APF Properties Pty Ltd v Kestrel Holdings Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

APF Properties Pty Ltd v Kestrel Holdings Pty Ltd (No 3) [2007] FCA 2016

COSTS – judgment in excess of amount of offer by applicant to two respondents prior to trial – whether Order 23 applicable – whether in any event indemnity costs should be awarded

Federal Court Rules Order 23
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 23 and 43

APF Properties Pty Ltd v Kestrel Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2007] FCA 1561 cited
King v Yurisich (No 2) [2007] FCAFC 51 cited
Aquatec-Maxcon Pty Ltd v Barwon Water Authority (No 3) [2006] VSC 270 cited

Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333 cited

MGICA Pty Ltd v Kenny & Good Pty Ltd (No 2) (1996) 70 FCR 236 cited
John S Hayes & Associates Pty Ltd v Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd (1994) 52 FCR 201 cited
Sanko Steamship Co Ltd v Sumitomo Australia Ltd (unreported, 7 February 1996) cited
Multicon Engineering Pty Ltd v Federal Airports Corporation (1996) 138 ALR 425 cited
WSA Online Limited v Arms (No 2) [2006] FCAFC 108 cited
Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Limited (1993) 46 FCR 225 cited

APF PROPERTIES PTY LTD v KESTREL HOLDINGS PTY LTD, NICOLAS GRAEME ROBINSON, ROBINSON INVESTMENT CAPITAL PTY LTD, HALISBWYN PTY LTD TRADING AS MANTACH WHITMORE VALUATIONS AND HARRISON HUMPHREYS PTY LTD (NO 3)
TAD 27 OF 2005

HEEREY J
19 DECEMBER 2007
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

TASMANIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

TAD 27 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

APF PROPERTIES PTY LTD
Applicant

AND:

KESTREL HOLDINGS PTY LTD
First Respondent

NICOLAS GRAEME ROBINSON
Second Respondent

ROBINSON INVESTMENT CAPITAL PTY LTD
Third Respondent

HALISBWYN PTY LTD TRADING AS MANTACH WHITMORE VALUATIONS
Fourth Respondent

HARRISON HUMPHREYS PTY LTD
Fifth Respondent

JUDGE:

HEEREY J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 DECEMBER 2007

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.There be judgment for the applicant against the first, second and fourth respondents for damages in the sum of $894,568. 

2.There be judgment for the fourth respondent against the first and second respondents for damages in the sum of $894,568.

3.The applicant’s claim against the third respondent for rescission of the Broadmoor lease is dismissed.

4.The first, second and fourth respondents pay the applicant’s costs to be taxed on a party and party basis up until 21 March 2007 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.

5.        The applicant pay the third respondent’s costs to be taxed on a party and party basis.

6.The first and second respondents pay to the fourth respondent the costs that are awarded against it as referred to in order 4.

7.The first and second respondents pay to the fourth respondent its costs of the proceeding to be taxed on a party and party basis.

8.        The time for filing and serving a notice of appeal is extended to 15 February 2008.

9.        There be a stay of judgment against the fourth respondent until 18 January 2008.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read APF Properties Pty Ltd v Kestrel Holdings Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 2016
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of APF Properties Pty Ltd v Kestrel Holdings Pty Ltd (No 3), the dispute revolved around the amount of damages to be awarded to the applicant, APF Properties, for overpaying for certain properties. The respondents, Kestrel Holdings and others, were the vendors of the properties and a valuer who provided a valuation relied upon by the applicant. The substantive judgment had already been handed down, determining the applicant's entitlement to damages, but further argument was heard regarding the precise amount of damages and the costs involved. The applicant argued that it was entitled to the difference between the purchase price and the true value of the properties, along with certain expenses and interest.

The primary legal issue before the court was the calculation of the damages owed by the respondents to the applicant. Specifically, the court had to determine the appropriate amount of interest on the excess borrowings resulting from the overpayment. The applicant argued that the reduction of its commercial bill facility following the sale of certain properties was a reasonable response to the decrease in its borrowings. The respondents contended that the applicant had the benefit of the money from the sale and should not receive further interest on the amount. The court needed to decide whether the applicant's arrangements with its bankers were relevant in calculating the interest owed.

The court found that the applicant's arrangements with its bankers were not relevant for the purposes of calculating the interest owed. Regardless of whether the applicant reduced its commercial bill facility or used the money for another purpose, it had the benefit of the money. Therefore, the respondents should not pay interest for any further period in respect of that amount. The court calculated the damages owed by the respondents to the applicant and ordered that judgment be entered for the applicant against the first, second, and fourth respondents for damages in the sum of $894,568. The court also dismissed the applicant's claim against the third respondent for rescission of the Broadmoor lease. Additionally, the court made orders regarding the costs of the proceeding, including the costs to be paid by the respondents and the applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. There be judgment for the applicant against the first, second and fourth respondents for damages in the sum of $894,568.

2. There be judgment for the fourth respondent against the first and second respondents for damages in the sum of $894,568.

3. The applicant’s claim against the third respondent for rescission of the Broadmoor lease is dismissed.

4. The first, second and fourth respondents pay the applicant’s costs to be taxed on a party and party basis up until 21 March 2007 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.

5. The applicant pay the third respondent’s costs to be taxed on a party and party basis.

6. The first and second respondents pay to the fourth respondent the costs that are awarded against it as referred to in order 4.

7. The first and second respondents pay to the fourth respondent its costs of the proceeding to be taxed on a party and party basis.

8. The time for filing and serving a notice of appeal is extended to 15 February 2008.

9. There be a stay of judgment against the fourth respondent until 18 January 2008.

Background

Background to the litigation

APF Properties Pty Ltd (the applicant) purchased two properties, Broadmoor and Lower Wilmot, from the Robinsons (the first and second respondents). Mantach (the fourth respondent), a valuer, provided a valuation that the applicant relied upon. The applicant claimed it overpaid for the properties and sought damages for the difference between the purchase price and the true value at the time of purchase, along with certain expenses and interest. The Robinsons were the vendors, and Mantach was the valuer whose valuation influenced the purchase. The applicant also argued that it borrowed more than necessary due to overpaying for the properties, and thus, the damages should include interest on the excess borrowing. The applicant sold Lower Wilmot and Mannings Jetty Road on 10 and 12 August 2004, with settlement occurring on 9 September 2004. The total sale price was $850,000. The applicant claimed that its commercial bill facility was reduced by $250,000 in September 2004 and by $508,000 in March 2005, following the sale of the two properties. The applicant argued that this reduction was reasonable given the decrease in borrowings from the sales. The respondents contended that the applicant was not obligated to use the entire sale proceeds to pay off its borrowings.

The substantive judgment in this proceeding was handed down on 15 November 2007 in the case of APF Properties Pty Ltd v Kestrel Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2007] FCA 1561. Following this decision, further argument was heard to determine the amount for which judgment should be entered and the question of costs. The matter before the court involved the interpretation of the substantive judgment concerning the damages and costs to be awarded to the applicant against the Robinsons and Mantach. The court considered the evidence and arguments presented regarding the reduction of the applicant's commercial bill facility post-sale of the properties and the interest on excess borrowings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

HEEREY J
The substantive judgment in this proceeding was handed down on 15 November 2007: APF Properties Pty Ltd v Kestrel Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2007] FCA 1561. Further argument has now been heard as to the amount for which judgment should be entered and the question of costs. Judgment I have found that the applicant is entitled to judgment against the first and second respondents (the Robinsons) and the fourth respondent (Mantach) for damages being the difference between the price paid for Broadmoor and Lower Wilmot and the true value of those properties at the time of purchase, together with certain expenses and interest. The Robinsons were the vendors of the properties and Mantach was a valuer which provided a valuation on which the applicant purchaser relied. It was accepted, at least implicitly, at the substantive hearing that if the applicant paid too much for the property it followed that it borrowed too much and the damages should include interest paid on the excess borrowing. In working out the detail for the purpose of the present hearing it is also accepted that there should be an allowance in the respondents’ favour for that portion of the borrowings attributable to the purchase of Mannings Jetty Road, in respect of which the applicant made no complaint. The price for Mannings Jetty Road constituted 18.25 per cent of the total purchase. Further it is accepted that the actual percentage of the purchase price borrowed was 68 per cent, and not 70 per cent as used by the applicant’s accountant witness Mr Cooper in his calculations. The main dispute on the present hearing centred around the reduction of the applicant’s commercial bill facility following its receipt of funds from the sale of Lower Wilmot and Mannings Jetty Road. These properties were sold on 10 and 12 August 2004 with settlement taking place on 9 September 2004. The total of the two sale prices was $850,000. According to the applicant, the bill facility was reduced by $250,000 in September 2004 and then by $508,000 in March 2005. Mr O’Farrell submitted that this was a reasonable response to the reduction of the applicant’s borrowings following those sales. The payments totalling $758,000 represented almost the entirety of the proportionate amount borrowed on the properties. He contended that the applicant was not under any obligation to pay off, against its borrowings, the whole of the sale proceeds on the two properties. That obligation depended on the applicant’s arrangements with its bankers. In my opinion, the applicant’s arrangements with its bankers are not relevant for present purposes. As Mr Ayliffe for the Robinsons pointed out, once the sale of Lower Wilmot and Mannings Jetty Road was settled the applicant had the use of the money. Whether the applicant was able to reduce the commercial bill facility or preferred to use the money for some other purpose, it nevertheless had the benefit of the money. The respondents should not pay interest for any further period in respect of that amount.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HEEREY J

The court considered the overpayment of the purchase price for Broadmoor and Lower Wilmot and determined the difference between the price paid and the true value of those properties at the time of purchase. It accepted that the applicant had borrowed more than necessary due to the overpayment and that the damages should include interest on these excess borrowings. However, the court limited the interest to the portion attributable to the properties in question, excluding Mannings Jetty Road. Regarding the reduction of the applicant's commercial bill facility, the court found that the applicant had the benefit of the money from the sale of Lower Wilmot and Mannings Jetty Road, regardless of its arrangements with its bankers. Therefore, the respondents should not pay interest for any further period in respect of the amount paid off against the borrowings. The court's approach to damages and interest was based on ensuring that the applicant was compensated for the overpayment while also considering the practicalities of the applicant's financial arrangements. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that damages for overpayment in a property transaction should be calculated based on the true value of the properties at the time of purchase, including interest on excess borrowings attributable to those properties, and that the benefit derived from the sale of other properties should be considered in determining the extent of the obligation to repay borrowings.