Anters v JM Group Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

PARTIES:

Anters v JM Group Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor
(No. 3) [2023] QIRC 238

Anters, Dawn
(Complainant)

v

JM Group Holdings Pty Ltd
(First Respondent)

and

Sharpe, Virginia
(Second Respondent)

CASE NO:

AD/2021/39

PROCEEDING:

Application for costs

DELIVERED ON:

23 August 2023

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

ORDERS:

McLennan IC

Decided on written submissions without oral hearing.

That, within 28 days, Mr Dawn Anters is to pay the Respondents $43,736.38 as costs incurred in these proceedings.

CATCHWORDS:

LEGISLATION & OTHER INSTRUMENTS:

CASES:

HUMAN RIGHTS – DISCRIMINATION – REFERRAL OF COMPLAINT – APPLICATION FOR COSTS – where substantive application in AD/2021/39 dismissed – where no breach of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 occurred – whether an order for costs ought be made in the interests of justice – where the Industrial Relations Act 2016 provides for consideration in costs orders under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 – where costs are awarded if it is in the interests of justice to do so – where the respondent seeks costs on an indemnity basis – where the respondent seeks to have costs fixed – consideration of the amount of costs ordered

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) s 124,
s 129, s 130, s 166

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) sch 2, s 545,
s 548

Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld) r 70

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 245AE

Anters v JM Group Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor (No. 2) [2023] QIRC 131

Anters v JM Group Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor [2022] QIRC 382

Blackwood v Egan [2014] ICQ 020

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Carlton v Blackwood [2017] ICQ 001

Colgate Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225

Commonwealth v Humphries (1998) 86 FCR 324

Dawson v State of Queensland (Department of the Premier and Cabinet) [2021] QIRC 436

Degiorgio v Dunn (No 2) (2005) 62 NSWLR 284

Gambaro v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2017] ICQ 005

Golding v Sippel and The Laundry Chute Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2021] ICQ 018

Habibi Arehjan v Journeaux [2020] QIRC 41

House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499
Latoudis v Casey (1990) 170 CLR 534

Lemoto v Able Technical Pty Ltd & Ors (2005) 63 NSWLR 300

Northern Territory v Sangare (2019) 265 CLR 164

Willmott v Woolworths Ltd [2014] QCAT 601

Reasons for Decision

  1. Mr Dawn Anters (the Complainant) initiated proceedings against JM Group Holdings Pty Ltd (the First Respondent) and Ms Virginia Sharpe (the Second Respondent), alleging various contraventions of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) (the AD Act) in the pre-work area.

  2. On 12 May 2023, this Commission dismissed that complaint.[1]  Parties were directed they would be heard on the question of costs.

  3. Some months earlier,[2] the Complainant also failed in an application for disclosure.  A decision on costs was reserved at that time.[3]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anters v JM Group Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QIRC 238
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Anters v JM Group Holdings Pty Ltd, the Complainant, Mr Dawn Anters, filed a complaint with the Queensland Human Rights Commission (QHRC) on 31 December 2020, alleging discrimination and victimisation during the course of applying for work. The QHRC's unsuccessful conciliation led to a referral to the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (Commission) on 24 August 2021. The Commission dismissed Mr Anters' substantive complaint on 12 May 2023, leading to an application for costs by the Respondents. The primary legal issue before the Commission was whether an order for costs should be made against Mr Anters in the interests of justice, considering the statutory provisions of the Industrial Relations Act 2016.

The Commission considered the relevant statutory provisions, including Section 2 of Schedule 2 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016, which provides that each party to proceedings brought under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (AD Act) is to bear their own costs. However, Section 4 of Schedule 2 allows for a departure from this practice if "the interests of justice" require an order for costs. The Commission also referred to precedent, particularly Dawson v State of Queensland (Department of the Premier and Cabinet) and Martin J's observations in Blackwood v Egan, which highlight the discretionary nature of awarding costs. The Court concluded that despite Mr Anters' self-representation and relatively small financial outlay, the circumstances justified an order for costs against him. The Respondents' attempts to resolve the matter early and their reasonable settlement offers contrasted with Mr Anters' unreasonable demands and persistence in pursuing a baseless claim.

The Commission found that Mr Anters continued to pursue a frivolous case despite warnings and reasonable offers to settle, leading to the decision that an order for costs was warranted. The Court ordered Mr Anters to pay the Respondents $43,736.38 within 28 days. The Commission noted that this amount was significantly lower than what Mr Anters had claimed, underscoring the unreasonableness of his demands. The decision was made on written submissions without an oral hearing, reflecting the straightforward nature of the costs application following the dismissal of the substantive complaint.

Orders

Orders of the court

McLennan IC

Decided on written submissions without oral hearing.

That, within 28 days, Mr Dawn Anters is to pay the Respondents $43,736.38 as costs incurred in these proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Complainant's position was that each party should bear their own costs.Background The Complainant filed a complaint in the Queensland Human Rights Commission (QHRC) on 31 December 2020, alleging that he had been asked unnecessary questions about the protected attributes of 'race' and 'age' and victimised, in the course of applying for work. An unsuccessful conciliation before the QHRC resulted in this matter being referred to the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (the Commission) on 24 August 2021, pursuant to s 166(1)(a) of the AD Act. A conciliation conference was conducted by the Commission on 12 October 2021; though the parties failed to reach resolution there either. A Mention was held on 12 November 2021. The matter was allocated to me to decide. Mentions were conducted on 13 April 2022 and 4 October 2022. At the Hearing on 10 November 2022, the Complainant alleged the First Respondent made unlawful requests for information in that he was asked:·to provide a copy of his passport or birth certificate before a telephone appointment with the First Respondent's Recruitment Manager, Ms Virginia Sharpe (the Second Respondent); ·his date of birth (an optional question); and·to indicate whether he is an Australian Citizen and to provide proof (e.g., Australian Passport, Full Australian Birth Certificate, Australian Citizenship Certificate or Certificate of Evidence of Citizenship).[4][4] Ibid [6]-[7]. The Complainant stated that he was "highly offended" and "intimidated" by the questions.[5][5] Ibid [8]. In light of those allegations, the Complainant contended:·the Respondents made three unlawful requests for information within the meaning of s 124 of the AD Act; ·that by not providing the Respondents with a copy of his passport when it was not required, the Complainant refused to do an act that would amount to a contravention of the AD Act within the meaning of s 130(1)(a)(i); and·to the detriment of the Complainant, the Respondents refused to consider him for any opportunities while he was unemployed and actively looking for work - this constitutes victimisation under s 129 of the AD Act.[6][6] Ibid [26]-[27]. The Respondents strenuously denied all allegations. In a Decision released on 12 May 2023, [7] I found that:·no breach of s 124 of the AD Act occurred; and·no victimisation occurred, within the meaning of s 130 of the AD Act.[7] Anters v JM Group Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor (No. 2) [2023] QIRC 131. The outcome was that Mr Anters' complaint was dismissed and the parties would be heard on costs. The Commission's Decision was not appealed.Application in Existing Proceedings On 1 September 2022, Mr Anters made application that the Respondents disclose:1) The documents – including briefs, email communications, and the contract with the potential employer – the job advertised by the Respondent…2) The total number of "junior lawyers" recruited by the Respondent since September 2020 Mr Anters then advised that the first category of documentation was no longer sought.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I agree there is no evidence to support Mr Anters' speculation on this rather irrelevant point.Consideration In deciding to award costs against the Applicant in Dawson v State of Queensland (Department of the Premier and Cabinet) ('Dawson'),[71] Vice President O'Connor cited the following:[71] [2021] QIRC 436. Martin J observed in Blackwood v Egan, that an order for costs is a quintessential exercise of discretion and that the principles in House v The King will apply. The principles that govern an award of costs are well established. In Latoudis v Casey, Mason CJ wrote: The Respondents early indicated their intention to seek a costs order against Mr Anters. I am minded to entertain that application for costs in this matter. In making this decision, I note the relevant legislative provisions. Section 2 of sch 2 of the IR Act provides that, for proceedings brought under the AD Act, the default position is for each party to bear its own costs. However, a departure from this practice may be exercised at my discretion, having regard to circumstances where "the interests of justice" would require an order for costs to be made. Section 4 of sch 2 lists circumstances that may inform any decision as to whether an order for costs may be made. Having considered those relevant legislative provisions, together with the circumstances of this case, I will disturb the usual practice so prescribed. I consider that Vice President O'Connor's conclusion that a costs order ought be made in Dawson is most apt in the circumstances of this case also (emphasis added):[23] Notwithstanding the various submissions made by the Respondent and efforts made to explain to the Applicant the situation in which he was placed, the Applicant continued on an erroneous path. Even on the hearing of this application for costs, the Applicant continued to rehearse submissions which had failed in respect of the substantive application. [24] In exercising the discretion, I have considered the fact that the Applicant was self‑represented. However, as the authorities suggest, that alone should not be a basis upon which a successful party should be denied their costs.[25] In Northern Territory v Sangare, the High Court observed: I observe that Mr Anters was warned that costs would be sought against him, that an offer to settle the matter was made quite early in the proceedings by the Respondents, and that the Respondents' offers were reasonable. I have carefully considered the Respondents' attempts to resolve the matter before incurring further legal expenses, and they certainly weigh in favour of an order for costs. That contrasts with Mr Anters' unreasonable and quite inexplicable claim that the matter ought be resolved for $115,100 plus interest.[74] Mr Anters would not have been awarded that much even if he had been successful at hearing.[74] 18 November 2021. As it transpired, Mr Anters was wholly unsuccessful at Hearing and his complaints were each dismissed. While Mr Anters is a lawyer and able to represent himself, his investment in the litigation was seemingly confined to his own time and some travel to attend the Hearing of the matter he had initiated. That is a relatively small outlay for a potential settlement sum, especially given how prolific a litigator Mr Anters had become.