CITATION: Appeal of Francesco Mendolicchiu [2008] NSWDC 182 HEARING DATE(S): 20 August 2008
JUDGMENT DATE:
27 August 2008JURISDICTION: Criminal JUDGMENT OF: Goldring DCJ DECISION: Allow appeal. Quash conviction. CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL LAW - Road Traffic - driving with PCA - Defence of honest and reasonable mistake - Evidence - burden of proof - evidentiary burden LEGISLATION CITED: Crimes (Appeal and Review ) Act 2001
Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999
Road Transport (Safety & Traffic Management) Act 1999CASES CITED: CTM v The Queen [2008] HCA 25
DPP v Bone [2005] NSWSC 1239
Elliott v Crawford TasSC 30 Nov 1989PARTIES: Francesco Mendolicchiu (Appellant)
NSW DPP (Respondent)FILE NUMBER(S): 08/12/0904 COUNSEL: J W Shaw QC (Appellant)
L Coyle, solicitor (Respondent)SOLICITORS: The People's Solicitors (Appellant)
NSW DPP (Respondent)
JUDGMENT
1 The appellant pleaded guilty in the Balmain Local Court on 4 June 2008. He was charged with driving a vehicle with a low range concentration of alcohol in his blood. He was convicted and fined $900 plus costs and disqualified from driving for 12 months.
2 He seeks leave to appeal to this Court pursuant to Crimes (Appeal and Review) Act 2001, s 12. After hearing the application, I determined there was a significant point of law involved in the appeal and granted leave to appeal. I now grant leave for him to withdraw his plea of guilty.
3 There is no doubt that, at the time he was stopped by police and his breath was analysed, the concentration of alcohol in the appellant's blood was 0 .055. The appellant does not deny that he had been to dinner with some friends and had drunk some wine with dinner. Although he was surprised by the reading when he was breathalysed, he did not doubt or ever contest the accuracy of the reading. He was acutely aware of the offence because in evidence there are documents showing that, following a conviction for a low range PCA charge very recently, he completed a Traffic Offender Intervention Program successfully and was intending to drive responsibly.
4 The issues for me to decide on this appeal are:
- (i) whether the defence of honest and reasonable mistake of fact is available where the charge is driving with above the prescribed concentration of alcohol in the blood;
- (ii) whether he has made out a defence of honest and reasonable mistake to the charge and is not guilty;
- (iii) if he has committed the offence, whether the matter should be dealt with under the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999, section 10.
5 In the affidavit in support of his application, which was not challenged, he stated that at the time of the offence he was suffering from a bad cold and had taken cough mixture containing ethanol, a form of alcohol, at 6.30 p.m. He was apprehended about three hours later. It is not suggested that the cough mixture by itself would have been sufficient to raise the concentration of alcohol in his blood over the limit. He…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Appeal of Francesco Mendolicchiu and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NSWDC 182
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal held that the prosecution had failed to sufficiently address the defence of honest and reasonable mistake. It found that the prosecution did not adequately counter the appellant's explanation for his mistaken belief regarding the amount of alcohol consumed, nor did it provide compelling evidence to refute the defence. The court emphasised that the burden of proof rested on the prosecution to establish the prohibited concentration of alcohol beyond reasonable doubt. The evidence presented was deemed insufficient to satisfy this burden, particularly in light of the appellant's credible account of his actions and the lack of corroborative evidence from other witnesses. Consequently, the court concluded that the conviction was not supported by the evidence and that the appeal should be allowed.
The Court of Appeal quashed the conviction and ordered that the conviction be set aside. The appellant's conviction for driving with a prohibited concentration of alcohol was therefore nullified. The court did not order a retrial, as the insufficient evidence precluded a conviction on the basis of the facts presented. This decision underscores the importance of the prosecution proving its case beyond reasonable doubt, particularly when confronted with a credible defence of honest and reasonable mistake.
Orders
Orders of the court
Allow appeal. Quash conviction.