| [2017] FWC 7040 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
INTERIM DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.225—Enterprise agreement
Joshua Findley
(AG2016/3814)
COMMISSIONER HARPER-GREENWELL | MELBOURNE, 22 DECEMBER 2017 |
Application for termination of the MSS Security Victorian Enterprise Agreement 2011 – s.590(2)(c) of the Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order for production of documents.
[1] On 6 July 2016 the Fair Work Commission (Commission) received an application (the Application) from Mr Joshua Findley (Applicant) under s.225 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the FW Act) for termination of the MSS Security Victorian Enterprise Agreement 2011 (the Agreement) after its nominal expiry date.
[2] The employer covered by the Agreement, MSS Security Pty Ltd t/a MSS Security (MSS), objects to the application, as does United Voice.
[3] On 11 May 2017, Mr Findley made an application for an order for production of documents (Form F52) under section 590(2)(c) of the FW Act. United Voice advised that they did not oppose the making of the proposed order and did not seek to make submissions. MSS objected to the order and filed submissions on 30 June 2017.
[4] The Parties agreed that I would deal with this application on the papers.
[5] Mr Findley’s Form F52 sought production of the following documents:
“1. The contract services agreement between MSS Security and Deakin University.
2. Any document (electronic or otherwise) that mentions a payment or benefit of any kind from MSS Security, its employees or affiliates, to United Voice, its employees or affiliates, sent or received between 1 January 2010 to the current date.
a. This includes making payment to any third party to the same effect.
b. Any payment from an MSS employee to United Voice between the amounts of $1 and $70 is not to be included.
3. All financial records, bank statements and receipts that show payment from MSS Security, its employees or affiliates, to United Voice, its employees or affiliates between 1 January 2010 to the current date.
a. This includes making payment to any third party to the same effect.
b. Any payment from an MSS employee to United Voice between the amounts of $1 and $70 is not to be included.”
Submissions of Findley
[6] Mr Findley submitted that the power to require the provision of documents, records or other things is a broad discretionary power to be exercised in accordance with the principles applied by the Courts. 1
Documents in Paragraph 1
[7] Mr Findley submitted that the document requested at paragraph 1 of the Form F52 would demonstrate the significant loss in profit MSS would face should the Commission grant his application to terminate the Agreement. He submitted that MSS have won contracts by submitting low bids at the expense of their employees and are opposing the termination of the Agreement because they will lose profit if they have to pay employees minimum wage. 2
[8] He submitted that this document would assist the Commission to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Application for termination of the MSS Security Victorian En... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FWC 7040
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the documents requested by Mr Findley were relevant to the matters that the Commission had to consider under section 226 of the Act and whether the documents were necessary for the Commission to make an informed decision. Mr Findley argued that the documents would provide insight into the employer's financial situation and the reasons for the employee organisation's opposition to the termination application. On the other hand, MSS Security argued that the documents were not relevant to the substantive matter and that Mr Findley had already been provided with sufficient information.
The court found that the documents requested by Mr Findley were not relevant to the matters it had to consider under section 226 of the Act. The court was not satisfied that a single contract of services agreement would provide an accurate reflection of the organisation's total profit and losses for any financial year. Furthermore, the court did not find Mr Findley's submissions regarding the reasons for the employee organisation's opposition to be persuasive. The court concluded that a comparison between the terms and conditions of the award and the agreement, together with submissions from the employees, employer, and employee organisation, would be more than sufficient to enable it to determine the application.
As a result, the court was not prepared to issue the orders sought by Mr Findley at that time. The court emphasised that the relevance of documents sought must be established in relation to the issues in the proceedings, and the test applied by the courts has been consistently applied in the Commission. The court found that Mr Findley had not provided a compelling reason for the Commission to re-examine the issue of corrupting benefits. The court considered procedural fairness in accepting MSS Security's submissions despite being filed late.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi