FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited v Konami Australia Pty Limited (No 3) [2022] FCA 1373
File number: NSD 1429 of 2011 Judgment of: NICHOLAS J Date of judgment: 18 November 2022 Catchwords: PATENTS – account of profits – apportionment of profits – availability of apportionment – characterisation of invention – consideration of form of claims – consideration of substance of the invention – whether broadest claim for an electronic gaming machine (“EGM”) including feature game with proportional trigger or to feature game with proportional trigger – whether substance of invention an EGM, a feature game with a proportional trigger or a proportional trigger – apportionment of profit made on sale of EGMs and conversion kits including feature game with proportional trigger – whether apportionment precluded by form of declaratory and injunctive relief – whether apportionment precluded by previous finding that invention was for a manner of manufacture – whether apportionment not available because infringing EGMs and conversion kits would not have been made or sold without a feature game with the proportional trigger – significance of the applicant’s commercial embodiments of the patented invention – extent to which their commercial success attributable to invention – allowable deductions – whether respondent entitled to deduction in respect of a proportion of general overheads – whether respondent suffered opportunity cost in making and selling infringing products – whether respondent would have made and sold non-infringing products in place of infringing products – significance of surplus manufacturing capacity – whether allocation method proposed by respondent provides a reasonably acceptable basis for allocating overheads – whether respondent’s proposed allocation of overheads should be discounted on basis that alternative non-infringing products would have been less successful than infringing products – whether loss made by respondent in certain financial years should be excluded from profit calculations – whether profit should be calculated on a pre-tax basis – whether respondent should be required to account for future tax benefit – whether award of profits calculated on a pre-tax basis would have that effect – whether adjustment should be made to take account of tax related contingencies – whether damages awarded based on user principle (see below) are an expense attributable to profits from sale of infringing products for which respondent may claim a deduction in calculating profit
DAMAGES – compensatory damages in respect of conversion kits supplied by respondent free of charge – calculation of damages based on user principle – whether as a matter of discretion no damages should be awarded due to mixed nature of applicant’s election – consideration of expert evidence and various licence agreements relating to reasonable royalty rate – consideration of other relevant terms of hypothetical licence governing circumstances in which royalty would be payable – circumstances in which no royalty should be payable – additional damages in respect of conversion kits supplied by respondent free of charge – whether evidence established basis for award of additional damages
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 51A
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Konami Australia... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] FCA 1373
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court’s reasoning and outcome were based on a detailed analysis of the patents, the commercial success of the inventions, and the evidence presented by both parties. The court found that the Konami Licence did not provide a reliable basis for calculating a reasonable royalty rate due to the specific circumstances in which it was negotiated. Instead, the court relied on other licence agreements and expert evidence to determine a reasonable royalty rate. The court also found that the infringing EGMs and conversion kits would have been made and sold without the feature game with the proportional trigger, which supported the apportionment of profits. The court calculated damages based on the user principle, considering the number of infringing products sold and the reasonable royalty rate.
The final orders of the court required the parties to confer and calculate the amounts of profits and damages owed by Konami to Aristocrat, taking into account the court’s reasons for judgment. The parties were also required to notify the court if there were any disagreements regarding the calculations or the form of costs order. The disclosure of the text of the Reasons was initially prohibited, but the parties were allowed to disclose the substance of the Reasons to their respective clients. The court fixed a further hearing to make final orders and any further interlocutory orders restricting publication of any part of the Reasons. Each party was given liberty to apply on three days’ notice.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The parties’ external legal representatives and accounting experts confer for the purpose of calculating:
(a) the amounts (exclusive of interest) that the respondent is required to pay in profits and damages in accordance with the reasons for judgment published today (Reasons); and
(b) interest pursuant to s 51A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) that takes into account, in the case of profits, the financial year in which they were made and, in the case of damages, the financial year in which the NCCs were supplied.
2. The parties are to notify the Associate to Nicholas J as soon as practicable if:
(a) there is any disagreement in relation to the calculations referred to in order 1;
(b) there is any disagreement in relation to the appropriate form of costs order; or
(c) the parties or the accounting experts seek clarification of any ruling in the Reasons.
3. Up to and including 12 December 2022 or until further order, and subject to order 4, the disclosure (by publication or otherwise) of the text of the Reasons be prohibited, other than to and as between:
(a) the external legal representatives of the parties;
(b) any independent expert retained by the parties; and
(c) Court staff.
4. Notwithstanding order 3, the external legal representatives of the parties may disclose to their respective clients (the parties):
(a) the substance of the Reasons; and
(b) so much of the text of the Reasons;
that does not disclose any facts or information in the Reasons which are the subject of orders 2, 3 and 4 of the Orders made on 13 March 2020 (Suppression Orders).
5. On or before 2 December 2022, so as to permit publication of the Reasons, the parties are to confer regarding the following:
(a) what, if any, redactions ought be made in respect of any confidential information in the Reasons having regard to the Suppression Orders; and
(b) whether the Suppression Orders ought be varied and, if so, what variations should be made.
6. On or before 7 December 2022, the parties are to file and serve:
(a) a joint statement setting out the matters in order 5 above which are agreed between them;
(b) failing agreement on any matters in order 5 above, competing orders, redactions (if necessary) and short submissions (limited to 2 pages) in support of their respective positions;
(c) any affidavit evidence to be relied on in support of any application for orders restricting publication of any part of the Reasons.
7. The proceeding be fixed for further hearing at 9.30am on 12 December 2022 for the purpose of making final orders and any further interlocutory orders restricting publication of any part of the Reasons.
8. Each party is given liberty to apply on 3 days’ notice.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
While it may be an analysis of the kind undertaken by Dr Mokdsi may prove useful in the absence of more specific and detailed information with which to evaluate the commercial significance of a patent, I have not found his analysis of any real assistance in this case. For the purposes of determining a reasonable royalty rate for the NCCs, I have given Dr Mokdsi’s analysis very little weight. Consideration Aristocrat submitted that the Konami Licence was the best starting point in determining a reasonable royalty rate because it represented an agreement actually made during the same period between the parties to a hypothetical negotiation in relation to the 689 Patent. It also submitted that it is implicit in Konami’s internal profit assessment as reflected in Exhibit 16 that Konami made (after-tax) net profits of more than $4,300 per Mystical Temple unit, which would more than support a $1,900 or (at least) a $1,250 per unit royalty rate. It is clear that the main purpose of the Konami Licence was to resolve (by the grant of a licence, a release and a discontinuance) the patent claims which Aristocrat asserted against Konami in the letter of demand and in the proceeding. I find that Konami was anxious to reach an agreement with Aristocrat to resolve the proceeding Aristocrat commenced against it and to protect Konami and its customers against the possibility of the customers also being sued for patent infringement. The circumstances in which the Konami Licence was negotiated created a significant incentive for Konami to pay considerably more than what might be regarded as a reasonable sum in respect of a licence in relation to a single game limited to 500 units. With regard to Mr Heberden’s evidence, I do not find his analysis persuasive. He considered that the Konami Licence implied a royalty of $1,900 per unit and that, in his opinion, that was a reasonable royalty for the infringing NCCs supplied by Konami between 2005 and 2016. Mr Heberden stated in his first affidavit that “… the arm’s length royalties for broadly comparable IP indicate that the per unit royalty implied by the Konami 2011 Licence is reasonable”. In support of that statement Mr Heberden relied on information (which he acknowledged to be limited) extracted from the RoyaltyStat database. Most of the licence agreements he identified were, by his own acknowledgement, not good comparables. Of the four licences that he appears to have considered relevant:·The first licence (Progressive Games/Ten Stix) relates to a table game and provides for a fixed per unit fee of US$250 per month and a revenue based component. The technology appears to relate to a jackpot component for a live casino table game. Leaving aside the revenue based component of the royalty, US$250 per month implies an annual royalty of US$3,000 per annum which, assuming an installation (whether EGM or conversion) has a life of five years, equates to a licence fee of US$15,000. In short, it does not appear to me that this licence is at all comparable to the Konami Licence. The very idea that a prospective licensee would agree to pay a royalty of anything like that amount for a licence to use the proportional trigger in either an EGM or a charged conversion (much less a NCC) is in my opinion completely unrealistic.·The second licence (PureDepth/IGT) appears to relate to a multi-layer display for use in gaming machines (i.e. not a jackpot mechanism). The licence fee according to Mr Heberden’s summary is US$125 per unit with a pre-payment royalty of US$3.75 million. In his report Mr Heberden treats this pre-payment of US$3.75 million as a payment additional to the per unit amount. However, assuming that he summarised the information extracted from the database accurately, the lump sum is in fact a pre-payment of royalties which implies a royalty rate of no more than US$125 per unit sold. As sketchy as the information relating to this licence agreement is, it cannot provide any support for the view that a royalty of $1,900 per NCC is reasonable. ·The third licence (IGT/WMS) relates to (inter alia) gaming machines either alone or with a cashless gaming system. According to Mr Heberden’s summary, the licence fee is:An execution fee of USD2 million as consideration for ‘reduced royalty’ shown below.USD300 to USD1,000 per unit, increasing by 30% over 9 years.Mr Heberden treats the US$2 million figure and the per unit figure as cumulative. Whether these figures are in fact cumulative is not clear. In any event, I do not think it is possible to derive any meaningful assistance from the information presented by Mr Heberden given the range of rates quoted (US$300 – US$1,000). The information presented in relation to this licence is too vague to provide any assistance. ·The fourth licence (Lowden/Archon) provides for a per unit licence fee of US$350 per month. What I have said in relation to the first licence also applies here. In this case the monthly licence fee is even higher, implying a royalty of US$21,000 per unit assuming a life of five years.