Archibald v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read
44 CLR 243

ARCHIBALD

THE COMMISSIONER OF STAMP DUTIES

RESPONDENT. (QUEENSLAND)

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

QUEENSLAND. Stamp Duty (8))-Assignment of life assurance policies-Gift-Gift duty-Settlement-

Ad valorem stamp duty-Two assessments-Stamp Acts 1894-1926 (Q.) (58 Vict. No. 8-17 Geo. v. No. 10), sec. 59 (1)*-Gift Duty Act 1926 (Q.) (17 Geo. v. No. 23), sec. 10 (1)*.

By two several indentures a person who had insured his life with two life assurance companies, assigned the two policies and all moneys payable in MELBOURNE, respect thereof to trustees to hold the same and pay Commonwealth and State succession, estate, probate and other duties. It was then declared in both documents that subject as aforesaid the assignments were on trust for the assured's wife should she become a widow, failing which, the assignments were on trust for the children of the assured, and in the event of failure of the trusts, then upon such trusts as the assured should by deed or will direct. The indentures provided that failing any such direction the trustees were to pay the moneys to the assured's executors or administrators as part of his estate. The two documents were assessed for gift duty under the Gift Duty Act of 1926 (Q.), and the Commissioner of Stamps claimed to assess them for ad valorem stamp duty as settlements under sec. 59 (1) of the Stamp Acts 1894 to 1926 (Q.). * It is provided by sec. 59 (1) of the

thing to the contrary in the Stamp Acts Stamp Acts 1894 to 1926 (Q.) that

the stamp duty chargeable on " where any money which may become

any instrument of gift due or payable upon any policy of life

be ten shillings, but this stamp duty shall be in addition to and not in instrument whereby the settlement is

substitution for any other stamp duty charged with

to which the instrument is liable so ad valorem duty," &.

far as it operates otherwise than Sec. 10 (1) of the Gift Duty Act of 1926

exclusively as an instrument of gift." (Q.) provides 'Notwithstanding any-

44 CLR 244

Held, that the indentures did not operate otherwise than exclusively as instruments of gift, and were not settlements within the meaning of the Stamp Acts 1894 to 1926 and were not chargeable with stamp duty beyond that specified in the Gift Duty Act of 1926.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Queensland.

DUTIES (Q.).

The facts, which were set out in a special case stated by the Commissioner of Stamp Duties for the opinion of the Supreme Court of Queensland, were substantially as follows: :-

1. On 8th March 1927 Robert John Archibald (the appellant) effected a policy of insurance on his life with the Australian Mutual Provident Society for the sum of £10,000, at a yearly premium of £508 6s. 8d. payable in advance, and duly paid the first premium on 8th March 1927.

2. On 15th March 1927 the appellant executed an indenture by which he assigned the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Archibald v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1930] HCA 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Archibald v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld)* concerned an appeal to the High Court of Australia from the Supreme Court of Queensland. The dispute arose from the Commissioner of Stamp Duties' assessment of ad valorem stamp duty on two indentures that assigned life assurance policies to trustees. The appellant contended that these indentures were solely instruments of gift and thus only liable for a nominal stamp duty under the *Gift Duty Act 1926* (Qld), while the Commissioner argued they constituted settlements under the *Stamp Acts 1894-1926* (Qld) and were subject to ad valorem duty.

The legal issues before the court were whether the indentures, which assigned life assurance policies to trustees for the benefit of the assured's wife and children, and also to cover succession, estate, and probate duties, operated exclusively as instruments of gift, or if they also constituted settlements liable to ad valorem stamp duty under the *Stamp Acts*. Specifically, the court had to determine the interplay between the *Gift Duty Act 1926* and the *Stamp Acts 1894-1926*, particularly section 10(1) of the former, which stipulated that the stamp duty on an instrument of gift in respect of which gift duty was payable would be ten shillings, but this was in addition to any other stamp duty to which the instrument was liable "so far as it operates otherwise than exclusively as an instrument of gift."

The High Court held that the indentures did not operate otherwise than exclusively as instruments of gift. The Court reasoned that the definition of "gift" in the *Gift Duty Act* was broad enough to encompass these transactions, as they involved a disposition of property without fully adequate consideration. Crucially, the Court interpreted section 10(1) of the *Gift Duty Act* to mean that if an instrument operated exclusively as a gift, it was not liable for additional stamp duty beyond the ten shillings. The Court found that the elements making the instruments gifts were also the elements that would make them settlements, and therefore, these elements could not be separated to render them liable for ad valorem duty as settlements.

Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, discharged the judgment of the Supreme Court of Queensland, and ordered that the indentures were not chargeable with stamp duty beyond ten shillings each. The Commissioner of Stamp Duties was ordered to pay the costs of the appellant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established