Anthony Golzio v Downer Edi

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

CITATION:    ANTHONY GOLZIO V DOWNER EDI [2021] NTLC 005

PARTIES:MR ANTHONY GOLZIO

V

DOWNER EDI

TITLE OF COURT:  WORK HEALTH COURT

JURISDICTION:  WORK HEALTH

FILE NO(S):21919346

DELIVERED ON:  12 FEBRUARY 2021

DELIVERED AT:  DARWIN

HEARING DATE(S):  26-30 OCTOBER 2020

JUDGMENT OF:  JUDGE ELISABETH ARMITAGE

CATCHWORDS:

Counterclaim by the Employer; onus of proof; causation or aggravation of injury; loss of earning capacity; surveillance evidence; “reasonably capable of earning”; “most profitable employment reasonably available”; “real job”.

Return to Work Act sections 65(2), 65(5), 68

Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act section 128

Quality Plumbing & Building Contractors Pty Ltd v Schloss [2015] NTSC 56

Catford v Laminex [2021] NTLC 004

Plewright v Passmore t/as Passmore Roofing unreported Supreme Court decision delivered 4 April 1997

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Worker:Matthew Littlejohn

Employer:Julian Wade Roper

Solicitors:

Worker:Payne Lawyers

Employer:Minter Ellison

Judgment category classification:                C

Judgment ID number:  005

Number of paragraphs:  70

IN THE WORK HEALTH COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21919346

BETWEEN

ANTHONY GOLZIO-CASA

Worker

AND

DOWNER EDI LTD

Employer

REASONS FOR DECISION

(Delivered 12 January 2021)

JUDGE ELISABETH ARMITAGE

  1. The Worker, Mr Anthony Golzio-Casa, commenced employment as an electrician with the Employer, Downer EDI, on 11 October 2018.

  2. The Worker said that he injured himself on 16 October 2018 at 7:45am. The Worker said that he was lifting his tool bag with his right arm to put it diagonally across his left shoulder when he felt a sudden onset of pain. A subsequent MRI scan suggested a SLAP tear of his superior labrum. The Worker continued his employment undertaking suitable duties and receiving on-site physiotherapy until March 2019 when he was made redundant. [1]

  3. On about 14 November 2018 the Worker made a claim for medical expenses only. The claim for medical expenses was accepted.[2] On about 25 February 2019 the Employer issued a Return to Work Act 1986 (the Act) section 69 Notice of Decision cancelling payments of medical expenses.[3] The Worker responded by commencing these proceedings by Statement of Claim. The Employer filed an Amended Defence and Counterclaim, and the Worker filed a Reply and Defence to the Counterclaim.

  4. At the commencement of the hearing the parties agreed that the Employer was dux litis. The parties provided a “Statement of Agreed Facts and Issues”[4] as follows:

    “The parties agree the following facts:

    1.      The Worker’s Normal Weekly Earnings as at the date of injury were $2,600.00.

    2.      The Worker has had since 25 February 2019 and continues to have an earning capacity of $1,272.00 per week.

    The parties agree that the only issues in dispute between them in these proceedings are:

    1.      whether the Employer’s Notice of Decision, issued 25 February 2019, was valid;

    2.      if the Notice was not valid, whether the Worker had an earning capacity post 25 February 2019 in excess of the agreed $1,272.00 per week and to what extent; and

    3.      costs.”

  5. At the close of the hearing the Employer no longer pressed its argument that its Notice of Decision was valid.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anthony Golzio v Downer Edi and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NTLC 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Work Health Court of the Northern Territory, Judge Elisabeth Armitage has delivered a decision in the case of Anthony Golzio v Downer Edi. The Worker, Mr Anthony Golzio-Casa, commenced employment as an electrician with Downer Edi on 11 October 2018. The Worker alleged he injured himself on 16 October 2018 by lifting his tool bag with his right arm to put it diagonally across his left shoulder. He claimed he experienced a sudden onset of pain. The Worker continued his employment until he was made redundant in March 2019. On 25 February 2019, the Employer issued a Return to Work Act 1986 (the Act) section 69 Notice of Decision cancelling payments of medical expenses. The Worker responded by commencing these proceedings. The Employer filed an Amended Defence and Counterclaim, and the Worker filed a Reply and Defence to the Counterclaim.

At the hearing, the parties agreed that the Employer was dux litis. The parties provided a “Statement of Agreed Facts and Issues” as follows: The parties agreed that the only issues in dispute between them in these proceedings were: (1) whether the Employer’s Notice of Decision, issued 25 February 2019, was valid; (2) if the Notice was not valid, whether the Worker had an earning capacity post 25 February 2019 in excess of the agreed $1,272.00 per week and to what extent; and (3) costs. The Employer no longer pressed its argument that its Notice of Decision was valid. The Employer submitted and closing submissions proceeded on the basis that “the Employer’s counter claim [is] the only live issue.” The Counterclaim pleaded: (10) If the worker sustained injury during the course of his employment on or about 17 October 2018 (which is denied) the injury does not result in or materially contribute to incapacity. (11) In the alternative to the pleading at paragraph 10, if the worker sustained injury in the course of his employment on or about 17 October 2018 (which is denied) and the injury resulted in or materially contributed to incapacity (which is denied) the Worker: (a) has not suffered a loss of earning capacity; (b) alternatively to subparagraph (a) herein, the Worker has suffered a loss of earning capacity to be determined by the Court.

The questions to be resolved were: (i) Did the Employer discharge its onus in proving that the injury did not arise out of or during the course of employment? (ii) Did the Employer discharge its onus in proving that the Worker has not suffered a loss of earning capacity? (iii) If the Worker has suffered a loss of earning capacity, has the Employer discharged its onus in proving what the Worker can earn over and above the otherwise agreed earning capacity of $1,272.00 per week post 25 February 2019?

The Employer did not discharge its onus in proving that the injury did not arise out of or during the course of employment. The Employer failed to discharge its onus that between 25 February and 17 August 2019 the Worker had an earning capacity greater than the agreed earning capacity of $1,272.00 per week. The Employer discharged its onus and satisfied the Court that on and from 17 August 2019 the Worker suffered from no continuing incapacity causative of any loss of earning capacity and had capacity to return to his pre-injury employment or any other position for which he was suitably qualified and experienced.

The Notice of Decision dated 25 February 2019 is set aside. Between 25 February and 17 August 2019 the Worker had an earning capacity of $1,272.00 per week and the Employer is to pay weekly or other compensation in accordance with the Act for this period. On and from 17 August 2019 the Worker suffered no continuing loss of earning capacity arising out of the injury. The Court will hear the parties as to costs and on any consequential orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.