Arkinstall & Spies v Gold Coast City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

[1997] QLC 45

 
LAND COURT

BRISBANE

11 APRIL 1997

Re:   A94-74
                 Determination of Compensation -
                 Resumption by the Council of the Shire of Albert
                 for Rubbish Depot Purposes -
Acquisition of Land Act 1967

BETWEEN:

Elizabeth B. Arkinstall and Royleen D. Spies

Claimants

and

Gold Coast City Council

Respondent Constructing Authority

J U D G M E N T

By proclamation published in the Government Gazette on 22 July 1994, the Council of the Shire of Albert, as it then was, took from that date, a number of parcels of land near Nerang for rubbish depot purposes. 
     One of those parcels was owned by the claimants in this matter and was described as Lot 2 on Registered Plan 142778 containing an area of 2.979 ha, being the whole of the land in Certificate of Title Volume 6405, Folio 190, Parish of Nerang.  The land is situated about 1 km north-east of the Town of Nerang, a short distance easterly of the Pacific Highway overpass of the Southport-Nerang Road.  It has frontage to Southport-Nerang Road as its south-eastern boundary, has slightly irregular rhomboid-type shape, running through in a north-westerly direction to the Pacific Highway.
     All town services namely electricity, town water, telephone, sewerage and garbage collection were available to the subject land.  The land falls slightly away from the Southport-Nerang Road frontage before rising moderately to a centrally positioned ridge then gradually falls away to the rear Pacific Highway boundary.  It is vacant land with green and regrowth timber cover.
     The land was zoned “Future Urban” under the 1988 Town Planning Scheme for the Shire of Albert in force at the date of resumption and remained within that zone in the 1995 Town Planning Scheme, the draft of which had been displayed in 1993.  In the 1982 and 1988 Strategic Plans, the location of the subject land was in the vicinity of the non-cadastral and “broadbrush”  boundary of the “Industry” and “Open Space” designation of preferred dominant land use.  In the draft Strategic Plan displayed in 1993 the “Open Space” designation was changed to “Special Development” although still with the broadbrush boundary between it and the “Industry” designation.  In the Strategic Plan as gazetted subsequent to the resumption (in 1995) the Southport-Nerang Road alignment was shown with more precision with the subject land clearly within the “Industry” designation of preferred dominant land use. 
     The principal issue in this matter is whether the potential of the land at the date of resumption was for rezoning to permit multi-unit residential development (the claimants’ case) or light industrial development (the respondent’s case).
     The neighbouring property to the north-east, between the subject land and Old Coach Road was also taken by the Council for the same purpose one week later (29 July 1994).  This property was owned by Mr P.F. Laerkesen, and for similar reasons dispute had arisen as to the compensation payable consequent upon that resumption.  The claimants in this matter and Mr Laerkesen through their respective solicitors, had instructed Mr J.E. Gallagher, QC,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Arkinstall & Spies v Gold Coast City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QLC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Arkinstall & Spies v Gold Coast City Council involved a dispute over the compensation payable for the resumption of land by the Gold Coast City Council for rubbish depot purposes under the Acquisition of Land Act 1967. The claimants, Elizabeth B. Arkinstall and Royleen D. Spies, owned a parcel of land that was taken by the Council for the rubbish depot. The central issue was whether the potential of the land at the date of resumption was for rezoning to permit multi-unit residential development, as claimed by the claimants, or light industrial development, as argued by the respondent. This dispute also encompassed valuation considerations and the risks involved in achieving the proposed rezoning.

The court examined the relevant town planning schemes and strategic plans to determine the potential highest and best use of the land. Expert evidence from town planners and valuers was considered, with the claimants' experts asserting that the land was suitable for multi-unit residential development, while the respondent's experts maintained that the land was intended for industrial use. The court found that while the land was zoned "Future Urban," indicating a holding zone for urban development, there was no certainty that it would be rezoned for residential use. The court also considered that the likelihood of successfully rezoning the land for residential purposes was better than not, but not significantly so.

In terms of valuation, the court adopted a "top-down" approach, acknowledging the potential for residential rezoning but also the associated risks. The court concluded that a prudent vendor would have understood the speculative element involved in the residential rezoning, and any premium paid above industrial value would be at risk if the rezoning failed. The court adopted a potential unit site value of $20,000 as rezoned and applied a discount factor to account for the risks involved, resulting in an as-zoned valuation of $956,250 for the subject land.

The court ordered the respondent to pay compensation of $956,250 for the loss of land, along with disturbance costs of $9,304, totalling $965,554. Interest was also ordered to be paid on the compensation amount.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.