AOB18 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

AOB18 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2025] FedCFamC2G 1450

File number(s): SYG 1319 of 2024
Judgment of: JUDGE LAING
Date of judgment: 8 September 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION - application for judicial review of a decision by the Immigration Assessment Authority (“IAA”) affirming refusal of a protection visa – whether the IAA failed to consider evidence or claims – whether the IAA’s decision was otherwise affected by relevant error – application dismissed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36 & 473DD
Cases cited:

BYX17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 41

CNY17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] HCA 50; (2019) 94 ALJR 140

FSG17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 29; (2020) 274 FCR 456

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v CRS20 [2022] FCA 579

Division: General
Number of paragraphs: 36
Date of last submission/s: 26 June 2025
Date of hearing: 1 May 2025
Place: Sydney
Appearing for the Applicant: In person
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr T Reilly
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor
Second Respondent: Submitting appearance, save as to costs

ORDERS

SYG 1319 of 2024

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

AOB18

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP

First Respondent

IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE LAING

DATE OF ORDER:

8 SEPTEMBER 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The name of the first respondent be amended to “Minister for Immigration and Citizenship”.

2.The application be dismissed.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 24.04(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2025 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 24.04 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2025 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE LAING:

  1. The applicant seeks judicial review of a decision made by the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) (as it was). The IAA affirmed a decision of a delegate (Delegate) of the first respondent (Minister) refusing to grant the applicant a Safe Haven Enterprise (Class XE) (Subclass 790) visa (protection visa).

  2. For the following reasons, I consider that I am obliged to dismiss the application before the Court.

    BACKGROUND

  3. The applicant applied for the protection visa that is the subject of this proceeding in September 2021.

  4. On 30 November 2023, the Delegate refused the application. The matter was then referred to the IAA for review.

  5. The applicant was invited by the IAA to comment on or respond to certain information on 12 February 2024. He submitted material to the IAA and, on 20 March 2024, attended an interview conducted by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AOB18 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 1450
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves AOB18, an applicant for a protection visa, who sought judicial review of the decision by the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) affirming the refusal of their visa application. The applicant argued that the IAA failed to consider certain evidence or claims and that the IAA's decision was otherwise affected by relevant errors. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the IAA's review was conducted correctly and whether the decision was legally sound.

The primary legal issues were whether the IAA appropriately considered all relevant evidence and claims, and whether the IAA's decision contained any errors that warranted judicial intervention. The applicant contended that the IAA neglected to consider certain evidence regarding their criminal history in Australia and that the IAA's assessment of the applicant's credibility and new claims was flawed. The Minister for Immigration and Citizenship defended the IAA's decision, arguing that it was conducted correctly and that the IAA appropriately assessed the evidence before it.

The Court examined the IAA's review process and found that it had appropriately identified and considered the relevant information under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The Court noted that the IAA had invited the applicant to comment on its intended approach to the information but ultimately decided not to consider it as relevant to the review. The Court held that the IAA's decision to disregard the criminal history evidence was reasonable given the context of the review. Regarding the new claims, the Court found that the IAA had carefully considered the credibility of the applicant's evidence, taking into account their mental health, the timing of the claims, and the applicant's admissions of untruthfulness. The Court concluded that the IAA's assessment of the evidence was thorough and that the IAA's decision did not contain any errors warranting judicial intervention.

The Court dismissed the application for judicial review, affirming the IAA's decision. The Court found that the IAA had correctly considered the relevant information and that the IAA's decision was legally sound. The Court held that the applicant's claims of procedural unfairness and error in the IAA's decision were unfounded.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, I consider that I am obliged to dismiss the application before the Court.BACKGROUND The applicant applied for the protection visa that is the subject of this proceeding in September 2021. On 30 November 2023, the Delegate refused the application. The matter was then referred to the IAA for review. The applicant was invited by the IAA to comment on or respond to certain information on 12 February 2024. He submitted material to the IAA and, on 20 March 2024, attended an interview conducted by the IAA. On 14 May 2024, the IAA affirmed the Delegate’s decision.THE IAA’S DECISION The IAA observed that information was provided in the review material regarding criminal charges, convictions and sentencing of the applicant in Australia, as well as reasons for refusing him a bridging visa. The IAA did not consider this material to be relevant to the review. However, the IAA observed that it had invited the applicant to comment upon its intended approach to the information. The IAA expressed that it “had no regard” to the information in relation to the review (at [4]-[5]). The IAA observed that it had received new information that had been provided after the Delegate’s decision. That information was assessed against the criteria for consideration under s 473DD of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act). The IAA found that the relevant criteria for consideration were met in relation to a series of information relevant to the applicant’s mental health, new claims that he had made, certain country information, as well as certain new information that he had otherwise provided in writing and at interview (at [5]-[38]). In relation to certain country information reports, although the IAA found that s 473DD(b) was not met, the IAA considered that there were exceptional circumstances justifying their consideration. The IAA therefore obtained them for the purposes of the review (at [38]). The IAA similarly obtained the most recent report from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade on Sri Lanka (at [39]). The IAA considered the claims and evidence before it in some detail at [40]–[107] of its decision, before summarising its findings as follows at [108]-[116] (some parts have been redacted to prevent identification of the applicant and others):108.I have set out my significant concerns with the credibility of the applicant’s claims. The belated introduction of such significant new claims now relied upon raises doubt, for the reasons expressed. The applicant has admitted, to the delegate and the IAA, that he has been untruthful in his claims and interaction during this process. I consider carefully the credibility concerns arising, conscious of the issues that can be at play in a change of claims and such admission, and that belated claim or change is not necessarily of itself demonstrative that a new claim is not true. However, as discussed above, the serious concerns with the credibility of the applicant’s new claims and account, and of being personally targeted as of real adverse concern in Sri Lanka, are for matters beyond merely of the LTTE claim belatedly raised, or associated accounts changed from that previous pressed. I have real concern about the shifting, escalating, unpersuasive, contradictory and implausible aspects of much of the applicant’s evidence.109.I have considered the mental health reports. I accept psychological issues such as the experience of past trauma can affect a person’s memory and ability to give coherent evidence and that living in Sri Lanka up until 2012, an environment of past prolonged armed conflict, serious human rights violations and military occupation, experiences of family injury and being questioned by authorities, may have been traumatic for the applicant. I accept that the applicant has been diagnosed with depression and anxiety and has presented with symptoms consistent with PTSD. I accept Doctors… expressed some concern about apparent cognitive function; but there is no diagnosis of Neurocognitive Disorder or cognitive impairment before me, and I do not make such a finding. As already discussed, I have significant concern about applicant’s presentation to the authors of the mental health reports before me and the circumstances and motivations at play in the timing of those assessments, noting the one-off event and purpose of the 2018 Psychiatry Report, and noting also the applicant’s willingness to be dishonest not only to the Department and to the IAA, but also to his STARTTS counsellor about the basis of his claimed recent increasing psychological distress, from the claimed sword attack on his family. The evidence before me illustrates that in choosing what claims to raise or story to tell or not the applicant has had some influence and inspiration from others – Tamils in the community, an LTTE asylum seeker friend, his sister - including in deciding to raise a series of false claims. I have real concern about this regarding his new claims, encouraged from advice by his LTTE asylum seeker friend including about whether changed claims would be believed, before seeing [name redacted], before the SHEV interview where he raised the new claims, and also regarding his presentation to healthcare report authors. [Name redacted] described in the August 2023 Assessment Report that the applicant reported experiencing nightmares, flashbacks and intense physiological reactions when reminded of traumatic events from his past such as detention, torture, disappearance and murder of family members, and engaged in high level of avoidance behaviours to prevent reminders of traumatic events. I have concern as to whether such claimed symptoms and behaviour are compatible with attending at Maaveerar Nal events to commemorate killed LTTE members, and note such activity now claimed by the applicant in 2016 was not recorded by [name redacted], suggesting this was not reported to him.110.For all the reasons discussed, I am not satisfied that the applicant’s mental health concerns adequately explain his failure to raise the LTTE claims and accounts belatedly now relied upon or outweigh the concerns identified with this claim. I am not satisfied that the applicant’s evidence or his ability to give account of his circumstances in Sri Lanka has been negatively impacted or prevented by any of his mental health concerns. And whilst I accept the applicant may have struggled to fully understand all the legal issues related to the various court/tribunal proceedings concerning his protection visa applications and bars on earlier applications, I am not satisfied by his explanation of continued heavy reliance on lay people advice, about his claims raised, after being provided with legal assistance for his several different visa applications and associated visa legal proceedings.111.For all the reasons discussed earlier, and not just the late introduction of these claims, I do not accept that the applicant was an LTTE member, or that he was in [specified areas] in 2008/2009 as claimed or was detained and interrogated in an IDP camp and released by bribery. I do not accept that the applicant’s father or (A) or any close family members, including an uncle (N) were LTTE members or cadres or supporters. I do not accept, on the unsubstantiated evidence before me, the very vague claims of various unspecified relatives, being LTTE members or LTTE combatants. I have accepted the applicant and his parents originated from areas formerly under LTTE control at different times. I do not accept the applicant’s family or relatives were involved with the LTTE other than incidentally from living in areas formerly under LTTE control. I do not accept that the applicant was regarded by the authorities as being from an LTTE family.112.I have significant concern with the unreliability of much of the applicant’s evidence concerning being targeted in Sri Lanka. Even taking into account the applicant’s mental health issues in assessing his claims and differing evidence, overall, I am not satisfied that these adequately explain or overcome the significant concerns I have with the credibility of those claims. His father was from [a specified area], as was (A), and I find that the applicant’s earlier claims of spending time in [area] in 2008 and this being a circumstance about which he would be asked questions in round-up detentions to be plausible and credible. However, whilst it is not implausible for the applicant to be exposed to questioning or checks by authorities in that era, as a young Tamil man in [a specified area] and with family roots and time spent in [another area], I have concern that he has greatly exaggerated such instances into a personal, ongoing targeting of him and his brother-in-law (A), or particular interest in him and (A) by the authorities.113.As earlier discussed, I have very serious doubt that the applicant’s father and an unnamed uncle were personally targeted to be shot. I do not accept they were LTTE members or supporters. I accept they were shot and injured in about 2006, but I am not satisfied that these shootings, or the shooting of a local school boy in [an area], were anything other than random violence in that era. I do not accept that the applicant was regarded by the authorities as being from an LTTE family, or that any aspect of his immediate family relationships brought the applicant to any adverse concern of the authorities or any other persons.114.I am prepared to accept the applicant’s claims in his SHEV statement that he was twice caught up in general SLA round-ups with others in [an area] and taken for questioning - first in 2010 at [a specified location] (with (A)) as described above, and then at a school near his home in 2011. It is possible that he may have experienced some mistreatment in the overnight questioning by the CID/SLA, given reported widespread mistreatment of Tamils detained in that era.27 I find this was the not uncommon experience of many young Tamil men in that era and reflected opportunistic information gathering and the general suspicions of the authorities against most Tamils. However, I do not accept that the applicant was personally targeted for these round ups or detentions, nor that he signed any confessions or was required to return for reporting. I am prepared to accept that armed men came to his house one day in 2011 and with guns made him and (A) kneel. I do not accept that they were looking for the applicant and/or (A), or a relative of his, or took them to an uncle’s house. I find his claim that the men merely conducted a search of the neighbourhood and later arrested a man in a neighbouring house in the village more convincing and plausible. It is possible this man later died. I do not accept the applicant or (A) were targeted in this search; I find they were merely at one of the village houses secured for the neighbourhood search.115.I accept that such incidents may have caused the applicant general fear for his safety at the time, but I do not accept that he went into hiding for two years before he left Sri Lanka or that he was in hiding at the ICRC or anywhere else in that time. I do not accept that the CID, SLA or any Sri Lankan authorities or other persons had genuine suspicion or concern that the applicant (or (A)) was really an LTTE member or supporter or of any adverse concern beyond the general imputations that most Tamil men in or from the north faced in that era. I do not accept that the CID, SLA or any Sri Lankan authorities or other persons were searching for or coming to enquire about or targeting the applicant and/or (A) at this or at any time for any reason claimed or at all, then or since the applicant departed Sri Lanka in 2012.116.I do not accept that the applicant or (A) filed a court case or legal complaint against the SLA or Sri Lanka Government concerning seized family land, and I do not accept that any family land of any close relative or of (A) or (N) has been occupied by the SLA or any Sri Lankan authorities. I do not accept there was or is currently any impending or ongoing court case of any kind against or involving the applicant in Sri Lanka.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 14 May 2024, the IAA affirmed the Delegate’s decision.THE IAA’S DECISION The IAA observed that information was provided in the review material regarding criminal charges, convictions and sentencing of the applicant in Australia, as well as reasons for refusing him a bridging visa. The IAA did not consider this material to be relevant to the review. However, the IAA observed that it had invited the applicant to comment upon its intended approach to the information. The IAA expressed that it “had no regard” to the information in relation to the review (at [4]-[5]). The IAA observed that it had received new information that had been provided after the Delegate’s decision. That information was assessed against the criteria for consideration under s 473DD of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act). The IAA found that the relevant criteria for consideration were met in relation to a series of information relevant to the applicant’s mental health, new claims that he had made, certain country information, as well as certain new information that he had otherwise provided in writing and at interview (at [5]-[38]). In relation to certain country information reports, although the IAA found that s 473DD(b) was not met, the IAA considered that there were exceptional circumstances justifying their consideration. The IAA therefore obtained them for the purposes of the review (at [38]). The IAA similarly obtained the most recent report from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade on Sri Lanka (at [39]). The IAA considered the claims and evidence before it in some detail at [40]–[107] of its decision, before summarising its findings as follows at [108]-[116] (some parts have been redacted to prevent identification of the applicant and others):108.I have set out my significant concerns with the credibility of the applicant’s claims. The belated introduction of such significant new claims now relied upon raises doubt, for the reasons expressed. The applicant has admitted, to the delegate and the IAA, that he has been untruthful in his claims and interaction during this process. I consider carefully the credibility concerns arising, conscious of the issues that can be at play in a change of claims and such admission, and that belated claim or change is not necessarily of itself demonstrative that a new claim is not true. However, as discussed above, the serious concerns with the credibility of the applicant’s new claims and account, and of being personally targeted as of real adverse concern in Sri Lanka, are for matters beyond merely of the LTTE claim belatedly raised, or associated accounts changed from that previous pressed. I have real concern about the shifting, escalating, unpersuasive, contradictory and implausible aspects of much of the applicant’s evidence.109.I have considered the mental health reports. I accept psychological issues such as the experience of past trauma can affect a person’s memory and ability to give coherent evidence and that living in Sri Lanka up until 2012, an environment of past prolonged armed conflict, serious human rights violations and military occupation, experiences of family injury and being questioned by authorities, may have been traumatic for the applicant. I accept that the applicant has been diagnosed with depression and anxiety and has presented with symptoms consistent with PTSD. I accept Doctors… expressed some concern about apparent cognitive function; but there is no diagnosis of Neurocognitive Disorder or cognitive impairment before me, and I do not make such a finding. As already discussed, I have significant concern about applicant’s presentation to the authors of the mental health reports before me and the circumstances and motivations at play in the timing of those assessments, noting the one-off event and purpose of the 2018 Psychiatry Report, and noting also the applicant’s willingness to be dishonest not only to the Department and to the IAA, but also to his STARTTS counsellor about the basis of his claimed recent increasing psychological distress, from the claimed sword attack on his family. The evidence before me illustrates that in choosing what claims to raise or story to tell or not the applicant has had some influence and inspiration from others – Tamils in the community, an LTTE asylum seeker friend, his sister - including in deciding to raise a series of false claims. I have real concern about this regarding his new claims, encouraged from advice by his LTTE asylum seeker friend including about whether changed claims would be believed, before seeing [name redacted], before the SHEV interview where he raised the new claims, and also regarding his presentation to healthcare report authors. [Name redacted] described in the August 2023 Assessment Report that the applicant reported experiencing nightmares, flashbacks and intense physiological reactions when reminded of traumatic events from his past such as detention, torture, disappearance and murder of family members, and engaged in high level of avoidance behaviours to prevent reminders of traumatic events. I have concern as to whether such claimed symptoms and behaviour are compatible with attending at Maaveerar Nal events to commemorate killed LTTE members, and note such activity now claimed by the applicant in 2016 was not recorded by [name redacted], suggesting this was not reported to him.110.For all the reasons discussed, I am not satisfied that the applicant’s mental health concerns adequately explain his failure to raise the LTTE claims and accounts belatedly now relied upon or outweigh the concerns identified with this claim. I am not satisfied that the applicant’s evidence or his ability to give account of his circumstances in Sri Lanka has been negatively impacted or prevented by any of his mental health concerns. And whilst I accept the applicant may have struggled to fully understand all the legal issues related to the various court/tribunal proceedings concerning his protection visa applications and bars on earlier applications, I am not satisfied by his explanation of continued heavy reliance on lay people advice, about his claims raised, after being provided with legal assistance for his several different visa applications and associated visa legal proceedings.111.For all the reasons discussed earlier, and not just the late introduction of these claims, I do not accept that the applicant was an LTTE member, or that he was in [specified areas] in 2008/2009 as claimed or was detained and interrogated in an IDP camp and released by bribery. I do not accept that the applicant’s father or (A) or any close family members, including an uncle (N) were LTTE members or cadres or supporters. I do not accept, on the unsubstantiated evidence before me, the very vague claims of various unspecified relatives, being LTTE members or LTTE combatants. I have accepted the applicant and his parents originated from areas formerly under LTTE control at different times. I do not accept the applicant’s family or relatives were involved with the LTTE other than incidentally from living in areas formerly under LTTE control. I do not accept that the applicant was regarded by the authorities as being from an LTTE family.112.I have significant concern with the unreliability of much of the applicant’s evidence concerning being targeted in Sri Lanka. Even taking into account the applicant’s mental health issues in assessing his claims and differing evidence, overall, I am not satisfied that these adequately explain or overcome the significant concerns I have with the credibility of those claims. His father was from [a specified area], as was (A), and I find that the applicant’s earlier claims of spending time in [area] in 2008 and this being a circumstance about which he would be asked questions in round-up detentions to be plausible and credible. However, whilst it is not implausible for the applicant to be exposed to questioning or checks by authorities in that era, as a young Tamil man in [a specified area] and with family roots and time spent in [another area], I have concern that he has greatly exaggerated such instances into a personal, ongoing targeting of him and his brother-in-law (A), or particular interest in him and (A) by the authorities.113.As earlier discussed, I have very serious doubt that the applicant’s father and an unnamed uncle were personally targeted to be shot. I do not accept they were LTTE members or supporters. I accept they were shot and injured in about 2006, but I am not satisfied that these shootings, or the shooting of a local school boy in [an area], were anything other than random violence in that era. I do not accept that the applicant was regarded by the authorities as being from an LTTE family, or that any aspect of his immediate family relationships brought the applicant to any adverse concern of the authorities or any other persons.114.I am prepared to accept the applicant’s claims in his SHEV statement that he was twice caught up in general SLA round-ups with others in [an area] and taken for questioning - first in 2010 at [a specified location] (with (A)) as described above, and then at a school near his home in 2011. It is possible that he may have experienced some mistreatment in the overnight questioning by the CID/SLA, given reported widespread mistreatment of Tamils detained in that era.27 I find this was the not uncommon experience of many young Tamil men in that era and reflected opportunistic information gathering and the general suspicions of the authorities against most Tamils. However, I do not accept that the applicant was personally targeted for these round ups or detentions, nor that he signed any confessions or was required to return for reporting. I am prepared to accept that armed men came to his house one day in 2011 and with guns made him and (A) kneel. I do not accept that they were looking for the applicant and/or (A), or a relative of his, or took them to an uncle’s house. I find his claim that the men merely conducted a search of the neighbourhood and later arrested a man in a neighbouring house in the village more convincing and plausible. It is possible this man later died. I do not accept the applicant or (A) were targeted in this search; I find they were merely at one of the village houses secured for the neighbourhood search.115.I accept that such incidents may have caused the applicant general fear for his safety at the time, but I do not accept that he went into hiding for two years before he left Sri Lanka or that he was in hiding at the ICRC or anywhere else in that time. I do not accept that the CID, SLA or any Sri Lankan authorities or other persons had genuine suspicion or concern that the applicant (or (A)) was really an LTTE member or supporter or of any adverse concern beyond the general imputations that most Tamil men in or from the north faced in that era. I do not accept that the CID, SLA or any Sri Lankan authorities or other persons were searching for or coming to enquire about or targeting the applicant and/or (A) at this or at any time for any reason claimed or at all, then or since the applicant departed Sri Lanka in 2012.116.I do not accept that the applicant or (A) filed a court case or legal complaint against the SLA or Sri Lanka Government concerning seized family land, and I do not accept that any family land of any close relative or of (A) or (N) has been occupied by the SLA or any Sri Lankan authorities. I do not accept there was or is currently any impending or ongoing court case of any kind against or involving the applicant in Sri Lanka.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established