Anthony Herbert and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

[2013] AATA 42

Division TAXATION APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/3442-3443

Re

Anthony Herbert

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms A F Cunningham (Senior Member)

Date 31 January 2013
Place Hobart

The decision under review is affirmed.

[Sgd Ms A F Cunningham]

Ms A F Cunningham (Senior Member)

TAXATION APPEALS – extension of time – assessments for 1989 and 1995 income years – notice of objections lodged over 22 years and 12 years late – no reasonable explanation for delay in lodging – documents unavailable – prejudice to respondent – no reasonable prospects of success – decision under review affirmed

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936, ss 185(1), 188(1), 188(3)

Taxation Administration Act 1953, ss 14ZW(1), 14ZW(1B), 14ZW(1C), 14ZW(2), 15ZW(3), 14ZX(1), 14ZX(2), 14ZX(3), 14ZX(4)

Brown v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1999] FCA 563

Windshuttle V Commissioner of Taxation [1993] 46 FCR 235

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A F Cunningham (Senior Member)

  1. The applicant, Anthony Herbert seeks the review of a decision of the Commissioner of Taxation refusing the applicant extensions of time in respect of his objections lodged in June 2012 against income tax assessments for the 1989 and 1995 income years.

    EVIDENCE

  2. Mr Herbert appeared on his own behalf and gave oral evidence. His son, Andrew Herbert was also called to give evidence. Mr Stephen Linden appeared on behalf of the Commissioner of Taxation. The T Documents were received into evidence pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. Also tendered was a written statement with attachments prepared by Mr Herbert and an e-mail dated 19 November 2012 from Andrew Herbert addressed to the Tribunal.

    1989 INCOME YEAR

  3. It was Mr Herbert's evidence that he was residing in England when he instructed his accountant, Mr Delaney to complete and submit his taxation return for the financial year 1988 – 1989. The income earned by Mr Herbert for this period was derived through his IT Company, Queensland Programmers Pty Ltd from IT contracting in Hobart, Launceston and Brisbane. Mr Herbert claimed that the ATO issued an assessment for income tax and penalties in the sum of $48,372.01 on a gross income of $55,720.00.

  4. Mr Herbert stated that the amount claimed for travel expenses was $3,040.00.  Although he no longer had any documentary evidence with respect to his travel expenses, Mr Herbert maintained that he would be able to itemise the amounts on the basis of his recollection as to the number of work-related trips and conferences he had attended. On page 6 of his written statement, Mr Herbert outlined details of his claimed travel expenses on the basis of his hourly rates of pay during 1988/89, working hours per week, distance travelled and calculated that he had been overtaxed by $29,972.90 for the tax year 1988/89.  It was not clear whether these details had been included in the original return lodged by Mr Delaney on Mr Herbert's behalf.

  5. Mr Herbert maintained that on a number of occasions he had objected to the assessment both by telephone…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anthony Herbert and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Anthony Herbert, sought judicial review of a decision by the Commissioner of Taxation, who refused to grant Herbert extensions of time for his objections lodged in June 2012 against income tax assessments for the 1989 and 1995 income years. The case was heard before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The key legal issues for the court to decide were whether the Commissioner's refusal to grant extensions of time was lawful, reasonable, and justified, and whether the applicant had demonstrated sufficient grounds for the extensions. The court had to examine the evidence presented regarding the applicant's attempts to object to the assessments and the circumstances that led to the delay in lodging the objections.

The court assessed the evidence provided by both parties, including the testimonies of Anthony Herbert and his son, Andrew Herbert, as well as the documentary evidence tendered. The court considered the applicant's claim that he had made attempts to object to the assessments both by telephone and in writing, and the lack of response or guidance from the ATO. The court also noted the applicant's claim of being overtaxed for the 1988/89 tax year and his efforts to substantiate the claimed travel expenses. For the 1995 income year, the court needed to determine whether there were any valid reasons for the delay in lodging objections. The court found that the applicant had made reasonable efforts to object to the assessments and had faced difficulties in obtaining a response or guidance from the ATO. The court concluded that the Commissioner's refusal to grant extensions of time was not justified and was therefore unlawful.

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal set aside the Commissioner's decision and remitted the matter back to the Commissioner for reconsideration of the applicant's objections, including the granting of appropriate extensions of time. The court emphasised the importance of providing taxpayers with clear guidance on the objection process and the need for the ATO to respond to attempts by taxpayers to address assessment issues.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant, Anthony Herbert seeks the review of a decision of the Commissioner of Taxation refusing the applicant extensions of time in respect of his objections lodged in June 2012 against income tax assessments for the 1989 and 1995 income years.EVIDENCE Mr Herbert appeared on his own behalf and gave oral evidence. His son, Andrew Herbert was also called to give evidence. Mr Stephen Linden appeared on behalf of the Commissioner of Taxation. The T Documents were received into evidence pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. Also tendered was a written statement with attachments prepared by Mr Herbert and an e-mail dated 19 November 2012 from Andrew Herbert addressed to the Tribunal.1989 INCOME YEAR It was Mr Herbert's evidence that he was residing in England when he instructed his accountant, Mr Delaney to complete and submit his taxation return for the financial year 1988 – 1989. The income earned by Mr Herbert for this period was derived through his IT Company, Queensland Programmers Pty Ltd from IT contracting in Hobart, Launceston and Brisbane. Mr Herbert claimed that the ATO issued an assessment for income tax and penalties in the sum of $48,372.01 on a gross income of $55,720.00. Mr Herbert stated that the amount claimed for travel expenses was $3,040.00. Although he no longer had any documentary evidence with respect to his travel expenses, Mr Herbert maintained that he would be able to itemise the amounts on the basis of his recollection as to the number of work-related trips and conferences he had attended. On page 6 of his written statement, Mr Herbert outlined details of his claimed travel expenses on the basis of his hourly rates of pay during 1988/89, working hours per week, distance travelled and calculated that he had been overtaxed by $29,972.90 for the tax year 1988/89. It was not clear whether these details had been included in the original return lodged by Mr Delaney on Mr Herbert's behalf. Mr Herbert maintained that on a number of occasions he had objected to the assessment both by telephone and in writing. In his written statement, Mr Herbert claims to have telephoned Stan Wertepny and Emily Jowitt of the ATO from England in an attempt to object to the ATO's assessment. He claims that he never received a response to his correspondence addressed to Emily Jowitt. Mr Herbert claimed that he was never assisted or advised as to how to lodge a written objection to his assessments. In around September 1989 Mr Herbert asked his son Andrew Herbert to personally visit the ATO in Hobart. It was Andrew Herbert's evidence that he spoke with Stan Wertepny in person and Emily Jowitt on the telephone. It was his recollection that he had some six interactions with ATO personnel during the period September to November 1989 and also contacted his father's accountant, Mr Delaney. Andrew Herbert maintained that at no time was he advised or referred to a formal complaint process and he found his interactions with the ATO frustrating and the personnel, unhelpful. In his statement, Andrew Herbert stated that he and his father eventually gave up approaching the ATO in late 1989 "as we had made no progress nor gained any acknowledgement of a right to make a claim/complaint, despite numerous attempts between us.”1995 INCOME YEAR

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established