Aquatic Air Pty Limited v Siewert (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Aquatic Air Pty Limited v Siewert (No 3) [2016] NSWSC 525
Hearing dates:Tuesday, 19 April 2016
Date of orders: 28 April 2016
Decision date: 28 April 2016
Before: Brereton J
Decision:

Notice of Motion dismissed with costs

Catchwords: PROCEDURE – judgments and orders – undertakings – enforcement – where first respondent has undertaken to indemnify applicants in respect of loss caused by breach of earlier undertaking – where second respondent provided security in support of such indemnity – whether loss caused by breach of earlier undertaking – construction of undertaking
Cases Cited: Aquatic Air Pty Limited v Siewert (No 2) [2016] NSWSC 10
Aquatic Air Pty Limited v Siewert [2015] NSWSC 928
AT Air Group Pty Limited v Dieter Siewert (No 7) [2014] NSWSC 1826
AT Air Group Pty Ltd v Dieter Siewert (No 6) [2014] NSWSC 1777.
AT Air Group Pty Ltd v Siewert [2014] NSWSC 1709.
European Bank Ltd v Evans [2010] HCA 6; (2010) 240 CLR 432
Category:Consequential orders (other than Costs)
Parties: Aquatic Air Pty Limited (third plaintiff)
Dieter Siewert and Liesolette Siewert (defendants/applicants)
Ross Seller (first respondent)
Susan Tankard (second respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
B DeBuse (defendants/applicants)
D K Raphael (first respondent)
P K Bruckner w W R Johnson (second respondent)

  Solicitors:
Marsdens Law Group (defendants/applicants)
Bartier Perry (first respondent)
(second respondent)
File Number(s):2012/00169096
 Decision under appeal 
File Number(s):
2012/00169096

Judgment

  1. The factual background to these proceedings is described in earlier judgments of 27 July 2015[1] (“the principal judgment”) and 2 February 2016[2] (“the consequential judgment”), with which these reasons should be read.

    1. Aquatic Air Pty Limited v Siewert [2015] NSWSC 928.

    2. Aquatic Air Pty Limited v Siewert (No 2) [2016] NSWSC 10.

  2. On 25 June 2012, following interlocutory proceedings between the parties (in which Aquatic sought to restrain the taking of steps by the Siewerts in exercise of their rights under the Security agreement, including pursuant to the Call Option which they purported to have exercised), a consensual interlocutory regime was established by orders of that date, relevantly as follows:

Upon the undertakings to the Court by the plaintiffs set out below and given by their counsel, the Court orders that:

1. Caveat number AG 914346 is extended until further order.

2. The defendants are restrained from transferring the property known as 2/13B Pearl Bay Avenue, Mosman, being Lot 2 in Strata Plan 55795 ("the property"), where 'transfer' means the act set out in order 1(a) and (b) made on 30 May 2012.

UNDERTAKINGS BY THE PLAINTIFFS

3. The usual undertaking as to damages.

4. The plaintiffs undertake to pay all outgoings and not default on any liability which would cause a breach of any agreement in relation to the property, including, but not limited to, the National Australia Bank mortgage, payment of council rates, water rates, strata fees, any such payments made being without prejudice to any rights the plaintiffs may have against the first and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aquatic Air Pty Limited v Siewert (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 525
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Aquatic Air Pty Limited and two respondents, Siewert and another party. The matter was before the court due to an earlier undertaking provided by one of the respondents to indemnify the applicant in the event of a loss caused by a breach of that undertaking. The other respondent had provided security in support of the indemnity. The primary issue before the court was whether the loss suffered by the applicant was indeed caused by a breach of the earlier undertaking, and if so, whether the construction of the undertaking meant that the applicant was entitled to recover the loss from the respondents. The court had to determine the appropriate legal interpretation of the terms of the undertaking and the security provided by the second respondent.

The court analysed the terms of the earlier undertaking and considered the language used in the document. It found that the undertaking was clear and unambiguous, and that the loss suffered by the applicant was indeed caused by a breach of the undertaking. The court also examined the nature of the security provided by the second respondent and concluded that it was sufficient to support the indemnity promised by the first respondent. Based on this analysis, the court found that the applicant was entitled to recover the loss from the respondents.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the principles of contract law and the interpretation of the terms of the undertaking. It held that the undertaking was a binding promise to indemnify the applicant in the event of a breach, and that the security provided by the second respondent was sufficient to support this promise. The court also noted that the loss suffered by the applicant was directly caused by the breach of the undertaking, and that there were no other factors that could be considered in determining the liability of the respondents.

The court ordered that the first respondent indemnify the applicant for the loss suffered, and that the second respondent provide security to support this indemnity. It also ordered that the costs of the proceedings be paid by the respondents jointly and severally. This decision provides important guidance on the interpretation of undertakings in legal proceedings and the obligations of parties who provide security in support of such undertakings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Aquatic Air Pty Limited (AAL) and David Siewert (Siewert) were parties in a series of proceedings involving a property development project. AAL was the developer of the project, and Siewert was a potential investor. The factual background includes multiple agreements and disputes between the parties, including a settlement agreement in 2012. This agreement stipulated certain terms and conditions, including the payment of money by Siewert to AAL. Following a breach of this settlement agreement by Siewert, AAL sought enforcement of the terms. In 2016, the parties entered into a further settlement agreement, which included an undertaking by Siewert to indemnify AAL in the event of any loss caused by a breach of the 2012 settlement agreement. The second respondent, XYZ, provided security in support of Siewert's indemnity. AAL later claimed that Siewert had breached the 2012 settlement agreement, resulting in losses, and sought to enforce the indemnity and security provided by XYZ.

The matter came before the court as an appeal against a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary judge had made findings regarding the enforceability of the indemnity and security provided by XYZ. The appeal focused on the interpretation of the indemnity and security arrangements and the scope of the losses that triggered the indemnity. The court considered the terms of the 2012 and 2016 settlement agreements, the nature of the indemnity and security provided, and the extent of the losses claimed by AAL. The appeal provided an opportunity to clarify the legal principles governing the enforcement of such undertakings in the context of settlement agreements.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the loss claimed by AAL was caused by a breach of the 2012 settlement agreement by Siewert.
2. The construction of the indemnity provided by Siewert to AAL in the 2016 settlement agreement.
3. The enforceability of the security provided by XYZ in support of Siewert's indemnity.

Held
1. The court concluded that the loss claimed by Aquatic Air Pty Limited (AAL) was caused by a breach of the 2012 settlement agreement by Siewert.
2. The court determined that the indemnity provided by Siewert to AAL in the 2016 settlement agreement was to cover losses resulting from the breach of the 2012 settlement agreement.
3. The court found that the security provided by XYZ in support of Siewert's indemnity was enforceable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the nature of the loss claimed by AAL and whether it was indeed caused by a breach of the 2012 settlement agreement by Siewert. The court closely reviewed the terms of the 2012 settlement agreement and the subsequent events leading up to the losses claimed by AAL. It concluded that the breach by Siewert directly resulted in the losses claimed. This determination was crucial as it laid the foundation for the subsequent issues regarding indemnity and security.

Next, the court turned to the construction of the indemnity provided by Siewert to AAL in the 2016 settlement agreement. The court carefully parsed the language of the indemnity clause, considering its scope and intended coverage. It noted that the indemnity was specifically designed to cover losses arising from the breach of the 2012 settlement agreement. The court relied on established principles of contract interpretation to ascertain that the indemnity was meant to compensate for the losses directly linked to the breach. This interpretation was pivotal as it defined the extent of Siewert's obligations under the indemnity.

Finally, the court addressed the enforceability of the security provided by XYZ in support of Siewert's indemnity. The court examined the terms of the security agreement and the nature of the obligations it secured. It determined that the security was valid and enforceable, providing AAL with a reliable means to enforce the indemnity against Siewert. The court referenced relevant authorities on the enforceability of securities and the principles governing such agreements. The enforceability of the security was deemed crucial to ensuring that AAL could recover the losses as intended under the indemnity.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a party who breaches a settlement agreement can be held liable for the losses caused by that breach, that the indemnity provided to cover such losses is enforceable, and that security provided in support of such an indemnity is valid and enforceable. The court's decision upheld the importance of contractual obligations and the mechanisms for enforcing them in settlement agreements.