Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Global Gaming Supplies Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
CRENNAN, KIEFEL, GAGELER AND KEANE JJ

Matter No S168/2012

ARISTOCRAT TECHNOLOGIES AUSTRALIA PTY
LTD & ORS  APPLICANTS

AND

GLOBAL GAMING SUPPLIES PTY LTD & ORS                 RESPONDENTS

Matter No S169/2012

ARISTOCRAT TECHNOLOGIES AUSTRALIA PTY
LTD & ORS  APPLICANTS

AND

RIAD ALLAM & ORS  RESPONDENTS

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Global Gaming Supplies Pty Ltd

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Allam

[2013] HCA 21

Date of Order:  2 May 2013
Date of Publication of Reasons:  10 May 2013

S168/2012 & S169/2012

ORDER

In each matter, special leave refused with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

A J L Bannon SC with J M Hennessy SC for the applicants in both matters (instructed by Gilbert + Tobin Lawyers)

M L D Einfeld QC with A C Harding for the respondents in S168/2012 and the second to fifth respondents in S169/2012 (instructed by Paul Bard Lawyers)

M Green for the first and sixth respondents in S169/2012 (instructed by Bruce & Stewart Lawyers)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. By orders made on 25 May 2012 the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia allowed appeals by the respondents against a judgment of a single judge awarding damages against them for infringement of the applicants' copyright.  The copyright related to literary and artistic works in and on components of electronic gaming machines manufactured by the applicants.  The applicants sought special leave to appeal to this Court against the decisions of the Full Court.  Their applications for special leave were referred to an enlarged Bench by orders of French CJ and Heydon J made on 16 November 2012.

  2. After hearing argument on 2 May 2013 this Court made orders dismissing the applications for special leave with costs and stated that reasons for its decision would be published subsequently. The question upon which special leave was sought was whether the Full Court had erred in characterising the primary judge's reasoning about evidence of email communications as inferring a "tendency" on the part of the respondents to engage in infringing conduct. Section 97 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ("the Evidence Act") provides that, absent compliance with conditions including reasonable notice, evidence of a tendency that a person has or had is not admissible to prove that a person has or had a tendency to act in a particular way. The applicants argued that the Full Court was wrong to say that the primary judge used the email evidence to infer tendency and that the appeal to that Court should not have been allowed on that basis. As appears from the reasons that follow, this Court was of the opinion that the Full Court's characterisation of the primary judge's reasoning was open to it and not attended with sufficient doubt to warrant the grant of special leave.

  3. The case was one of some complexity factually and procedurally.  It…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Global Gaming Su... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] HCA 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd and others (the applicants) brought proceedings against Global Gaming Supplies Pty Ltd, Impact Gaming Pty Ltd, Tonita Enterprise Pty Ltd, and individuals associated with these companies (the respondents). The applicants alleged that the respondents refurbished and sold gaming machines that incorporated pirated copies of software and artwork in which the applicants held copyright, thereby infringing sections 36 and 38 of the *Copyright Act 1968* (Cth). The primary judge found that some of the impugned transactions involved gaming machines containing infringing components, inferring that the respondents had knowledge of the infringing conduct. The Full Court of the Federal Court later characterised the primary judge's use of certain email communications as evidence of a tendency to engage in infringing conduct, without explicit compliance with section 97(1) of the *Evidence Act 1995* (Cth).

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the Full Court was entitled to conclude that the primary judge had relied on email communications as tendency evidence, notwithstanding that the primary judge had not explicitly used the term "tendency" or referred to section 97 of the *Evidence Act 1995* (Cth). The applicants contended that the primary judge's reasoning did not demonstrate a reliance on the emails to establish a tendency to infringe copyright.

The High Court considered that, despite the absence of explicit language, the inferences drawn by the primary judge regarding the respondents' sanctioning, approval, or countenance of copyright infringements by others were not directly linked to the specific infringing transactions. This suggested that the reasoning process, in part, involved discerning a pattern of behaviour or a disposition on the part of the respondents to deal with articles whose creation infringed the applicants' copyright. Consequently, the High Court found that it was open to the Full Court to characterise the primary judge's approach to the email evidence as based on the discernment of a tendency.

Special leave to appeal was refused in each matter, with costs awarded to the respondents. The High Court concluded that the Full Court's view of the primary judge's use of the email evidence was reasonably open and that the applications did not involve a question of law of public importance.

Orders

Orders of the court

In each matter, special leave refused with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case was one of some complexity factually and procedurally. It is helpful to outline the background as appears from the judgments both at first instance and in the Full Court of the Federal Court. Factual and procedural background The applicants manufactured and sold electronic gaming machines and game software. Each of the applicants' gaming machines incorporated computer programs that play games of chance displayed on a video screen. The computer programs that embodied the games, and compliance plates and artwork displayed on the machines, were literary and artistic works within the meaning of s 10 of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ("the Copyright Act"). Copyright subsisted in those works and was owned by the applicants. The respondents Global Gaming Supplies Pty Ltd ("Global") and Impact Gaming Pty Ltd ("Impact") were in the business of selling second hand gaming machines to overseas markets. The respondents Anthony Andrews and Francis Cragen were the sole directors and shareholders of Global and Impact respectively. Those parties are referred to collectively as the Global and Impact respondents. The other corporate respondent is Tonita Enterprise Pty Ltd. Riad Allam is its principal. He and his company are referred to in these reasons as the Tonita respondents. Mr Allam is a gaming technician who provided gaming machine refurbishment services to Global. From at least October 2004 there was a joint venture between the Global and Impact respondents for the supply of refurbished gaming machines to overseas markets. The Tonita respondents carried out significant technical work for the joint venture. The applicants' gaming machine software was stored in removable memory chips known as erasable programmable read only memory chips ("EPROMs"). The compliance plates were attached to the applicants' gaming machines to meet regulatory requirements. The essence of the applicants' case, as the primary judge described it, was that the Global and Impact respondents were in a joint venture together "to counterfeit and sell, principally in South America, second hand gaming machines assembled in Australia using pirated copies of materials in which the applicants hold the copyright." The principal question as his Honour put it, was whether he could infer copyright infringement "in the absence of direct evidence of the gaming machines which are said to have been counterfeited." The applicants alleged 54 transactions in which some or all of the respondents were said to have exported "counterfeit gaming machines to South America." These involved a total of 618 machines. The applicants were not in a position to identify which components in the gaming machines in the impugned transactions involved infringements of any copyright of the applicants. In the end the primary judge was satisfied that 11 of the 54 impugned transactions involved gaming machines which contained infringing components. It was not possible, however, to conclude on the evidence precisely which components in the machines, the subject of those transactions, were "counterfeit" components.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN, KIEFEL, GAGELER AND KEANE JJ
The applicants made detailed written submissions criticising the Full Court's characterisation of the primary judge's use of the email evidence. They contended that there was nothing said in the primary judge's reasons which indicated that his Honour had used the emails as tendency evidence. While the primary judge did not use the word "tendency" nor refer to s 97 of the Evidence Act his Honour, as already pointed out, used the email evidence in such a way as to justify the Full Court's view of his reasoning process. The applicants referred to elements of his Honour's reasoning which, it was said, did not link his findings about the infringing transactions to evidence of a tendency. However, the inferences that his Honour drew, that the Global and Impact respondents "sanctioned, approved or countenanced the infringements of copyright carried out by the Tonita respondents", did not appear to have been based upon conduct related directly to the particularised infringing transactions. Once that much is accepted, and having regard to other findings of the primary judge mentioned earlier, it must also be accepted that it was open to the Full Court to characterise his Honour's reasoning as based upon discernment of a tendency on the part of the respondents to act in a particular way which involved dealing with articles, the making of which infringed copyright of the applicants. Conclusion It is sufficient to say that the Full Court's view of the approach taken by the primary judge to the use of the email evidence was reasonably open. The applications did not involve a question of law of public importance[1]. The applicants did not contend that they involved such a question. They argued, in effect, that the interests of justice, either generally or in this particular case, required consideration by the High Court of the Full Court's judgment[2]. For the reasons given, the Court did not accept that argument and special leave was refused with costs in each application.[1]Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 35A(a)(i).[2]Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 35A(b).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN, KIEFEL, GAGELER AND KEANE JJ