Architects Marshall v Lake Macquarie City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION:

Architects Marshall v Lake Macquarie City Council [2005] NSWLEC 78

PARTIES:

Applicant:
Architects Marshall Pty Ltd

Respondent:
Lake Macquarie City Council

FILE NUMBER(S):

10663 of 2004

CORAM:

Roseth SC

KEY ISSUES:

Development Application :- Planning principle
weight to be given to evidence on aesthetics

DATES OF HEARING: 06/12/2004 to 09/12/2004, 15/12/2004, 21/12/2004, 14/02/2005, 24/02/2005
 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 


03/01/2005

LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:

Applicant:
Mr C Shaw, solicitor of Shaw Reynolds

Respondent:
Mr G Newport, barrister
instructed by Mr G Long, solicitor of P Rees


JUDGMENT:

      THE LAND AND
      ENVIRONMENT COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES

      Roseth SC

      1 March 2005

      10663 of 2004 Architect Marshall v Lake Macquarie City Council

      JUDGMENT

1 Senior Commissioner: This is an appeal against the deemed refusal of a development application to demolish the existing buildings and erect a multiple dwelling housing project containing ten dwellings over basement parking on lots 1 and 2 DP 800421 and lot 306 DP 11537, known as 34-36 Fishing Point Road, Rathmines.


      The site

2 The site is on the west side of Fishing Point Road, between the intersections with Burnage Place and Sunlight Parade. It is an amalgamation of three allotments, each with a dwelling house on it. It is irregular in shape, has an area of 2,365m2, a frontage of 31m to Fishing Point Road and a frontage of 6m to Burnage Place.

3 Five allotments, each containing a detached dwelling, adjoin the site. To the north they are 32 Fishing Point Road and 4 Burnage Place. To the southwest they are 8 Burnage Place and 2 Sunlight Parade. The fifth allotment, 38 Fishing Point Road, adjoins to the south. It contains a three-storey house.

4 The locality contains one and two-storey detached houses. The three-storey house on 38 Fishing Point Road is an exception.

      The proposal and its history

5 The applicant proposes to demolish the three existing buildings and to erect a multiple dwelling housing project containing ten dwellings over basement parking. Above the ground the dwellings appear to be in three buildings. One, containing four dwellings, faces Fishing Point Road. The second, containing five dwellings, is located in the centre of the site. The third, containing one dwelling, faces towards Burnage Place. Each dwelling has its separate entrance and private open space accessible from the living room. Thus the proposal has the characteristics of a townhouse development, called multiple dwellings in the local environmental plan. It is classified as a residential flat building only because of its continuous basement-parking floor that extends under all three buildings.

6 The applicant lodged the application in December 2003. Following notification, the council received 200 submissions. The applicant lodged the appeal in June 2004. At the time of hearing the council had not determined the application.

7 The Court heard the appeal on four days, 6, 7, 8 and 9 December 2004. On 21 December the Court handed down its preliminary findings on the issues. The parties agreed on directions requiring…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Architects Marshall v Lake Macquarie City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWLEC 78
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Architects Marshall v Lake Macquarie City Council, the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales reviewed an appeal against the deemed refusal of a development application by Architects Marshall Pty Ltd to demolish existing buildings and construct a multiple dwelling housing project on a site in Rathmines. The site was zoned for medium and high-density housing under the new Local Environmental Plan 2004 (LEP 04), which had replaced the previous zoning. The application proposed a development with ten dwellings over basement parking, which was denser than the surrounding single-family homes but complied with the new zoning and planning controls.

The Court heard objections from local residents and evidence from planning experts retained by both parties. The primary concerns raised by the objectors were the impact on the character of the locality, potential traffic congestion, parking issues, and loss of views. The council's expert argued that the proposal was visually dominant and disproportionately massive, while the applicant's expert believed the revised two-storey design was an improvement but still not fully acceptable to the objectors.

The Court concluded that while the proposal introduced a new element to Rathmines, the 2(2) zoning permitted medium and high-density housing, and the proposal was consistent with the zoning objectives. The Court found that the proposal complied substantially with the setback and building envelope requirements, and the objections regarding the architectural style did not carry major weight as they were based on individual opinions rather than widely accepted professional views. The Court also upheld the applicant's objection to the Floor Space Ratio (FSR) control under the State Environmental Planning Policy 1 – Development Standards, as the new LEP 04 had removed the FSR control.

The Court found that the proposal's impact on nearby properties, particularly the loss of water views, was reasonable given the compliance with planning controls. The proposal also addressed internal amenity concerns through amendments. Consequently, the Court upheld the appeal and granted development consent subject to conditions to ensure compliance with various planning and environmental requirements, including provisions for stormwater management, erosion control, and contributions to public facilities.

The final orders included granting development consent for the proposed residential flat building, imposing conditions to address the identified impacts and compliance issues, and requiring the payment of contributions to the council for community facilities and open space acquisition. The Court also outlined the process for obtaining necessary certificates and approvals before commencing construction and occupation of the development.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.