Aqua Max Water Filtration Solutions Pty Ltd v Hurtado

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeals to a Single Judge: Civil)

AQUA MAX WATER FILTRATION SOLUTIONS PTY LTD v HURTADO

[2017] SASC 165

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

15 November 2017

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

PROCEDURE - COURTS AND JUDGES GENERALLY - COURTS - CONCURRENT JURISDICTION OF DIFFERENT COURTS - CASES OTHER THAN UNDER CROSS-VESTING LEGISLATION

Appeal against dismissal by a Magistrate of application for stay of proceedings.

The appellant distributes water filtration products Australia-wide from its base in New South Wales.

In September 2016 the appellant’s directors and the respondent had discussions in Adelaide concerning the appointment by the appellant of the respondent as a distributor of its products in South Australia.  The respondent transferred $55,000 into the appellant’s bank account.  There is a dispute in the action whether this was for the payment of goods sold and delivered (according to the appellant) or a refundable deposit conditional on the parties entering into a distribution agreement (according to the respondent).  There is also a dispute whether the parties entered into a legally binding distribution agreement.  There were subsequent meetings in Adelaide between the parties later in September and in October 2016 and email communications between them.  However ultimately agreement was not reached on the terms of a written distribution agreement and the respondent requested repayment of the sum of $55,000. 

The respondent instituted an action in the Magistrates Court against the appellant for recovery of $55,000.  The appellant applied pursuant to s 20 of the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth) for a stay of proceedings, contending that the District Court of New South Wales is the appropriate court to determine the issues between the parties.  A Magistrate dismissed the application. 

Held dismissing the appeal:

1.   The Magistrate did not make the specific error asserted by the appellant, namely to take into account the fact that the proceeding was commenced in the Magistrates Court in South Australia (at [46]-[48]).

2.  The appellant has not demonstrated an outcome error, namely that the Magistrate’s refusal of a stay was unreasonable or plainly unjust.  On the contrary, the Magistrate’s exercise of discretion was correct (at [57]).

3.  On a notional fresh application for a stay based on new evidence that the appellant has now instituted in the District Court of New South Wales an action against the respondent for $150,000 plus GST being the price of the sale of the exclusive distributorship rights, the appellant has not demonstrated that the District Court of New South Wales is the appropriate court to hear the disputes between the parties (at [66]).

4.  Appeal dismissed (at [69]).

Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth) ss 9, 10, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 and 21, referred to.
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499, applied.
Fertico v Murray River Corn [2002] SADC 89, not followed.

AQUA MAX WATER FILTRATION SOLUTIONS PTY LTD v HURTADO
[2017] SASC 165

Magistrates Appeal:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aqua Max Water Filtration Solutions Pty Ltd v Hurtado and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASC 165
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Aqua Max Water Filtration Solutions Pty Ltd brought an appeal against the decision of a Magistrate to dismiss its application for a stay of proceedings under section 20 of the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth) (the Act). Aqua Max argued that the South Australian proceedings should be stayed in favour of a proceeding brought in the New South Wales District Court. The parties had entered into discussions during the Royal Adelaide Show in 2016, and a non-disclosure agreement was signed by Mr Hurtado. The amount of $55,990 was transferred into Aqua Max’s bank account, and a dispute arose over the purpose of the payment. The parties had differing views on whether the payment was a refundable deposit conditional on the parties entering into a distribution agreement or for the purchase of stock. Aqua Max also claimed that Mr Hurtado had taken possession of the remaining stock that Aqua Max had brought to Adelaide for the Royal Adelaide Show, with differing views on whether the purpose of Mr Hurtado taking possession was to store the stock for Aqua Max until the next exhibition in Adelaide to be attended by the Dogras or was delivered to Mr Hurtado by way of sale of the stock.

The legal issue before the court was whether Aqua Max's application for a stay of proceedings should be granted under section 20 of the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth) (the Act). The court had to consider the factors relevant to determining the appropriate forum for the proceedings. The court also had to consider the existence of the proceeding recently commenced in the District Court of New South Wales and its effect on the exercise of the discretion. The court found that the factors identified that point in favour of South Australia as the more appropriate forum applied equally whether Aqua Max prosecutes a claim against Mr Hurtado or whether Mr Hurtado is the only one prosecuting a claim against Aqua Max. The court also found that there were several factors that favoured South Australia as the more appropriate forum. The court found that it would be untenable for two separate proceedings raising common issues to proceed in two different courts with the possibility of inconsistent results.

The appeal was dismissed. The court will hear the parties as to consequential or other orders. Subject to determining Aqua Max’s notional fresh application for a stay based on the new evidence of the proceeding recently commenced in the District Court of New South Wales, the appeal should be dismissed. Fresh consideration on new material should be given to the existence of the proceeding in the District Court of New South Wales and its effect on the exercise of the discretion. The factors identified that point in favour of South Australia as the more appropriate forum apply equally whether Aqua Max prosecutes a claim against Mr Hurtado or whether Mr Hurtado is the only one prosecuting a claim against Aqua Max. The court found that it would be untenable for two separate proceedings raising common issues to proceed in two different courts with the possibility of inconsistent results.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal against a decision by a Magistrate dismissing an application for a stay of proceedings under section 20 of the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth) (the Act).Background The facts set out below are based on the pleadings and affidavits filed by each party in the Magistrates Court insofar as they state facts not contested by the opposite party. Obviously the evidence adduced at trial will be more extensive and the facts found may differ from the facts set out below. Aqua Max Water Filtration Solutions Pty Ltd (Aqua Max) carries on business distributing and exhibition marketing water filtration products from its base at Homebush West New South Wales. Its shareholders and directors are Ashok Kumar Dograr (Ash Dogra) and Pankaj Kumar Dogra (Kumar Dogra). The Dogras travel around Australia (with the exception of the Northern Territory) to attend exhibitions at which they market Aqua Max’s products. Mr Hurtado carries on businesses engaged in residential and commercial building, renovation, maintenance and security. In September 2016 the Dogras established a display stall at the Royal Adelaide Show at Wayville South Australia which they attended throughout the Show between 2 and 11 September 2016. Mr Hurtado attended at his own display stall at the Royal Adelaide Show and had several conversations with the Dogras over the course of the Show. They told him that they were importers, distributors and wholesalers of water filtration products and were looking to appoint a distributor in South Australia. There were discussions about Mr Hurtado becoming Aqua Max’s South Australian distributor. It was agreed that the Dogras would provide to Mr Hurtado a draft distribution agreement. There is a dispute about the detail of the discussions. However it appears to be common ground that a figure of $150,000 plus GST as a payment for a distributorship was discussed. On 11 September 2016 the Dogras produced to Mr Hurtado a non-circumvention/non-disclosure agreement (the non-disclosure agreement) under which Mr Hurtado agreed to keep information to be supplied to him confidential and use it only for the purpose of enabling Aqua Max to negotiate and discuss with him financial and business matters relating to Aqua Max including future strategic business plans. Although described as an “agreement”, the document only showed Mr Hurtado as a party and only provided for execution by him. Mr Hurtado executed the agreement. On 11 September 2016 Mr Hurtado transferred $55,990 into Aqua Max’s bank account. This amount comprised $50,000 plus GST of $5,000 plus $990 being 1.8 per cent said to cover Aqua Max’s bank transfer credit card fee. There is a dispute whether this money was paid as a refundable deposit conditional on the parties entering into a distribution agreement (according to Mr Hurtado) or for the purchase of stock (according to Aqua Max). On 11 September 2016 Mr Hurtado took possession of the remaining stock that Aqua Max had brought to Adelaide for the Royal Adelaide Show. There is a dispute whether the purpose of Mr Hurtado taking possession was to store the stock for Aqua Max until the next exhibition in Adelaide to be attended by the Dogras (according to Mr Hurtado) or was delivered to Mr Hurtado by way of sale of the stock (according to Aqua Max).

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the hearing of the appeal, Mr Hurtado informed the Court that he agreed to waive the jurisdictional limit of the Magistrates Court so as to permit Aqua Max to bring a counterclaim for $150,000 plus GST. Aqua Max reserved its position on that question. Accordingly, if Aqua Max also waives the jurisdictional limit, the action and a counterclaim can proceed to trial in the Magistrates Court. If not, upon the filing of the counterclaim, the matter will need to be transferred to the District Court.Conclusion I dismiss the appeal. I will hear the parties as to consequential or other orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Subject to determining Aqua Max’s notional fresh application for a stay based on the new evidence of the proceeding recently commenced in the District Court of New South Wales, the appeal should be dismissed.Fresh consideration on new material I turn to consider whether considered afresh and taking into account the existence of the proceeding in the District Court of New South Wales a stay should be granted under section 20 on the merits. As noted above, on 12 October 2017 Aqua Max instituted in the District Court of New South Wales an action against Mr Hurtado for $150,000 plus GST being the price of the sale of the exclusive distributor rights for Aqua Max’s products in South Australia. By paragraph 5 of its pleading, Aqua Max pleads that an agreement was made between the parties on about 11 September 2016 whereby “the plaintiff agreed to sell to the defendant and the defendant agreed to purchase immediately from the plaintiff the sole and exclusive distributor rights for the plaintiff’s product in the state of South Australia for the sum of $150,000.00 plus GST”. Aqua Max pleads that the agreement was made in the non-disclosure agreement. This is not a tenable plea because the non-disclosure agreement does not contain any term for the sale or purchase of a distributorship. Aqua Max pleads that the agreement was also made “orally and by the conduct of the parties on or about the said date”. This must be a reference to discussions between the parties at the Royal Adelaide Show on 11 September 2016. The fact that Aqua Max has now instituted the proceeding in the District Court of New South Wales which its counsel told the Magistrate in July was to be instituted does not make a significant difference to the exercise of the discretion. The choice to be made is between the present action in South Australia together with a counterclaim to be brought by Aqua Max proceeding to trial in South Australia on the one hand and the present action in New South Wales together with a counterclaim to be brought by Mr Hurtado proceeding to trial in New South Wales. Clearly it would be untenable for two separate proceedings raising common issues to proceed in two different courts with the possibility of inconsistent results. The factors identified above that point in favour of South Australia as the more appropriate forum apply equally whether Aqua Max prosecutes a claim against Mr Hurtado or whether Mr Hurtado is the only one prosecuting a claim against Aqua Max. On an overall assessment, there are several factors which are neutral either because matters are equally balanced or because the factor has no weight. In addition there are several factors that favour South Australia as the more appropriate forum. They are the three factors identified at [56] above. In addition, there is a slight preponderance of witnesses in favour of South Australia (three witnesses for Mr Hurtado and two witnesses for Aqua Max) but this is only to be given relatively slight weight.