Applicant M38/2002 v Refugee Review Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Applicant M38/2002 v Refugee Review Tribunal [2003] FCA 58

MIGRATION – protection visa – error of law - whether the Tribunal failed to take into account relevant considerations which it was bound to take into account in the making of its decision.

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 48B, 417

High Court Rules O55 r 17, O55 r 30 and O60 r 6
Federal Court Rules O29 r 2

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24, applied

APPLICANT M38/2002 v REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL and HON. PHILLIP RUDDOCK, MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS

V 696 OF 2002

MARSHALL J
10 FEBRUARY 2003
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V696 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

APPLICANT M38/2002
APPLICANT

AND:

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
FIRST RESPONDENT

HON. PHILLIP RUDDOCK, MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 FEBRUARY 2003

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding be adjourned to a directions hearing at 9.45 am on 21 March 2003.

2.Costs be reserved.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V696 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

APPLICANT M38/2002
APPLICANT

AND:

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
FIRST RESPONDENT

HON. PHILLIP RUDDOCK, MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE:

10 FEBRUARY 2003

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This matter was remitted to the Court by an order of the High Court of Australia (Hayne J) dated 1 August 2002. The application initiating the proceeding was filed in the High Court on 9 April 2002. It sought orders for Prohibition, Certiorari and Mandamus in respect of a decision of the first respondent, the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”). The Tribunal’s decision affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (“the Minister”), the second respondent to the proceeding, refusing the grant to the applicant of a Protection (Class XA) visa (“protection visa”). The application additionally sought an order prohibiting the Minister from repatriating the applicant to Iran, the applicant’s country of origin.

  2. On remittal from the High Court, this Court made orders on 25 October 2002 progressing the matter to trial. Paragraph 2 of the orders provided that the applicant file and serve proper particulars of the application. Those particulars were filed on 18 December 2002 and read as follows:

    “1.The First Respondent failed to take into account relevant considerations in the exercise of its power under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).

    Particulars

    The Tribunal failed to have regard to the statement made in the Applicant’s screening interview of 10 June 2000 that his arrest related to a “candidate’s voting platform.

    The Tribunal failed to have regard to the statement made by the Applicant in the July/August 2000 Delegate Interview that he had been arrested “after the so called local council elections.”

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Applicant M38/2002 v Refugee Review Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Applicant M38/2002, an Iranian citizen detained in Australia, challenged the Refugee Review Tribunal’s decision to deny his application for a protection visa. The applicant argued that the Tribunal erred in its assessment by not considering certain relevant evidence, specifically his claims about his arrest and interrogation by Iranian authorities. The case reached the Federal Court of Australia, which was tasked with determining whether the Tribunal had indeed overlooked significant considerations that should have influenced its decision.

The central legal issue was whether the Tribunal had erred in the exercise of its power by failing to take into account relevant considerations as referred to in the applicant’s particulars. This involved examining the Tribunal's reasons for decision to determine if it had appropriately considered all relevant submissions and evidence provided by the applicant. The court also had to consider whether the applicant's claims about his past activities and arrests were sufficiently supported and whether these could lead to a well-founded fear of persecution if he were to return to Iran.

In its judgment, the Federal Court found that the Tribunal had not erred in its assessment. The court concluded that the Tribunal was aware of the applicant's claims but had reasonably rejected them as implausible or embellishments. The court found no basis for the argument that the Tribunal was required to accept the applicant's evidence without scrutiny, as the Tribunal was not bound to accept every claim at face value. The court further noted that the applicant had not demonstrated that the Tribunal’s failure to consider certain aspects of his claims amounted to an error that warranted judicial intervention.

The court dismissed the application and ordered the proceeding to be adjourned to a directions hearing to address other aspects of the application. The court reserved costs, indicating that the decision on costs would be made at a later stage.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be adjourned to a directions hearing at 9.45 am on 21 March 2003.

2. Costs be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 30 January 2003, I ordered, pursuant to O29 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules, that the questions arising pursuant to paragraph 1 of the particulars of application “be heard separately from and prior to any other question arising in the proceeding”. Consequently, these reasons for judgment deal only with the issue of whether the first respondent fell into error in the exercise of its power under the Act by failing to take into account relevant considerations, in the sense referred to in the first paragraph of the particulars.Background The applicant, a citizen of Iran, is currently in immigration detention. He arrived in Australia in June 2000 and was detained as an unlawful non-citizen pursuant to the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”). On 10 June 2000, the applicant undertook an Unauthorised Arrivals interview (“the screening interview”) with an officer of the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (“the Department”). The minutes of the screening interview record that the applicant said:“Last year 1999 they objected to a candidate not using a correct sentence in a candidate’s voting platform – so I was taken and asked the extent of my allegiance to the IMAM. Three hours of interrogations with my eyes closed facing the wall. I was not allowed to move.” On 30 June 2000, the applicant applied for a protection visa. Attached to the application was a statement made by the applicant at the detention centre where he was in immigration detention. That statement, dated 30 June 2000, had been translated from Farsi to English. On 9 July 2000, the applicant was interviewed by an officer of the Department (“the July interview”). The interview was recorded. The interview was then translated by an interpreter of the Western Australian Translation and Interpreting Service. On 9 August 2000, a delegate of the Minister refused the grant of a protection visa to the applicant. The July interview formed part of the material before the delegate. On or about 11 August 2000, the applicant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision. The application for review was heard on 13 September 2000 in Sydney, via video link to Port Hedland, where the applicant was held in immigration detention. Regarding the evidence before the Tribunal, the member hearing the application said at p 4 of the Tribunal’s reasons for decision:“The Applicant’s evidence is contained in the record of an initial interview which took place shortly after his arrival in Australia (because he did not have a passport), in his original application for a protection visa, in a statement accompanying that application, in the record of an interview with an officer of the Department which took place on 9 July 2000 and in the record of the hearing before me.” The applicant’s claims before the Tribunal included the claim that when he was still in secondary school he was involved with the leading opposition group in Iran, the Mujahideen-e-Khalq Organisation (“the MKO”), which supports clandestine resistance to the regime in Iran, by distributing newspapers and pamphlets and carrying out terrorist attacks. The applicant claimed that he distributed pamphlets for the MKO and put up posters. He said that he sold the MKO newspaper and worked in a shop that sold MKO books. The applicant claimed that he ceased his activities in respect of the MKO in 1981 when the leader of the MKO was forced to flee Iran and the MKO was suppressed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MARSHALL J
In relation to the applicant’s various claims the Tribunal, at pp 11-15, found as follows:“FINDINGS AND REASONS FOR DECISIONI accept that when the Applicant was still at school he was involved with the MKO but that his involvement did not continue after the MKO was suppressed in Iran in 1981. I accept that the Applicant was detained while doing his military service because his juvenile involvement in the MKO came to light. However I do not accept that the Applicant has a well-founded fear of being persecuted by reason of his juvenile involvement in the MKO if he returns to Iran now or in the reasonably foreseeable future. The Applicant was issued with an Iranian passport in 1996 and, as the Applicant himself noted, this indicates that he did not have security problems at the time.I accept that the Applicant was arrested and questioned for three hours in 1984. However as the Applicant’s evidence developed it appears that he was arrested on this occasion because he was taking notes of a speech made by one of the members of the Hojatieh in a mosque rather than because of his actual or imputed political opinion. In any event no further consequences appear to have flowed for the Applicant as a result of his arrest on this occasion. I do not accept that the Applicant was arrested in March 1999 at the time of the local council elections and questioned about his attitude to Ayatollah Khomeini, as the Applicant said in the statement accompanying his original application. I consider that it is implausible for the Applicant to suggest that he would have been singled out to be arrested and threatened, kicked and beaten for no apparent reason. At the hearing before me the Applicant suggested for the first time that he had in fact been singled out as a result of his involvement in campaigning for a friend in the local council elections. He said that he had mentioned this before but that it had not been translated. However I note that the statement accompanying the Applicant’s original application indicates that it was translated back to him in the Farsi language before he signed it. I consider that the Applicant’s evidence that he was campaigning for a friend in the local council elections is an embellishment intended to provide some explanation for his arrest on this occasion.I likewise do not accept that the Applicant was arrested again in October 1999 as a result of his role in copying an audio tape of Ayatolah Montazeri speaking against Ayatollah Khamenei and a video tape of a student meeting being disrupted by members of the Ansar-e-Hezbollah. I consider that the Applicant’s evidence with regard to this incident is contradictory and implausible. The Applicant suggested that he had been released on this occasion after only three hours because there was no proof but he claimed that the reason he was arrested in the first place was that a tape had passed from him either directly (as he said at the Departmental interview) or indirectly (as he said at the hearing before me) to a person who was working for the Intelligence Service. The Applicant said that he believed that they thought that if he was free he would do some more things and they could have more proof to arrest him in the future but at the same time he suggested that his involvement in copying and distributing the tapes was regarded sufficiently gravely for the Intelligence Service to write to his employers asking them not to employ him anymore.Moreover, if the Applicant had been arrested in October 1999 and released after only three hours so that the authorities could gather more evidence against him, I do not accept that he would then have been allowed to leave Iran travelling on a passport in his own name as he did in March or April 2000. As I put to the Applicant, the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade has advised that travel out of Iran through legal exit points is a reliable indication that a person is of no particular adverse political or security interest (DFAT Country Profile – Islamic Republic of Iran, March 1996, paragraph 1.7.1.3). The Applicant said that the reason he had been able to leave in this way was that he had paid a smuggler $1,000. However, as I put to him, the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade has advised that it would appear virtually impossible for Iranians whose names were on the computerised black-list because they were of adverse political or security interest to use bribery to have their names removed to effect a legal departure from Iran (DFAT Country Information Reports Nos. 78/99, dated 18 March 1999, CX34282, and 185/99, dated 1 June 1999, CX35323).The Applicant said that the smuggler he had used had had connections with a person who worked for the Ministry of Information in Iran. He suggested that the exit of a person whose name was on the computerised black-list was not as serious as some of the other things that occurred in Iran. However I give greater weight to the independent advice of the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade in this regard and I conclude that the Applicant was not perceived by the Iranian Government as being of adverse political or security interest at the time that he left Iran. I do not accept, therefore, that he was arrested in October 1999 and released so that the authorities could gather more information against him nor that he was arrested, detained and beaten in March 1999 by reason of his political opinion, real or imputed. I likewise do not accept that the Applicant was dismissed from his employment in November 1999 at the request of the Intelligence Service following his supposed arrest in October 1999.The Applicant’s representatives submitted that the Applicant’s lengthy absence from Iran and application for refugee status in Australia were likely to attract suspicion on his return to Iran and that this meant that he was likely to face mistreatment which could be characterised as persecutory. However, as I put to the Applicant, the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade has advised that the act of applying for asylum abroad is not, in itself, an offence in Iran. At worst knowledge that an individual had sought political asylum would not result in much more than verbal harassment, unless the asylum-seeker had had a high opposition political profile (DFAT Country Profile – Islamic Republic of Iran, March 1996, paragraph 1.7.6.2).I consider that it is clear that the Applicant does not have a high opposition political profile in Iran. I have rejected above the Applicant’s claims with regard to his arrests in March and October 1999 and I do not accept that the Applicant’s juvenile involvement in the MKO has given him a significant opposition political profile. Once again I note in this connection that the fact that he left Iran travelling on a passport in his own name indicates that he was of no adverse particular political or security interest to the authorities at the time that he left (DFAT Country Profile – Islamic Republic of Iran, March 1996, paragraph 1.7.1.3). The Applicant suggested that he would be imprisoned or even killed if he were to return to Iran but I regard the Applicant’s claims in this regard as fanciful. I do not accept that there is a real chance that the Applicant will be persecuted by reason of his political opinion, real or imputed, if he returns to Iran now or in the reasonably foreseeable future.The Applicant said at the hearing before me that he has converted from Islam, or at least that for the time being he had no religion. He said that he was interested in Christianity and that he was learning about Christianity. He said that if the Iranian Government knew that he wanted to convert to Christianity they would punish him severely. However, as I put to the applicant, the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade has advised that the evidence is that converts to Christianity who go about their devotions quietly are generally not disturbed (DFAT Country Profile – Islamic Republic of Iran, March 1996, paragraph 1.7.7.8). The Applicant said that if a Muslim converted he was regarded as an unbeliever and anyone could kill such a person in the street. However, while apostasy is regularly reported as carrying a death sentence there are only one or two high profile cases (involving Christian clergy) where this penalty has actually been imposed (DFAT Country Profile – Islamic Republic of Iran, March 1996, paragraph 1.7.7.8).As I put to the Applicant, a delegation from a western country which visited the Assemblies of God church in Tehran was told that the Government appeared to be prepared to turn a blind eye to conversions, as long as the church was very discreet and low key in its proselytising activities (DFAT facsimile dated 5 March 1996, CX15554). The Applicant said that he had heard a report on the BBC to the effect that the Iranian Government had asked the leaders of churches in Iran to turn away Iranians who wanted to join their churches. However I do not regard such public pronouncements as necessarily inconsistent with the attitude reported by the Assemblies of God church in Tehran. Obviously the Islamic regime in Iran does not publicly approve of conversions but this does not mean that apostates or converts are in fact persecuted in Iran by reason of their religion. Whether or not the Applicant pursues his interest in Christianity and converts, therefore, I do not accept that there is a real chance that he will be persecuted by reason of his religion if he returns to Iran now or in the reasonably foreseeable future.I have considered the totality of the Applicant’s circumstances as someone who had a juvenile involvement in the MKO which led to his detention while he was undertaking his military service in 1986, as someone who has applied for refugee status in this country and as someone who has turned away from Islam and who has expressed an interest in Christianity. However, even taking into account the cumulative effect of all these circumstances, I am not satisfied that the Applicant has a well-founded fear of being persecuted for a Convention reason if he returns to Iran. It follows that he is not a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees Convention as amended by the Refugees Protocol. Consequently the Applicant does not satisfy the criterion set out in subsection 36(2) of the Migration Act for the grant of a protection visa.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MARSHALL J

Counsel contended that the missing statement from the July interview (being the statement which escaped the original translation) was to the effect that the applicant had been arrested after the local council elections. There was no mention in the statement, however, that the reason for the arrest at the time of the elections was that the applicant had been campaigning for a friend. Therefore, it was submitted, the statement does not contradict anything in the Tribunal’s reasons for decision. Counsel further submitted that the statement recorded in the 10 June 2000 “screening interview” and set out at [5] above, did not assert that the applicant was campaigning for a friend in the 1999 council elections.Consideration I accept the submission of counsel for the Minister that the Tribunal did not err by failing to make express reference in its reasons for decision to the applicant’s statement at his “screening interview” in June 2000 that his arrest related to “a candidate’s voting platform”. The relevant portion of the notes of the screening interview, set out at [5] above, makes no reference to the applicant having campaigned for a friend in 1999. The specific reference is to “a candidate”. There is no basis for the contention that the Tribunal was, in any event, bound to take that evidence into account in coming to its decision; see Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 at 39, per Mason J. I also accept the submission of counsel for the Minister that the Tribunal did not fail to take into account relevant considerations by not having regard to the statement made by the applicant in his interview with the delegate that he had been arrested “after the so-called local council elections”. The passage from the reasons of the Tribunal, quoted from at [29] above, shows that the Tribunal was aware that a claim to that effect was advanced by the applicant. The Tribunal focused on the applicant’s evidence about campaigning for a friend in the elections. It was that aspect of the claim about the applicant’s involvement in the elections which the Tribunal considered to be recent embellishment. It was also that aspect of the applicant’s claim which was not made with sufficient clarity in his screening interview. I see no merit in the applicant’s allegations that the Tribunal failed to take into account relevant considerations in the two specified respects, as referred to in the first particular of the applicant’s “Particulars of Application” filed on 18 December 2002. As a consequence, it is unnecessary for the Court to consider whether the applicant is estopped from raising his current grounds of review, given the history of his efforts to obtain refugee status including by a previous application to this Court. I will order that the proceeding be adjourned to a directions hearing at which time the Court will make orders concerning the progressing of paragraph 2 of the particulars of application, which seeks that the Minister be prohibited from repatriating the applicant to Iran. It would assist the expeditious progress of the directions hearing if the parties would file and serve any written submissions, relevant to any orders they intend to seek at the directions hearing, at least 7 days prior to the directions hearing.