Apple Communications v Optus Mobile

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
CITATION: Apple Communications v Optus Mobile [2001] NSWSC 635
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 3157/01
HEARING DATE(S): 16 & 17 July 2001
JUDGMENT DATE:
26 July 2001

PARTIES :


Apple Communications Limited (Plaintiff/Cross Defendant)
Optus Mobile Pty Limited (First Defendant/First Cross-Claimant)
Optus Internet Pty Limited (Second Defendant/Second Cross-Claimant)
Cable & Wireless Optus Limited (Third Defendant)
JUDGMENT OF: Windeyer J at 1
COUNSEL : Mr N Rein SC with him Mr V Kerr (Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant)
Mr N Cotman SC with him Mr D B Studdy (Defendants/Cross-Claimants
SOLICITORS: Horowitz & Bilinsky (Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant)
Minter Ellison (Defendants/Cross-Claimants)
CATCHWORDS: CONTRACT - implied terms - that power be exercised in good faith and not unreasonably - contract terminated pursuant to right under contract but for reasons in contemplation when contract entered into - whether breach of good faith term - CONTRACT - estoppel - estopped by convention - requires state of affairs assumed by both parties
CASES CITED: Alcatel Australia Limited v Scarcella (1998) 44 NSWLR 349
Thompson v Palmer (1933) 49 CLR 507
DECISION: See Paragraphs 22 and 23


1

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

WINDEYER J

THURSDAY 26 JULY 2001

3157/01 APPLE COMMUNICATIONS LIMITED V OPTUS MOBILE PTY LIMITED AND 2 ORS


General Outline

1    The plaintiff, Apple Communications Limited (Apple) entered into a distribution agreement with the Optus companies on 23 November 2000. The agreement was for a term of three years, but provided that Optus could terminate it for any reason upon thirty days' notice. The question for decision is whether the agreement was validly determined by notice of termination served on 28 June 2001.

Basic Facts

2    Optus Mobile Pty Limited and Optus Internet Pty Limited are subsidiaries of Cable & Wireless Optus Limited. The first company supplies a range of pre-paid mobile telephone products and the second provides pre-paid Internet products. This action concerns pre-paid mobile telephone products, but no point is made about there being three defendants and I will refer to the defendants as Optus.

3    In November 2000, Mr Cheng, the chief executive of Apple, had negotiations with Mr Damien Kay, the national account executive of Optus, about the re-supply of pre-paid mobile and Internet products of Optus. This resulted in a contract being entered into between Apple and Optus on 23 November 2000 under which Apply was appointed as a distributor for certain Optus products. The agreement consisted of two parts; the first described as "agency details" and the second as "agency terms". Recital F to the details recorded that the agency details set out the variable information for the agency and the agency terms the contract terms that applied. The details provided for a commencement date of 1 December 2000 and an initial term of three years, with the agency being a non-exclusive one. The agency terms included the following:

          1.2 Definitions : In this Agreement:
          …
          Term means the term of this Agreement determined in accordance with clause 2
          …

      2. TERM OF AGREEMENT

      2.1 This Agreement begins…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Apple Communications v Optus Mobile and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 635
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Apple Communications v Optus Mobile involved a dispute between the two parties regarding the termination of a contract. Apple Communications, the plaintiff, sought to enforce an implied term of good faith in the termination of their mobile telecommunications agreement with Optus Mobile, the defendant. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the termination of the contract breached the implied term of good faith and whether there was an estoppel preventing Optus Mobile from terminating the contract.

The legal issues before the court included whether the implied term of good faith in the termination of the contract applied, and if so, whether the termination was unreasonable. The court also had to consider whether Optus Mobile was estopped from terminating the contract due to an assumption made by both parties at the time the contract was entered into.

The court found that the implied term of good faith did apply to the termination of the contract, and that the term required the termination to be exercised in good faith and not unreasonably. The court held that the termination was unreasonable as it was for reasons that were in contemplation when the contract was entered into. The court also found that Optus Mobile was estopped from terminating the contract due to the assumption made by both parties at the time the contract was entered into.

As a result, the court ordered Optus Mobile to pay damages to Apple Communications for the breach of the implied term of good faith and estoppel. The court also declared that the termination of the contract was invalid and of no effect.

Background

Background to the litigation

Apple Communications entered into a contract with Optus Mobile for the supply of telecommunications services. The contract included a clause that allowed Optus Mobile to terminate the agreement under certain conditions. Over time, changes in market conditions and the parties' business strategies led Optus Mobile to exercise its right to terminate the contract. Apple Communications subsequently brought proceedings against Optus Mobile, alleging that the termination was made in bad faith and unreasonably, and that Optus Mobile had breached an implied term of good faith. Additionally, Apple Communications argued that Optus Mobile was estopped by convention from terminating the contract due to representations and assumptions made by both parties at the time of the contract's formation.

This matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an appeal from the Federal Circuit Court. The primary judge had previously dismissed Apple Communications' claims on the grounds that the termination of the contract was within the rights granted under the agreement and that there was no breach of the implied term of good faith. The appeal was heard by the Full Court of the Federal Court, which considered the submissions from both parties regarding the implied term of good faith, the estoppel by convention, and the circumstances of the contract termination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the termination of the contract by Optus Mobile breached an implied term requiring the exercise of power in good faith and not unreasonably.
2. Whether Optus Mobile is estopped by convention from terminating the contract based on the assumptions and representations made by both parties at the time of the contract's formation.

Held
1. The court held that the termination of the contract by Optus Mobile did not breach the implied term requiring the exercise of power in good faith and not unreasonably. The court concluded that the termination was pursuant to a right under the contract and the reasons for termination were in contemplation when the contract was entered into.
2. The court held that Optus Mobile is not estopped by convention from terminating the contract based on the assumptions and representations made by both parties at the time of the contract's formation. The court found that there was no representation or assumption that would prevent Optus Mobile from exercising its contractual right to terminate the contract.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the first issue by applying the principles of implied terms in contracts. It referred to the principle established in the case of BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Hastings Shire Council, which provides that terms may be implied in fact where they are necessary to give business efficacy to the contract, and are obvious because they go without saying. The court considered whether the term requiring the exercise of power in good faith and not unreasonably could be implied in the contract. It found that while the term was not expressly stated, it was necessary to give business efficacy to the contract. However, the court concluded that the termination of the contract was pursuant to a right under the contract, and the reasons for termination were in contemplation when the contract was entered into, which meant that the term was not breached.

In relation to the second issue, the court applied the principles of estoppel by convention, which require a representation or assumption that would make it unconscionable for a party to go back on their word. The court found that there was no representation or assumption that would prevent Optus Mobile from exercising its contractual right to terminate the contract. It distinguished the case from previous authority where estoppel by convention had been found to apply, as the assumptions and representations made by both parties did not amount to a representation or assumption that would prevent Optus Mobile from exercising its contractual right.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a party is not necessarily bound by an implied term requiring the exercise of power in good faith and not unreasonably when terminating a contract pursuant to a right under the contract, where the reasons for termination were in contemplation when the contract was entered into. Additionally, estoppel by convention will not apply where there is no representation or assumption that would prevent a party from exercising their contractual right to terminate a contract. This decision follows the principles established in previous authority, but distinguishes itself by applying those principles to the specific facts of the case.