the categories of documents to be discovered by each party and the deadline for compliance.

Orders

Orders of the court

On or before 4 October 2011, the respondent give discovery to the applicant of the following categories of documents:

1. All documents brought into existence on or before 31 March 2008 recording or evidencing the acquisition of the ISAS business, including but not limited to: –

(i) The sales or acquisition agreements referred to in paragraph 16 of the Statement of Claim;

(ii) . . .

(iii) Documents recording the negotiations in respect of the applicant's sale of shares in ISAS to the respondent, including any terms and conditions of the ISAS acquisition or sale of business;

(iv) . . .

(v) . . . .

2. Any document evidencing or recording any of the alleged representations which are in issue on the pleadings.

3. All documents recording or evidencing: –

(i) . . .

(ii) The employment contract with the applicant;

(iii) . . .

(iv) . . .

4. All documents recording or evidencing communications in respect of Firesistex, Quantum Guard or other products in development by ISAS in the period 14 March 2008 through to 2 April 2009.

5. All documents recording or evidencing the performance of the ISAS business in the period between 14 March 2008 and 2 April 2009.

6. All prospectuses, advertising or marketing material prepared in the period 14 March 2008 to 2 April 2009 in relation to: –

(i) . . .

(ii) . . .

(iii) ISAS;

(iv) . . .

(v) . . .

(vi) . . .

(vii) Firesistex;

(viii) Quantum Guard;

(ix) . . .

7. All documents prepared by Jeminex relating to proposed ISAS sales and marketing strategy for the period between 1 January 2007 and 2 April 2009.

8. . . . .

9. . . .

10. All documents recording or evidencing any management appraisal, HR assessment, disciplinary action, warning, notices, reprimands or termination notifications taken in respect of the applicant during her employment by the respondent.

11. All documents recording or evidencing the respondent’s marketing of the ISAS products for the period 14 March 2008 to 2 April 2009.

12. All documents recording or evidencing the respondent’s control or ownership of offshore factories for the production of fire retardant apparel for the period 1 June 2007 to 2 April 2009.

13. All documents referring to ISAS on the respondent’s websites, including but not limited to the Worksense, Heatley or Beaver websites, in the period 14 March 2008 to 2 April 2009.

14. All documents recording or evidencing any assistance provided by the respondent to the applicant in integrating ISAS products into the respondent’s sales distribution and marketing or product development programs in the period 14 March 2008 to 2 April 2009.

15. All documents recording or evidencing the development, manufacture, marketing and sale of Fire Protected Apparel products within the Jeminex Group, other than the ISAS product, in the period 14 March 2008 to 2 April 2009.

16. . . .

17. . . .

18. . . . .

19. All documents recording consideration by the respondent of the capital that was to be made available to assist with the ISAS business in the period 1 January 2008 to 30 April 2009.

20. All documents recording or evidencing the termination or proposed termination of the applicant’s employment as ISAS Business Manager with the respondent.

21. . . .

22. All documents recording or evidencing the due diligence undertaken by the respondent prior to entering into the ISAS Sale Acquisition Agreement for the period 1 January 2007 to 14 March 2008.

23. . . .

On or before 4 October 2011, the applicant give discovery to the respondent of the following categories of documents:

(a) all documents showing product sales made by Industrial Safety Apparel Solutions Pty Ltd (“ISAS”) between 30 January 2005 and 14 March 2008, including the terms of those sales;

(b) all documents evidencing each of the actual or proposed transactions in the Sales Forecast provided by the applicant to the respondent in an email sent by the applicant to Mr Kevin Jacobsen at 11.26 am on 20 January 2008, and in particular all documents evidencing or containing:

(i) the actual or proposed transactions included in the Sales Forecast and relating to the Status provided for each of these transactions; and

(ii) all communications between ISAS and each of the parties to the proposed transactions in the Sales Forecast and concerning each of the actual or proposed transactions referred to and its Status.

(c) all documents showing how the projected sales of $2.8m referred to in the Sales Forecast were to be achieved;

(d) the negotiations between ISAS and the respondent in respect of the applicant’s sale of shares in ISAS to the respondent, and in particular any document evidencing or recording any of the alleged representations which are in issue on the pleadings;

(e) the advice received by the applicant concerning the sale of the applicant’s shares in ISAS to the respondent, the share acquisition agreement and the applicant’s entitlement to rely on any alleged representation made in connection with the sale of the applicant’s shares in ISAS to the respondent which are in issue on the pleadings;

(f) the applicant’s assessment for the period 1 June 2007 to 31 March 2008 of how ISAS’ financial position would be affected by the respondent’s acquisition of the applicant’s ISAS shares and the applicant’s forecast of ISAS’ financial position;

(g) for the period 1 June 2007 to 31 March 2008, documents containing or recording the applicant’s consideration of the earn out budget and how it might be achieved;

(h) the applicant’s alleged expectations regarding the customers that ISAS would retain or acquire; the contracts that would be entered into with them; the sales that would be achieved and the products that would be developed following the acquisition of the applicant’s ISAS shares and in particular all documents containing or recording the applicant’s expectations referred to above and the lack of fulfilment of those expectations;

(i) any document showing the applicant’s expectations as to the distribution, marketing, manufacturing plant and supply chain that would be available to ISAS in the Post Acquisition Period, and any document containing or recording the non-fulfilment of those expectations;

(j) any document showing the applicant’s expectations as to the information technology that would be available to ISAS in the Post Acquisition Period, and any document containing or recording the non-fulfilment of those expectations;

(k) any document showing the applicant’s expectations as to access to the services of Mr van Buiten that would be available to ISAS in the Post Acquisition Period, and any document recording or containing the non-fulfilment of those expectations.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Insofar as the applicant seeks to resist this category because it requires a judgment, I also reject that contention. The category seeks advice received. This is a matter within the applicant's knowledge.CONCLUSION I order discovery in the terms that I have indicated, and that the parties by 4 October 2011 give discovery as ordered either electronically, or certainly in the case of category (e), by way of a list. There was a question about subpoenas. At present I refuse leave to issue the seven or ten subpoenas. That can stand over until the discovery and inspection process takes place, but I would indicate that at present I would be unwilling to grant leave to issue subpoenas to third parties where it is material that is not exclusively within the possession or control of the third parties, but at least in part is material that is be within the possession or control of one or other of the parties. In relation to costs question I acknowledge the force of what counsel for the respondent, put to me however, in terms of court time, the time for the various categories has been about equal. Further, the respondent did not file any written submissions on the topic of the applicant’s discovery. I also take into account that there was no detailed response at any time by the respondent to the applicant’s claim. It was put at the level of generality. So looking at the costs question globally – as I think I should, rather than category by category – my order is that costs be costs in the cause. That is costs of both applications be costs in the cause. I exclude the costs in relation to the application to issue subpoenas.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I reject this category. It is far too widely cast by reference to the issues that arise on the pleadings.19. All documents recording consideration by the respondent of evidencing or referring to the funds and the capital that was to be made available to assist with the ISAS business in the period 1 January 2008 to 30 April 2009. Again, it is a category where the respondent indicated a willingness to accept a narrower class. I order discovery of this category as amended by me.20. All documents recording or evidencing or referring to the termination or proposed termination of the applicant’s employment as ISAS Business Manager with the respondent. With the marked words struck through category 20 is agreed to and I order that discovery be given in those terms.21. All documents recording, or evidencing or referring to the performance of the ISAS business in the period 2 April 2009 to date being and indicative of: –(a) The cash flow;(b) Aged debtors;(c)Forecasts for sales, revenue and expenses;(d) Budgets;(e) Annual, half yearly or quarterly profit and loss statements;(f) Balance sheets; (h) Business plans;(h) Growth projections;(i) ISAS contracts that were cancelled or not renewed;(j) Profit distributions including dividends paid in relation to the ISAS business of a period 1 April 2009 to date;(k) Cross-subsidising of ISAS by other members of the Jeminex Group, either by cash injection, and use of resources, including IT equipment, office sharing, equipment sharing and common use of personnel. I do not order discovery in accordance with category 21. In my view, for the period there specified performance of the ISAS business is not shown to be relevant on the pleadings.22. All documents recording, or evidencing or referring to: –(a) Tthe due diligence, enquiries and audits undertaken by the respondent prior to entering into ISAS Sale Acquisition Agreement for the period 1 January 2007 to 14 March 2008;(b) The due diligence, enquiries and audits undertaken by the respondent during the earn out period, namely 14 March 2008 to 2 April 2009;(c) Any communications between the respondent and the AMP Group relating to the ISAS earn out period between 14 March 2008 to 2 April 2009; and(d) All sale acquisitions, enquiries and due diligence undertaken by the respondent in respect of John Smith and Noble Agencies. I order discovery of this category as amended by me. I accept that in terms due diligence may not be relevant on the pleadings, but in my view it would cover relevantly what the respondent knew about the ISAS business in that time period.23. The Income Tax Returns and Notices of Assessment for the Respondent for the financial years ending 30 June 2008, 2009, 2010 and 2011. The relevance of this category has not been established and I will not make an order for discovery of those documents. In other words, this category is too general and insufficiently related to the issues on the pleadings. Turning next to the respondent’s request, the respondent gave a notice of discovery dated 1 June 2011.