LAND COURT, BRISBANE
[2000] QLC 72
10 November 2000
Re:Appeal against Annual Valuation - Valuation of Land Act 1944 - Property ID: 1110778 -
Local Government: Brisbane City - South Brisbane (AV00-517).
Michael J and Demetra Anthony v.
Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources
DECISION ON JURISDICTION
Background:
This matter relates to land at 90-92 Vulture Street, South Brisbane, and described as Lot 10 on RP218258, Parish of South Brisbane. The subject land is used as professional offices, and has an area of 1021 square metres. The matter before the Court relates to the preliminary question of whether the Court has jurisdiction to hear the merits of the matter in respect of an appeal against an annual valuation at 1 October 1999 under the Valuation of Land Act 1944. Michael J Anthony appeared and gave evidence for the appellants. Mr R Paterson, Principal Legal Officer, appeared for the respondent.
The Facts:
The Chief Executive issued a valuation of the subject land on 27 March 2000 at $950,000. Following an objection the Chief Executive revised the unimproved value to $770,000 on 27 June 2000. The appellants appealed that figure on 14 August 2000, together with a letter of authority for James Varitimos to act as their agent.
On 17 August 2000, the Registrar of the Land Court notified the appellants that the appeal appeared to have been lodged after the statutory period of 42 days allowed for an appeal under s.45(2) of the Act, which was 8 August 2000. The Registrar advised that such an appeal did not lie, unless the appellant was able to satisfy the requirements of s.57(1) and (2), copies of which were supplied to the appellant for information. That notification of 17 August 2000 by the Registrar
specified a reply within 21 days, as to whether the appeal would be proceeding, or advice if the matter was to be withdrawn. There was no response from the appellants to the Registrar.
On 12 September 2000 the Registrar wrote to the appellants advising that a response had not been received, and the matter would be set down by the Court in order to determine the preliminary point of jurisdiction. On 9 October 2000, a court notice was sent to the appellants advising that the matter of jurisdiction would be heard on 24 October 2000. Copies of all correspondence to the appellants were forwarded to the respondent for information.
Mr Anthony explains that he had informed the Court by letter of 18 October 2000 of the background to his appeal as follows:
(1)The notice of appeal was filed by Mr Anthony's wife personally before leaving on vacation on 2 August 2000.
(2)Within one week of departing on vacation the file on the subject land was delivered to Mr Varitimos, a solicitor handling the matter for the appellants in their absence.
(3)The appellants became aware that the notice of appeal had not been filed correctly with the Court only on their return to Australia on 5 October 2000.
(4)Investigations subsequently revealed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Anthony v Department of Natural Resources and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] QLC 72
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court examined the statutory interpretation of the amended section 57(1) of the Valuation of Land Act 1944, which allowed the Court greater discretion in considering the reasonableness of the appellants' excuse for the delay. The Court also considered relevant case law on the distinction between procedural and substantive statutes, and the retrospective application of legislative amendments. After reviewing the evidence and arguments presented, the Court found that the appellants had not satisfied the statutory requirements for lodging an appeal within the prescribed time limit. The appellants' failure to respond to the requisition by the Registrar of the Land Court as required under section 58(3) further undermined their case. The Court concluded that the appellants had not provided a reasonable excuse for the delay in lodging their appeal and therefore dismissed the appeal, finding that it had no jurisdiction to hear the matter.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi