IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited v Bally Technologies ANZ Pty Ltd [2015] APO 68
Patent:2011101675
Title:A method and system for gaming
Patentee: Bally Technologies ANZ Pty Ltd
Opponent: Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited
Delegate: Xavier Gisz
Decision Date: 26 October 2015
Hearing Date: Written submissions filed on 14 July 2015, 29 July 2015 and 4 August 2015
Catchwords: PATENTS - opposition to the allowance of amendments under subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990 – amended claims in-substance disclosed – amended claims in-substance fall within the scope of the granted claims – amended claims and comply with subsections 40(2) and (3) – amendment allowed – cost in accordance with Schedule 8 awarded against the opponent.
Representation: Patent applicant: Franke Hyland
Opponent:Griffith Hack
IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Patent:2011101675
Title:A method and system for gaming
Patentee: Bally Technologies ANZ Pty Ltd
Date of Decision: 26 October 2015
DECISION
The opposition fails on all grounds relied on. The proposed amendments satisfy the requirements of subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patent Act 1990.
I allow the amendments.
I award costs against Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited.
REASONS FOR DECISION
Background
Australian Innovation Patent 2011101675 (the Patent) in the name of SHFL Entertainment (Australasia) Pty Limited (which subsequently changed name to Bally Technologies ANZ Pty Ltd (the Patentee)) was filed on 21 December 2011 as a divisional of 2011201004 which in turn claims priority from Australian provisional applications 2010903536 and 2010903538, filed on 7 August 2010 and 8 August 2010 respectively.
The patent was advertised as certified on 16 August 2012. On 27 May 2014 a re-examination report was issued. Amendments were proposed on 28 July 2014. Another re-examination report was issued on 30 September 2014. Amendments were proposed on 28 November 2014. Another re-examination report was issued on 15 January 2015 noting that, once allowed, the amendments would overcome the objections raised in the previous re-examination report. The amendments were advertised for opposition on 29 January 2015.
The amendments were opposed by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited (the Opponent) on 27 March 2015. A Statement of Grounds and Particulars was filed on 27 April 2015. Evidence in support in the form of a declaration by Benjamin Ellis was filed on 22 June 2015.
Grounds of Opposition
The statement of grounds and particulars opposes the amendments under subsection 102(1) and paragraphs 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act. Under paragraph 102(2)(b), it is asserted that the proposed amendments would not comply with subsections 40(2) or 40(3).
Preliminary matter
On 4 September 2015 the Opponent filed another statutory declaration of Benjamin Ellis made on 13 August 2015. The letter accompanying the declaration stated:
“We draw the Commissioner's attention to the Statutory Declaration of Benjamin Ellis (copy without annexures attached) filed in the related opposition to the amendment of Australian patent application 2011201004. In reaching a decision in this matter, the Commissioner may wish to consult this document under Regulation 5.23.
In particular, the Commissioner…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited v Bally Techno... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] APO 68
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Background
Background to the litigation
Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited filed an opposition to the proposed amendments on 27 March 2015. A Statement of Grounds and Particulars was filed on 27 April 2015. Evidence in support in the form of a declaration by Benjamin Ellis was filed on 22 June 2015. Another statutory declaration of Benjamin Ellis was filed on 4 September 2015. Written submissions were filed on 14 July 2015, 29 July 2015 and 4 August 2015. The decision was handed down on 26 October 2015.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Do the proposed amendments satisfy the requirements of subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990?
2. Are the amended claims in substance disclosed in the specification as filed?
3. Do the amended claims in substance fall within the scope of the claims of the specification before amendment?
4. Do the amended claims comply with subsections 40(2) and 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990?
Held
1. The opposition to the proposed amendments to the patent fails on all grounds.
2. The proposed amendments satisfy the requirements of subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990.
3. The amended claims are in substance disclosed in the specification as filed.
4. The amended claims in substance fall within the scope of the claims of the specification before amendment.
5. The amended claims comply with subsections 40(2) and 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990.
6. The court allows the amendments to the patent.
7. Costs are awarded against Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited in accordance with Schedule 8.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The opposition to the proposed amendments to Australian Innovation Patent 2011101675, owned by Bally Technologies ANZ Pty Ltd, was heard and decided by Delegate Xavier Gisz. The opposition, filed by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited, was based on several grounds under the Patents Act 1990. The Delegate examined the amendments in light of the Act, focusing on whether they satisfied the requirements of subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b), if they were in substance disclosed in the specification as filed, if they fell within the scope of the claims before amendment, and if they complied with subsections 40(2) and 40(3) of the Act.
The Delegate considered that the amendments introduced terms such as 'non-scatter', 'any of a fixed number of predetermined winning symbol combinations and positions', and 'base wagers'. The court found that the term 'non-scatter' served only to narrow the scope of the claims and was in substance disclosed in the specification as filed, thus satisfying subsections 102(1) and 102(2)(a) of the Act. The term 'any of a fixed number of predetermined winning symbol combinations and positions' was found to be broader than the term 'payline', and there was ample disclosure of 'paylines' which provided fair basis for 'predetermined winning symbol combinations'. This amendment was also found to be in substance disclosed and within the scope of the claims before amendment. The term 'base wagers' was found to be clear and fairly based on the description, and its meaning was consistent with the examples in the specification, thus satisfying subsections 102(1) and 102(2)(a) of the Act.
The Delegate concluded that the proposed amendments satisfied the requirements of subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990. The amendments were allowed, and costs were awarded against Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited in accordance with Schedule 8 of the Patents Regulations.