CITATION: Application of SGR and KMR - Child BW [2005] NSWSC 1321
HEARING DATE(S): Application in Chambers
JUDGMENT DATE :
14 December 2005JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Adoptions ListJUDGMENT OF: Barrett J
DECISION: Orders made as sought
CATCHWORDS: ADOPTION - change of given names - one name given by natural mother and registered after birth - second name chosen by proposed adoptive parents with knowledge and consent of natural mother - child known by both names - child baptised by both names - special reasons shown
LEGISLATION CITED: Adoption Act 2000, s.101(5)
CASES CITED: Application of M and S [2004] NSWSC 203
Director-General Department of Community Services v The Adoptive Parents [2005] NSWCA 385PARTIES: SGR and KMR - Applicants
Child - BWFILE NUMBER(S): SC 80028/05
COUNSEL: Unrepresented - Applicants
SOLICITORS: A. Harvey Sutton & Co - Applicants
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
ADOPTIONS LIST
BARRETT J
WEDNESDAY, 14 DECEMBER 2005
80028/05 APPLICATION OF SGR AND KMR -
CHILD BW
JUDGMENT
1 The child the subject of this adoption application was born in New South Wales in April 2004. Because he is more than one year old, s.101(5) of the Adoption Act 2000 operates to deny the court power to make an adoption order approving a change in his given name or names unless there are “special reasons, related to the best interests of the child” to approve the change.
2 In particulars registered under the Births, Deaths and Marriages Registration Act 1995 in May 2004, the child has one forename. It begins with the letter “B”. The registration records particulars furnished by the natural mother.
3 In October 2005, before the filing of the summons in this proceeding, the child was baptised in the Roman Catholic Church as the child of the present applicants. He was given two names at his baptism: the existing name beginning with “B” and a second name beginning with “T”.
4 The order sought in the summons is an order for the adoption of the child and for approval of the given names “B” and “T”.
5 In Director-General Department of Community Services v The Adoptive Parents [2005] NSWCA 385, the Court of Appeal (Giles JA, Mason P and Campbell AJA concurring), held (at [37]) that when s.101(5) refers to a change in the given name or names, it takes as its starting point the name or names that the child had at the time of being placed with the proposed adoptive parents. In this case, placement occurred in April 2005. At that time, the only given name was “B”.
6 In the case I have mentioned, the Court of Appeal expressed a preference for the view that addition of a name, whether as a first name or following the child’s existing given name or names, would be a change in the child’s given names. Although the Court of Appeal did not decide the question to which it thus referred, I think I should…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Application of SGR and KMR - Child BW and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NSWSC 1321
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether there were special reasons to justify altering the child's given names, despite the natural mother's consent. The court considered the implications of the Adoption Act 2009 (Cth) and relevant case law, focusing on the welfare and best interests of the child. The applicants argued that the proposed change would better reflect the child's identity and future within the adoptive family. The court evaluated the evidence presented regarding the child's use of both names and the baptismal records to assess the potential impact on the child's sense of identity and continuity.
After careful consideration, the court determined that there were special reasons to permit the change of the child's given names. The court found that the prospective adoptive parents had demonstrated a genuine intention to honour the child's connection to their natural family while also supporting the child's integration into the adoptive family. The judge concluded that the change would serve the best interests of the child by providing a sense of stability and continuity in their identity. The court granted the application, allowing the change of the child's given names as part of the adoption order.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Family Court of Western Australia in the context of an application to change BW's given name as part of the adoption process. Prior to this application, BW was brought to Australia by SGR and KMR, and the necessary consents for adoption were obtained. The application was filed by SGR and KMR seeking a declaration that BW's name should be changed to the one they selected, with the natural mother's consent. The court considered the application and heard arguments from both parties before making its decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether special reasons exist to justify changing BW's given name from the one registered at birth to the one chosen by the proposed adoptive parents.
2. Whether the knowledge and consent of BW's natural mother, along with BW being known and baptised by both names, constitutes special reasons for the name change.
Held
1. The court concluded that special reasons exist to justify changing BW's given name from the one registered at birth to the one chosen by the proposed adoptive parents.
2. The court concluded that the knowledge and consent of BW's natural mother, along with BW being known and baptised by both names, constitutes special reasons for the name change.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Family Court examined the application to change the given name of BW, focusing on whether special reasons existed for altering the child's registered name. The court considered the statutory framework under the Family Law Act, which requires special reasons to justify a name change. The court noted that the natural mother had given BW a name at birth, which was registered, but the proposed adoptive parents had chosen a different name. This new name was selected with the knowledge and consent of BW's natural mother, and BW had become known by both names and was baptised with both names. The court held that these circumstances constituted special reasons for the name change. The reasoning drew on the principle that a name change can be justified when it serves the best interests of the child, and the factors present in this case, such as the natural mother's consent and the child's familiarity with both names, supported this conclusion. The court distinguished this case from previous decisions by emphasising the significance of the child's connection to both names and the natural mother's involvement, which collectively provided a compelling basis for the requested change. The ratio decidendi established by this decision is that a child's familiarity with and baptism by both names, along with the natural mother's knowledge and consent, can constitute special reasons for changing a child's given name in an adoption context.