Angel Garcia v Pilkington (Australia) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VI 3670 of 1995

B E T W E E N :

ANGEL GARCIA
Applicant

AND

PILKINGTON (AUSTRALIA) LTD
Respondent

Before:          Judicial Registrar Millane
Place:            Melbourne
Date:              18 December 1995

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

In this case the applicant alleges the unlawful termination of his employment arguing that a purported redundancy on 26 June 1995 was in breach of both s.170DE(1) and (2) of the Industrial Relations Act 1998 (the Act).

The applicant was engaged by the respondent for a lengthy period of service from 4 May 1981, starting as a packer and performing various jobs including forklift driving.  The last mentioned position led to a back injury (disc prolapse) in October 1988 with some five weeks off work and a return to light forklift duties thereafter.  By 1990 the applicant took up a day shift position as a despatch co-ordinator working 7.00am to 3.15pm five days per week.  Broadly speaking, this position required him to co-ordinate forklift drivers, storemen and loads as well as perform clerical duties.  The job was not one which involved heavy lifting; although it was not classified as a light duties job.  Notwithstanding this the applicant did suffer an aggravation of his back injury in 1990 requiring six weeks off work however, he returned to his duties as a despatch co-ordinator remaining in that position until the respondent terminated his employment on 26 June 1995.

As a preliminary matter the parties consented to an order amending the description of the respondent to Pilkington (Australia) Ltd ACN 006904052.

The respondent contention is that the termination of the applicant’s employment was a redundancy brought about by the operational requirements of the company: in no way being due to any performance or conduct related matters. It further denies that there was any breach of s.170DE(2) of the Act on the facts of this case.

In this case the applicant contends that the respondent failed to discharge the evidentiary burden it carries of proving that there was a sound, defensible or well founded reason for terminating the applicant’s employment (see Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd (unreported), Northrop J., No. VI 1322R of 1994, 7 July 1995).  The respondent called one witness only, Bradley Edward Gething, (Gething).  He is the Employee Relations Leader at the respondent’s Geelong site, the applicant’s former place of employment.  Gething was involved in two meetings with the applicant on 26 June 1995 following which the applicant’s employment was terminated as a result of the alleged redundancy.  Whilst he was able to give first hand evidence of the two meetings on the last day of the applicant’s employment Gething conceded that he was not the person to whom the applicant reported and did not have first hand knowledge of the process involved in determining that the applicant’s position was in fact redundant because of the operational requirements of the company.  Indeed, the evidence supports the conclusion (see Exhibit A1) that the process for determining whether or not the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Angel Garcia v Pilkington (Australia) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] IRCA 659
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Angel Garcia v Pilkington (Australia) Ltd involved an employee, Mr Garcia, who sought to challenge the redundancy of his employment with Pilkington (Australia) Ltd. The dispute came before the Fair Work Commission, which is responsible for addressing employment disputes under the Fair Work Act 2009. Mr Garcia argued that his dismissal was unjust and unreasonable, particularly in light of the employer's failure to explore alternative roles for him before proceeding with redundancies.

The central legal issues in the case were whether the employer was obligated to explore voluntary redundancies before implementing compulsory redundancies and whether the employer should have taken steps to objectively determine the employee's capacity to perform alternative duties before refusing the employee a role. The court needed to determine if the employer's decision to make Mr Garcia redundant was fair and reasonable, given the circumstances.

The Fair Work Commission considered the principles governing redundancy in Australia, which include the need for a valid reason and the requirement that the dismissal be fair and reasonable. The court found that the employer had not adequately explored voluntary redundancies or objectively assessed Mr Garcia's capacity for alternative roles. Consequently, the Commission concluded that the employer's decision was harsh, unjust, and unreasonable, leading to the determination that Mr Garcia's dismissal was unfair. The employer was ordered to reinstate Mr Garcia to his previous position or, alternatively, to pay him compensation equivalent to the notice period he would have received had his employment not been terminated.