Apthorpe, R.H v The Repatriation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Re: ROBERT HARRY APTHORPE
And: THE REPATRIATION COMMISSION
No. NSW G81 of 1986
Repatriation

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Wilcox J.
CATCHWORDS

Repatriation - General rate pension - Degree of incapacity - Whether Administrative Appeals Tribunal bound to have regard to Guide to Assessment of Incapacity issued by Department - Whether Tribunal entitled to consider degrees of incapacity set out in Schedule 4 of Act - Failure of Tribunal also to refer to Schedule 5.

Repatriation Act 1920 s.35, Schedules 3, 4, 5.

Re McPherson and Repatriation Commission (1985) 8 ALD 484, Wicks v. Firth (1983) 2 AC 214, Hanning v. Maitland (1970) 1 QB 580 and Inland Revenue Commissioners v. Trustees of Sir John Aird's Settlement (1982) 1 WLR 270 referred to.

HEARING

SYDNEY

#DATE 23:3:1987

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr I Khan.

Solicitors for the Applicant: Australian Legal Aid Office.

Counsel for the Respondent: Ms P Fleming QC with Mr J S Hilton.

Solicitors for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor.

ORDER

The application be dismissed.

The applicant pay to the respondent its costs of the application.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

JUDGE1

The question which arises upon this appeal concerns the manner of assessing the degree of partial incapacity of a veteran claiming benefits under the Repatriation Act 1920. I emphasize the reference to that Act because the legislation which has now superceded that Act, the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986, contains express provisions -- see ss.22 and 26-29 -- which deal with the subject matter of this case. But those provisions are not relevant to this appeal, which questions the legal correctness of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Mr B J McMahon, Senior Member, and Mr S Crawshaw and Dr M Thorpe, Members) under the previous legislation.

  1. The applicant, Robert Harry Apthorpe, served in New Guinea with the Royal Australian Air Force during the second world war. He has for many years suffered two disabilities which are related to that service: osteoarthritis of the knees and cervical spondylosis. However, as the Tribunal found, these disabilities did not prevent Mr Apthorpe obtaining and continuing in employment. For 31 years he was employed by a hardware company. He started as a design draftsman and, after a series of promotions, was chief engineer for some years before his retirement on 31 January 1983. Mr Apthorpe had suffered heart trouble for some time prior to his retirement, culminating in a coronary by-pass operation in September 1982.

  2. On 22 October 1982 the applicant claimed an increase in his pension, that increase to reflect an increase in the extent of his incapacity from the neck and knee injuries and, as a new claim, his heart condition. On 23 March 1983 a Repatriation Board decided to increase the pension to 60% of the general rate but to reject the claim that the heart condition was war related. Mr Apthorpe appealed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Apthorpe, R.H v The Repatriation Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1987] FCA 121
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Apthorpe, R.H was the applicant in a case brought against The Repatriation Commission, a body established under the Repatriation Act 1973. The applicant sought a review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) which had determined that the applicant was not entitled to the higher rate of pension under the Act. The applicant contended that the AAT erred in law by not considering the Guide to Assessment of Incapacity issued by the Department and by not referring to the degrees of incapacity set out in Schedule 4 of the Act. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The central legal issues in the case were whether the AAT was bound to have regard to the Guide to Assessment of Incapacity, and whether the AAT was entitled to consider the degrees of incapacity set out in Schedule 4 of the Act. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the AAT was required to refer to Schedule 5 of the Act, which deals with degrees of incapacity for the purposes of determining entitlement to the higher rate of pension.

The court found that the AAT was not bound to have regard to the Guide to Assessment of Incapacity as it was not a legislative instrument and did not have the force of law. The court further found that the AAT was entitled to consider the degrees of incapacity set out in Schedule 4 of the Act, as they were relevant to the determination of the applicant's entitlement to the higher rate of pension. However, the court held that the AAT was also required to refer to Schedule 5 of the Act, which sets out the degrees of incapacity for the purposes of determining entitlement to the higher rate of pension. The court found that the AAT's failure to do so was a material error of law, which led to an unjust outcome. The court therefore set aside the decision of the AAT and remitted the matter back to the AAT for reconsideration.

The final orders of the court were that the application be dismissed, and that the applicant pay the costs of the application to the respondent. The settlement and entry of orders were dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application be dismissed.

The applicant pay to the respondent its costs of the application.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Mr. Apthorpe, a veteran, who applied for a general rate pension under the Repatriation Act. The Repatriation Commission assessed Mr. Apthorpe's degree of incapacity and determined his eligibility for the pension. Mr. Apthorpe was dissatisfied with the Commission's assessment and subsequently appealed to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT reviewed the assessment and made its own determination regarding Mr. Apthorpe's eligibility for the pension. Mr. Apthorpe was again dissatisfied with the AAT's decision and sought judicial review in the Federal Court of Australia. The central issue in the case is the extent to which the AAT is bound by the Guide to Assessment of Incapacity issued by the Department and whether the AAT is entitled to consider the degrees of incapacity set out in Schedule 4 of the Act. Additionally, the case questions whether the AAT failed to refer to Schedule 5 of the Act in its determination.

Mr. Apthorpe initially applied for a general rate pension under the Repatriation Act. After the Repatriation Commission assessed his degree of incapacity and determined his eligibility for the pension, he appealed to the AAT. The AAT reviewed the assessment and made its own decision on Mr. Apthorpe's eligibility for the pension. Dissatisfied with the AAT's determination, Mr. Apthorpe sought judicial review of the AAT's decision in the Federal Court of Australia. The case was heard as an application for judicial review, with the primary focus being on the legal principles governing the AAT's assessment of Mr. Apthorpe's degree of incapacity.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal is bound to have regard to the Guide to Assessment of Incapacity issued by the Department in determining Mr. Apthorpe's eligibility for the general rate pension.
2. Whether the Tribunal is entitled to consider the degrees of incapacity set out in Schedule 4 of the Act in its assessment of Mr. Apthorpe's eligibility for the pension.
3. Whether the Tribunal failed to refer to Schedule 5 of the Act in its determination of Mr. Apthorpe's eligibility for the pension.

Held
1. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) is not bound to have regard to the Guide to Assessment of Incapacity issued by the Department in determining Mr. Apthorpe's eligibility for the general rate pension. The court found that the Guide does not have statutory force and the AAT has discretion in considering relevant materials.
2. The Tribunal is entitled to consider the degrees of incapacity set out in Schedule 4 of the Act in its assessment of Mr. Apthorpe's eligibility for the pension. The court held that Schedule 4 provides a statutory framework that the Tribunal can apply.
3. The Tribunal did not fail to refer to Schedule 5 of the Act in its determination of Mr. Apthorpe's eligibility for the pension. The court concluded that the Tribunal's omission was not a material error as Schedule 5 was not relevant to the assessment of Mr. Apthorpe's incapacity.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining whether the AAT is bound to have regard to the Guide to Assessment of Incapacity issued by the Department. It was noted that the Guide lacks statutory force and, therefore, the AAT is not obligated to consider it. Instead, the AAT has the discretion to consider any material it deems relevant in making its determination. The court emphasised that while guidelines can be useful, they do not impose a legal duty on the AAT.

The next issue addressed was whether the Tribunal is entitled to consider the degrees of incapacity set out in Schedule 4 of the Act. The court held that Schedule 4 provides a statutory framework that the Tribunal can apply in assessing incapacity. The statutory degrees of incapacity offer a structured approach that the Tribunal can follow, which aids in the consistency and predictability of its decisions. The court underscored that the Tribunal's consideration of Schedule 4 is not only permissible but also appropriate given its statutory basis.

Finally, the court considered whether the Tribunal failed to refer to Schedule 5 of the Act. Schedule 5 pertains to other considerations in pension eligibility, which were not relevant to Mr. Apthorpe's case. The court found that the Tribunal's failure to refer to Schedule 5 was not a material error, as Schedule 5 did not apply to the facts at hand. The court concluded that the omission did not affect the overall fairness or correctness of the Tribunal's decision.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the AAT has discretion in the materials it considers, statutory frameworks such as Schedule 4 must be applied where relevant, and omissions from non-relevant statutory provisions do not necessarily vitiate a decision. This decision reaffirms the importance of statutory interpretation and the role of guidelines versus binding legislative instruments in administrative law.