Applicant N v Respondent C

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

APPLICANT N v RESPONDENT C [2006] FMCA 1936
HUMAN RIGHTS – Disability Discrimination – child care centre – no case submission – relevant factors – Briginshaw test – serious allegations – public interest – whether Respondent should be put to its election – consideration of expense to parties – desirability of ‘no case’ submission at conclusion of Applicant’s evidence – human rights cases distinguished from civil claims – whether Respondent ‘educational authority’.
Disability Discrimination Act 1992, ss.4, 22, 24
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986, ss.46PH(2), 46PO(4)
Protean (Holdings) Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) & Ors v American Home Assurance Co (1985) VR 187
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Amcor & Printing Papers Group Ltd (2000) 169 ALR 344
X v McHugh for the Auditor General of Tasmania, Unreported, 8 July 1994
Applicant: APPLICANT N
Respondent: RESPONDENT C
File number: MLG 1617 of 2005
Judgment of: McInnis FM
Hearing dates: 20, 21, 22 March 2006, 2 October 2006,
30 November 2006, 19 December 2006 and 21 December 2006
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 22 December 2006

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M.W. Harding
Solicitors for the Applicant: Access Law
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M. D.Wilson
Solicitors for the Respondent: Sparke Helmore

ORDERS

  1. The Application filed 19 October 2004 be dismissed.

  2. The Applicant shall pay the Respondent's costs to be taxed according to the Federal Court Rules up until the date of transfer and thereafter pursuant to Schedule 1 of the Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001.

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
MELBOURNE

MLG 1617 of 2005

APPLICANT N

Applicant

And

RESPONDENT C

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Revised from transcript)

  1. The application before the court in this matter is by way of a no-case submission made on behalf of the Respondent at the conclusion of the Applicant's evidence.  The substantive application in this matter arises out of a complaint which had been made to the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (the Commission), relying upon a claim of unlawful discrimination pursuant to provisions of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (the DDA).

  2. The application before the court was in fact commenced on 19 October 2004 in the Federal Court by the next friend and father of a minor or infant.  Presumably, the application was filed in that manner pursuant to Order 40(3) of the Federal Court Rules.  The minor in this matter is now aged six years. 

  3. The proceedings were transferred from the Federal Court to this court on 14 December 2005.  There is no dispute that the minor is a person with a disability for the purposes of the DDA.  The disability is set out in the Statement of Claim, which I note is admitted in the following terms:

    “7.    The Applicant's disability:

    a   may be described as right sided hemiplegia, arm worse than leg;

    b   is such that the Applicant has restricted flexibility and use of the right leg;

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Applicant N v Respondent C and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FMCA 1936
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Applicant N v Respondent C involved a dispute between the Applicant, who has a disability, and the Respondent, who was responsible for the Applicant's care. The Applicant sought to challenge the adequacy of the Respondent's care and strategies for managing the Applicant's disability, particularly in relation to the development and use of the Applicant's right hand. The case was heard and determined by the Federal Court of Australia.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Respondent had implemented appropriate therapeutic strategies to support the development of the Applicant's right hand, given that the Applicant spent most of his time at a crèche. The court examined the evidence provided by the occupational therapist, Mr Hoare, who acknowledged that the Applicant had made significant progress in his handskill development over a four-year period. The court also considered the necessity for consistent and daily implementation of therapeutic strategies across all environments where the Applicant spent significant time, including his home and crèche.

The court reasoned that the significant progress observed in the Applicant's right hand development could only have been achieved if the strategies were consistently applied in all environments, particularly the crèche where the Applicant spent most of his time. The court found that the Respondent's strategies and therapies were likely implemented at the crèche, as the Applicant's progress could not have been attained without such consistent and daily reinforcement of therapeutic activities. The court concluded that it was an inevitable outcome that the crèche provided the appropriate therapy, as the Applicant's development and use of his right hand improved significantly over the relevant period.

The court ultimately dismissed the Applicant's application and ordered that the Applicant pay the Respondent's costs in accordance with the Federal Court Rules.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The Application filed 19 October 2004 be dismissed.

2.

The Applicant shall pay the Respondent's costs to be taxed according to the Federal Court Rules up until the date of transfer and thereafter pursuant to Schedule 1 of the

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At page 57 of the transcript, it is relevant to note, in the further evidence of Mr Hoare in cross‑examination other comments were made in relation to the material and what had occurred in terms of strategies in place by the Respondent dealing with the disability of Applicant N. “MR WILSON I’m sorry. Yes, if he could. Perhaps before we deal with the affidavit, can I just clarify one thing with you, Mr Hoare. What [Applicant N] needed, given that he had a right-sided specicity, is he needed encouragement in his early developmental years to use the right side. That’s it in a nutshell, isn’t it?---Very basically yes.Yes, very basically?---But within that, encouragement can take on many different strategies. Such as?---Such as? In term of actually understanding, as I’ve said before, the roles of the hand and what normal hand function is in bi-manual play and most of the activities – all the activities what we do in such children, or the treatment that we provide is within play. Choosing the appropriate toys and equipment to use for [Applicant N] in --- “(Transcript p.57 8 to 20)…“You started to see [Applicant N] in 2001, did you not?---Correct.At that time, he was not in the crèche. Correct---From memory, no.He hadn’t yet started. Is that right. Okay. You then swore an affidavit, 4 March 2005. Do you see that?---Yes.In paragraph 1 of that affidavit, you say that, “[Applicant N] has made significant progress in his handskill development over the past four years.” Is that so?---He has.Do you include 2005 in that period?---It would have been probably to end of 04.Working backwards, you would include 2005, 2004, 2003, 2002. They’re the four years you’re referring to?---Correct.In that period you’re saying in your affidavit, that he “has made significant progress in his handskill development”, and you’re referring to his right side, are you not?---Yes, that’s - part of bi-manual is part of handskill development.You go on to say that he “has much improved spontaneous use of his right hand”, Correct?---He does.The side, the hand with his disability. Correct?---Yes, compared to that ---His gross grasp grip has become very effective in that period of time?---Yes, correct.I’ll take it and you don’t have to be bashful about this Mr Hoare, but some of the strategies that you’ve developed for [Applicant N], you would attribute that progress to those strategies, would you not?---Part of the overall care at Monash, yes.That he has had. But of course, the only way that a child can make significant progress is if the strategies that are developed by people such as yourself are implemented in a day-to-day basis?---Correct.”(Transcript p.59 lines 14 to 45 and p.60 lines 1 to 6)…“It’s got to be reinforced in a daily basis?---That’s right, in all environments.In a normal environment.HIS HONOUR: Sorry, did you say “normal” or “in all”?---All environments.MR WILSON: I’m sorry, thank you, your Honour.All environments?---Yes.So that would be his crèche environment, as well as his home environment. Correct?---Yes.Now, you know that [Applicant N] spent a large proposition of each week at the crèche, don’t you?---Correct.It goes without saying that he could not have achieved what you described as “significant progress” without those therapies and strategies being put in place by one of his principal caregivers, namely the crèche?---that would perhaps be correct, but I haven’t seen anything.That’s exactly right. But you haven’t seen it, but if follows, doesn’t it? The only way the he could have made what you call “significant progress” is the place where he spends five days a week, probably 11 months of the year, implementing those strategies and encouraging the use of his right hand?---Whether or not those are part of a co-ordinated team approach, I’m not sure. [Applicant N] did receive quite a lot of treatment at Monash. He’s had four lots of Botox injections and quite intensive therapy from part of a rehab program at Monash. Yes he does spend the majority of his time at crèche. It’s a minimal amount of time at Monash. But I think in terms of coordination of his care and coordinated approach, I’m not sure whether or not they were incorporated into his program at child care.You don’t know because you weren’t there. Correct?—No, I wasn’t there and I haven’t seen ---You’ve never been there. You’ve never been asked to go there to view them. Correct?---No, I’ve never been asked and I’ve never been sent---We know that. What I’m asking you, as an occupational therapist, is very simply this: this child could not have made significant progress that you observed over the previous four years, going back from March 205 if the place where he spent most of his time was not implementing appropriate therapies on his right hand. It follows, doesn’t it?---It does make some sense, yes.Of course, it does. It’s an absolute inevitable conclusion, isn’t it, Mr Hoare? Do you agree with that?---Yes In terms of his development, he did improve quite a lot over those four years.No that’s not the question. I’m saying it’s an inevitable conclusion that the crèche provided the appropriate therapy to his right hand. That’s the only way he could have made significant progress?---I can’t answer that because I wasn’t at the crèche.”[Emphasis added](Transcript p.60 lines 11 to 45 and p. 61 lines 1 to 23)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.