Ansah and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

Ansah and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 323 (4 April 2025)

Applicant/s:  Cameron Ebow ANSAH

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2025/0374

Tribunal:Senior Member N Manetta  

Place:Adelaide

Date:4 April 2025

Decision:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the cancellation of the applicant’s visa be revoked.

.........................[SGND]...................................

Senior Member N Manetta

Catchwords

MIGRATION – mandatory cancellation of a visa – section 501 of Migration Act - applicant a citizen of New Zealand – applicant does not pass character test – whether another reason for cancellation decision to be revoked – applicant guilty of serious violence in company of gang – applicant fulfilling a special role in a single-parent family in relation to a disabled brother – strong family ties to Australia – none in New Zealand – low risk of recidivism – decision set aside

Legislation

Migration Act, 1958 (Cth)

Cases

Frugtniet v ASIC [2019] HCA 16; (2019) 266 CLR 250; (2019) 79 AAR 9

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v LJTZ [2021] FCA 92

Pearson v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FCAFC 203; (2022) 295 FCR 177

Secondary Materials

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Cth), Direction no. 110 — Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (7 June 2024)

Statement of Reasons

  1. This is an application by Mr Cameron Ansah seeking a review of the decision of the respondent’s delegate dated 13 January 2025.[1]  By this decision, the respondent’s delegate declined to cancel the revocation of Mr Ansah’s visa.[2] The cancellation had taken place earlier, and mandatorily so, following Mr Ansah’s conviction of very serious offences involving gang violence.  For his offending, Mr Ansah received an aggregate sentence exceeding 12 months, part of which he was required to serve on a full-time basis in jail. In this circumstance, the respondent was obliged to cancel Mr Ansah’s visa under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act, 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’).  I shall describe the offending in due course.

    [1] The delegate’s decision and reasons were before me at Hearing Book (‘HB’), 146ff.

    [2] A Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa.

  2. Mr Ansah made a timely application for an internal review. The internal-review delegate had two questions to consider under s 501CA(4)(b) of the Act.  The first was whether Mr Ansah passed the so-called ‘character test’ as elaborated under s 501(6) and (7) of the Act.  Given the serious offences to which I have already made reference, Mr Ansah did not pass the test, and the delegate’s conclusion in this regard was clearly correct.[3]  The second question, which arose if the answer to the first question was no, was whether there was ‘another reason’ – that is, a reason other than Mr Ansah passing the character test – warranting the revocation of the cancellation decision. In addressing this second question,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ansah and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 323
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Mr Ansah, a New Zealand citizen who was born in 1999, and the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. Mr Ansah, who migrated to Australia in 2006, was subject to a mandatory cancellation of his visa under section 501 of the Migration Act due to failing the character test. The central issue before the court was whether the decision to cancel Mr Ansah’s visa should be revoked, considering his family ties in Australia, his role in supporting his disabled brother, and the low risk of recidivism.

The court examined the balance between safeguarding the Australian community from serious criminal conduct and the impact of Mr Ansah’s absence on his family, particularly his disabled brother. The court acknowledged the severity of Mr Ansah’s past violent actions, which included an assault occasioning actual bodily harm and participation in a serious affray. However, the court also highlighted Mr Ansah’s significant role in his family, especially in supporting his brother with autism. Furthermore, the court noted the absence of strong family ties for Mr Ansah in New Zealand and the potential difficulties he would face if returned.

After weighing these considerations, the court concluded that the specific circumstances of Mr Ansah’s case warranted a careful application of the relevant Direction. The court found that the protection of the Australian community should generally be given greater weight, but in this instance, the unique family dynamics and low risk of recidivism led to the decision to set aside the visa cancellation. This outcome reflects a nuanced approach to the mandatory cancellation provisions under the Migration Act, considering individual circumstances.

Background

Background to the litigation

I set out below the background facts and then my reasons for this conclusion.BACKGROUND FACTS Mr Ansah is a citizen of New Zealand, who was born there in 1999. He is of Ghanaian heritage, and his parents emigrated to New Zealand a few years before his birth. Mr Ansah has two brothers, Kevin and Dylan. Mr Ansah emigrated with his family from New Zealand to Australia in December 2006 when Mr Ansah was seven years of age. Mr Ansah completed his schooling in Australia and was awarded his high school certificate. I accept the oral evidence given by Mr He, a friend, that Mr Ansar behaved creditably at school, was popular with both teachers and parents, and did not display antisocial tendencies. When Mr Ansah left school, he undertook a number of paid jobs including as an apprentice plumber, waiter, and shoe salesperson. He has also worked more recently packing vegetables and fruit for delivery. This work was done for Mr He.[8][8] HB, 76. So far as Mr Ansah’s personal circumstances are concerned, I note that his life has been attended by difficulties within the family. First, I accept that his father was an abusive and violent alcoholic. He was abusive and violent both towards Mr Ansah’s mother and towards the children. The father eventually left the family home. His mother was required to work two jobs to ensure the family had sufficient resources to meet their basic needs. Secondly, and significantly, Mr Ansah’s younger brother suffers from autism. This has been a challenge for the family. Mr Ansah had a close relationship with the younger brother, and Mr Ansah’s fraternal care and affection have made him something of a father figure to the younger brother. He was involved in the washing and dressing of his brother, for example. That was confirmed in Mr Ansah’s evidence and also in his mother’s, which I accept. The younger brother’s difficulties have now been substantially exacerbated by Mr Ansah’s ongoing absence from the family. The brother is unable to rationalise and accept Mr Ansah’s ongoing absence. The younger brother lashes out frequently according to Ms Ansah’s evidence to me. This version is supported by the documentary evidence before me.[9] [9] See, for example, HB, 36, 40 I now turn to Mr Ansah’s criminal history. His record was before me in evidence.[10] The record is a concerning one, although relatively short. The most significant parts of the record consists of violent assaults. The first offence in the record consists of an assault occasioning actual bodily harm. The offence was found proven on 12 December 2018 in the Downing Centre Local Court. No conviction was recorded, and a conditional release order was made for two years commencing on 12 December 2018 and concluding on 11 December 2020. [10] HB, 175-177. The next conviction is in the same court on 22 November 2019. On that occasion Mr Ansah was found guilty of two offences. First, he was found guilty of failing to appear in accordance with a bail acknowledgment. Mr Ansah pleaded guilty to that charge, and the Court treated the matter as one where the breach was established but no action was required.[11] There was a further conviction of affray involving a serious assault in concert upon an innocent victim. The transcript of the sentencing hearing that was before me records, however, that it was ‘not implied in the Crown case that [Mr Ansah] was in any way cognisant or mindful’ of the fact that Mr Ansah’s co-accused would strike the victim with a bottle of alcohol that was hidden in the co-accused’s jacket.[12] That particular criminal conduct was found not to have been in Mr Ansah’s contemplation.[13] Mr Ansah did, however, run over to join two other people so as to drag the victim to the ground and fall on top of him. The Court observed that apart from that, it was unclear that Mr Ansah did anything.[14] One noteworthy feature of this offending, however, is Mr Ansah’s acting in concert with others. Mr Ansah received a community corrections order for 12 months for his part in the affray. [11] Ex A2, 5.[12] Ibid.[13] Ex A2, 3.[14] Ibid.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the hearing before me, Mr Ehimudiamen appeared for Mr Ansah; Mr Burnham, for the respondent. I am grateful to them both for their measured advocacy and helpful submissions in what was undoubtedly a difficult case.STATEMENT OF CONCLUSION I have decided to set aside the decision under review and to substitute a decision that the cancellation of Mr Ansah’s visa be revoked. I set out below the background facts and then my reasons for this conclusion.BACKGROUND FACTS Mr Ansah is a citizen of New Zealand, who was born there in 1999. He is of Ghanaian heritage, and his parents emigrated to New Zealand a few years before his birth. Mr Ansah has two brothers, Kevin and Dylan. Mr Ansah emigrated with his family from New Zealand to Australia in December 2006 when Mr Ansah was seven years of age. Mr Ansah completed his schooling in Australia and was awarded his high school certificate. I accept the oral evidence given by Mr He, a friend, that Mr Ansar behaved creditably at school, was popular with both teachers and parents, and did not display antisocial tendencies. When Mr Ansah left school, he undertook a number of paid jobs including as an apprentice plumber, waiter, and shoe salesperson. He has also worked more recently packing vegetables and fruit for delivery. This work was done for Mr He.[8][8] HB, 76. So far as Mr Ansah’s personal circumstances are concerned, I note that his life has been attended by difficulties within the family. First, I accept that his father was an abusive and violent alcoholic. He was abusive and violent both towards Mr Ansah’s mother and towards the children. The father eventually left the family home. His mother was required to work two jobs to ensure the family had sufficient resources to meet their basic needs. Secondly, and significantly, Mr Ansah’s younger brother suffers from autism. This has been a challenge for the family. Mr Ansah had a close relationship with the younger brother, and Mr Ansah’s fraternal care and affection have made him something of a father figure to the younger brother. He was involved in the washing and dressing of his brother, for example. That was confirmed in Mr Ansah’s evidence and also in his mother’s, which I accept. The younger brother’s difficulties have now been substantially exacerbated by Mr Ansah’s ongoing absence from the family. The brother is unable to rationalise and accept Mr Ansah’s ongoing absence. The younger brother lashes out frequently according to Ms Ansah’s evidence to me. This version is supported by the documentary evidence before me.[9] [9] See, for example, HB, 36, 40 I now turn to Mr Ansah’s criminal history. His record was before me in evidence.[10] The record is a concerning one, although relatively short. The most significant parts of the record consists of violent assaults. The first offence in the record consists of an assault occasioning actual bodily harm. The offence was found proven on 12 December 2018 in the Downing Centre Local Court. No conviction was recorded, and a conditional release order was made for two years commencing on 12 December 2018 and concluding on 11 December 2020. [10] HB, 175-177.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I accept that he would face some impediments on return to New Zealand. I accept his and his mother’s evidence that he has no connections there and has no real familiarity with the country, having left so young. Although I proceed on the basis that New Zealand has an equivalent social-welfare system and, overall, an equivalent standard of living, I accept that Mr Ansah does need – or would benefit substantially from – secure housing, a secure job, and a family environment. This would allow him to better absorb the therapeutic interventions of which he stands in need. I accept Mr Tsolis’s opinion, expressed in his oral evidence to the Tribunal, that it is difficult to treat psychological conditions of PTSD and depression when a patient is suffering additional stresses caused by financial or family insecurity. That is a factor weighing in Mr Ansah’s favour.Weighing the considerations I turn now to weighing the various considerations. This is not an easy task. I begin with the very serious gang violence in which Mr Ansah participated actively and which could easily have led to a death. This violence is spoken against very strongly in the Direction at various points. Clearly, it is a violence that threatens the Australian community directly and also undermines the conditions of a safe and well-ordered society. I return also to the setting of the violence; namely, a birthday party at a private suburban home. That innocuous setting became the scene of considerable violence, which led to multiple injuries of a very serious kind. Three months later he was involved in further violence, acting in concert with another. I must weigh very carefully the violence that has occurred in this case. I have found the risk of recidivism to be low but not nil, and it is a matter that I must in any event assess ‘cumulatively’ with the very serious consequences that could arise from future acts of group violence. There is, however, the very real impact upon Mr Ansah’s family. I have often said that family members are frequently the victims of the dysfunction brought into the family unit by criminal offending. The mother in this case faces special difficulties in connection with her disabled son, who has been an extreme challenge for her in Mr Ansah’s absence, and that has been true notwithstanding the presence of another son in the household. Mr Ansah has fulfilled a very significant role in his disabled brother’s life. That is an important aspect of the matter. I also weigh that the risk of recidivism is low (although not nil). Whilst I do not wish to simplify the weighing process, since all factors must be weighed, there are two opposing considerations that starkly arise in this case; namely, the understandable emphasis in the Direction on safeguarding the community on the one hand, and, on the other hand, the impact of the applicant’s absence from a family where there are special needs. I have borne in mind that the weighing process must take account of the ‘specific circumstances’ of the case,[35] which are highly unusual here. The weighing process must not simply devolve into a mechanistic application of the Direction, but must, to the contrary, involve its very considered application consideration in the context of specific facts. I bear in mind that the Direction does not prescribe a consequence that universally applies in the case of any particular offending, although, as I have said, it speaks strongly against the offending in this case. I must bear in mind, and I do so, that the Direction says that ‘generally’ the protection of the Australian community is to be given greater weight than the other considerations, and that the safety of the community is the highest priority of the Australian Government.[36] [35] Paragraph 5.1(3) of the Direction.[36] Paragraphs 7(2) and 5.2(2) of the Direction.