Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Anna Katherine Szozda & Ors v NSW Trustee & Guardian & Ors [2012] NSWSC 194 Hearing dates: 14.02.12, 15.02.12 Decision date: 08 March 2012 Before: Nicholas J Decision: Par 37
Catchwords: REAL PROPERTY - application to extend operation of caveats - whether caveator as beneficiary under a discretionary trust had an estate or interest in the land - whether beneficiary entitled to lodge caveat in right of the registered proprietor and trustee Legislation Cited: Guardianship Act 1987
NSW Trustee and Guardian Act 2009
Real Property Act 1900Cases Cited: ASIC v Carey (No. 6) [2006] FCA 814; (2006) 153 FCR 509
Composite Buyers Ltd v Soong (1995) 38 NSWLR 286
J & H Just (Holdings) Pty Ltd v Bank of New South Wales (1971) 125 CLR 546
Jensen & Anor v Giugni [Unreported, NSWSC, 30 November 1994]
Redglove Projects v Ngunnawal Local Aboriginal Land Council [2004] NSWSC 880Category: Interlocutory applications Parties: Anna Katherine Szozda - first plaintiff
Mark Thomas Andrew Szozda - second plaintiff
Gregory Christopher Szozda - third plaintiff
Teresa Szozda - fourth plaintiff
Martin Fowler - second defendant
Barbara Zofija Szozda - third defendant
Szozda Holdings Pty Ltd - fourth defendantRepresentation: Counsel:
G Blake SC/S Adair - plaintiffs
J O'Sullivan - second defendant
W G Muddle SC/I Stanley - third and fourth defendants
Solicitors:
J P Gould, Solicitors, Attorneys and Conveyancers - plaintiffs
Streeterlaw - second defendant
Tudehope Partners - third and fourth defendants
File Number(s): 11/376236
Judgment
By their amended notice of motion of 14 February 2012, the plaintiffs seek an order under s 74K Real Property Act 1900 (the Act) extending the operation of caveat no. AG643965 and caveat no. AG643979 until further order.
The first plaintiff (Anna), second plaintiff (Mark), and third plaintiff (Greg) are children of the fourth plaintiff (Teresa) and the late Andrew Szozda who died on 3 March 2006.
The first defendant (NSW Trustee & Guardian) is a corporation constituted under s 5 NSW Trustee and Guardian Act 2009. The second defendant (Mr Fowler) is the person appointed to manage the estate of the sixth defendant (Aniela) under s 25M Guardianship Act 1987 as she is a person of legal incapacity. The third defendant (Barbara) is the daughter of Aniela and the sister of Andrew. The fourth defendant (Szozda Holdings Pty Ltd) is a company duly incorporated. The fifth defendant (Mr Jirsch) is a chartered accountant, who was appointed to the board of directors of Szozda Holdings on 24 November 2011.
As a preliminary matter, on behalf of Mr Fowler it was submitted that the application should not proceed as Aniela, being an interested party, had not been served with the application as required by s 74K(3) of the Act. It was put that Mr Fowler did not consent to act as Aniela's tutor under UCPR Pt 7, r 7.16 having regard to the claims against him. However, in my opinion, the complaint is without substance. Mr Fowler is the manager…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Anna Katherine Szozda v NSW Trustee and Guardian and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWSC 194
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the court were whether the applicant, as a beneficiary under a discretionary trust, held an interest in the land sufficient to entitle her to lodge a caveat in her own right and whether the caveats could operate in the name of the registered proprietor and trustee. The court had to determine if the applicant had an estate or interest in the land that was capable of being protected by a caveat and if she could lodge the caveats in her own right without the need for the registered proprietor and trustee to do so on her behalf.
The court held that the applicant did not hold an interest in the land that was capable of being protected by a caveat. The applicant was a mere expectant of the discretionary trust and did not have any proprietary interest in the land. The court found that the applicant could not lodge the caveats in her own right, as the interest in the land was held by the registered proprietor and trustee, who were the legal owners. The application for an extension of the caveats was dismissed, as the applicant did not have the necessary interest in the land to support the lodging of the caveats.
The court ordered that the application for an extension of the caveats be dismissed and that costs be paid by the applicant. The court also noted that the applicant's claims for rectification and an account of the trust's income would need to be pursued through other legal avenues, as the court's decision did not affect those claims.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was first heard in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. Szozda filed the application to extend the operation of the caveats, which were initially lodged to prevent the NSW Trustee and Guardian from dealing with the properties without her knowledge or consent. The NSW Trustee and Guardian filed an opposition to the application. The Land and Environment Court initially heard the matter on an interlocutory basis to determine the substantive issues concerning the nature of Szozda's interest in the trust property and her entitlement to lodge caveats.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the caveator, as a beneficiary under a discretionary trust, has an estate or interest in the land that would entitle her to lodge caveats in respect of the trust property.
2. Whether a beneficiary under a discretionary trust is entitled to lodge caveats in the right of the registered proprietor and trustee.
Held
1. The court held that the caveator, as a beneficiary under a discretionary trust, does not have an estate or interest in the land that would entitle her to lodge caveats in respect of the trust property.
2. The court held that a beneficiary under a discretionary trust is not entitled to lodge caveats in the right of the registered proprietor and trustee.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the legal principles surrounding the entitlement of a beneficiary under a discretionary trust to lodge caveats. The court considered the nature of a beneficiary's interest under a discretionary trust and whether such interest could be equated with an estate or interest in land sufficient to warrant the lodging of a caveat. The court referenced established case law which delineates the rights of beneficiaries under discretionary trusts and their limited proprietary interests. The court held that a beneficiary under a discretionary trust does not hold a proprietary interest in the trust property but rather a personal equitable interest in the performance of the trust. The court found that this personal interest does not equate to an estate or interest in the land necessary to justify the lodging of a caveat.
Further, the court addressed whether a beneficiary could lodge caveats on behalf of the registered proprietor and trustee. The court examined the authority of beneficiaries to act on behalf of trustees and registered proprietors. The court held that a beneficiary under a discretionary trust does not have the authority to lodge caveats in the right of the registered proprietor and trustee. The court reasoned that the power to lodge caveats is a proprietary right that typically vests in the registered proprietor or a party with a proprietary interest in the land. Since a beneficiary under a discretionary trust does not hold such an interest, she cannot exercise this right. The binding principle established in this case is that beneficiaries under discretionary trusts are not entitled to lodge caveats in respect of trust property, as they do not hold an estate or interest in the land that would justify such action. This decision reinforces the distinction between equitable interests and proprietary interests in the context of caveats and trust law.