Archibald v Commissioners of Stamps

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read
8 CLR 739

ROBERT JOHN ARCHIBALD

THE COMMISSIONERS OF STAMPS

RESPONDENTS.

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

QUEENSLAND. Succession duties-Gifts made within 12 months of death-Aggregation - -Succession

and Probate Duties Act 1892 (Q.), (56 Vict. No. 13), secs. 3, 4, 12-Succession and Probate Duties Act 1904 (Q.), (4 Edw. VII. No. 17), sec. 4.

Sec. 12 of the Succession and Probate Duties Act 1892 is applicable to a gift coming under sec. 4 of the Succession and Probate Duties Act 1904, SO as to render the donee liable to pay succession duty.

In estimating the amount of duty payable, the aggregate value of all the several successions passing to all persons to whom beneficial interests come on the death of the predecessor should be taken into consideration and not merely the independent value of each particular succession.

In re Blissett, 1903 St. R. Qd., 320, considered.

ON 24th of August 1906 the Honourable John Archibald transferred by way of immediate gift to each of his seven children, including the appellant, personal property approxi- mately of the value of £4,100 in each case.

The Honourable John Archibald died on 20th day of May 1907, and on 23rd day of September 1907 probate of his will and codicil was granted. All his children survived him. In September 1907 the Commissioners of Stamps made an assess- ment on the appellant in the sum of £206 5s. 9d. in respect of the gift to him of the sum of £4,100, being at the rate of

8 CLR 740

£5 per centum on that sum, whereupon the appellant, being

dissatisfied with the assessment, duly gave notice in writing to the Commissioners of his intention to appeal against the assessment, and duly furnished the statement of the grounds of such appeal in accordance with the provisions of sec. 50 of the Succession and Probate Duties Act 1892. The appellant con- tended that no succession duty was payable on the gift to him, or, in the alternative, that if any succession duty was payable in respect of the gift, then such duty was payable, in any event, at no greater rate than £2 per centum on the £4,100 and should not have been assessed at a rate ascertained by aggregating the amounts of the gifts above mentioned, nor at a rate ascertained by aggregating those amounts with the value of the testator's estate, nor as if the gift to the appellant had formed part of such estate at the time of his death. The appellant asked the Supreme Court of Queensland to declare whether (1) any succession duty whatsoever was payable on the said gift to him; or (2) if any succession duty was found payable, at what rate should such duty be assessed. The Supreme Court answered (1) in the affirmative, and (2) at five per centum.

From this decision the appellant now appealed to the High Court.

The relevant provisions of the Statutes sufficiently appear in the judgments hereunder.

Stumm and Fowles,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Archibald v Commissioners of Stamps and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1909] HCA 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland. The appellant, Robert John Archibald, was appealing an assessment of succession duty made by the Commissioners of Stamps. The dispute arose from a gift of personal property valued at approximately £4,100 made to the appellant by his father, the Honourable John Archibald, less than twelve months before the father's death. The Commissioners assessed duty at 5 per cent, which the appellant argued was excessive.

The legal issues before the High Court were twofold. Firstly, whether section 12 of the *Succession and Probate Duties Act 1892* (Qld) applied to gifts made *inter vivos* within twelve months of death, as provided for by section 4 of the *Succession and Probate Duties Act 1904* (Qld), so as to render the donee liable for succession duty. Secondly, if duty was payable, the court had to determine whether the rate of duty should be calculated based on the value of the individual succession (the gift to the appellant) or on the aggregate value of all successions passing from the predecessor upon his death.

The Court reasoned that the *Succession and Probate Duties Act 1904* was intended to be read with the principal Act of 1892. Section 4 of the 1904 Act created a deemed succession for gifts made within twelve months of death, and this deemed succession was intended to be subject to the taxing provisions of section 12 of the 1892 Act. The Court held that the phrase "whole succession or successions derived from the same predecessor and passing upon any death to any person or persons" in section 12 required the aggregation of all successions for the purpose of determining the rate of duty. This interpretation was supported by the legislative history and prior judicial decisions, including *In re Blissett*, which had established this practice of aggregation. The Court found that the appellant's contention that duty should be calculated on the individual value of his gift was contrary to the plain meaning of the legislation and established practice.

The High Court dismissed the appeal. The Court affirmed the decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland, upholding the assessment of succession duty at 5 per cent, which was derived from aggregating the value of the gift to the appellant with other successions passing from the predecessor.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established