Angas Securities Ltd & KWS Capital (No 2) P/L v Williams

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Appeal Against a Master's Decision)

ANGAS SECURITIES LTD & KWS CAPITAL (NO 2) P/L v WILLIAMS

[2007] SADC 41

Reasons for Decision of His Honour Judge Chivell

26 April 2007

PROCEDURE

Appeal from a Master; nature of the appeal; summary judgment entered in favour of plaintiffs; claim on contract of guarantee; defendant became guarantor after a debt restructure; whether guarantee supported by consideration; whether defendant has an arguable defence.

Held: appeal by way of rehearing with powers in 6R 292; defendant has an arguable case that guarantee not supported by consideration; appeal allowed; judgment set aside; application for summary judgment dismissed.

Bowman & Bowman v Westpac Banking Corporation (1997) 194 LSJS 115; South Esplanade Developments P/L v Astill & Anor [2007] SADC 24; Leasefin Corporation v Clarke & Ors Judgment No S3660; McKay and Another v National Australia Bank [1998] 1 VR 173, applied.

ANGAS SECURITIES LTD & KWS CAPITAL (NO 2) P/L v WILLIAMS
[2007] SADC 41

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal by Paul Douglas Williams, against an order made by Master Bampton on 18 December 2006 pursuant to Rule 25 of the District Court Rules, whereby summary judgment was entered in favour of Angas Securities Limited and KWS Capital (No 2) Pty Limited, in the sum of $3,200,000 plus enforcement expenses and costs.  I will refer to Angas Securities Limited and KWS Capital as the plaintiffs, and to Mr Williams as the defendant.

  2. The plaintiffs’ claim is based upon a contract of guarantee.  They argue that in a written contract of guarantee and indemnity, dated 25 November 2004, the defendant guaranteed the payment by Port Adelaide Wool Stores (SA) P/L (“PAWS”), a company of which he was the principal director and shareholder, all amounts payable pursuant to a loan agreement entered into on the same day.  The amount guaranteed was capped at $3,200,000, plus interest and expenses.

  3. The loan agreement was extended on 22 March 2005.  The plaintiffs gave a Notice of Demand on 11 May 2006 demanding payment.  It is common ground that the money has not been paid.

    The Decision Appealed From

  4. There was extensive affidavit material before the Master.  Indeed, the hearing was adjourned to enable the defendant to place further material before the Court.

  5. The Master prepared comprehensive written reasons for decision which were posted to the parties on 18 December 2006.

  6. I set out the following sections of her Honour’s conclusions:

    35To grant summary judgment the plaintiffs must demonstrate they are entitled to the relief sought and there is no real question to be tried.

    36The power to order summary judgment must be exercised with exceptional caution and should never be exercised unless it is clear there is no real question to be tried: Fancourt v Mercantile Credits Ltd (1983) 154 CLR 87 at 99.

    37In my view, this is a matter simply where Port Adelaide Wool Stores, the borrower, borrowed $3,200,000 in November 2004 and the defendant guaranteed repayment of that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Angas Securities Ltd & KWS Capital (No 2) P/L v Williams and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SADC 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Angas Securities Limited and KWS Capital (No 2) Pty Limited v Williams was brought by Paul Douglas Williams against an order made by Master Bampton on 18 December 2006, pursuant to Rule 25 of the District Court Rules, that granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs in the sum of $3,200,000 plus enforcement expenses and costs. The plaintiffs' claim was based on a contract of guarantee and indemnity, dated 25 November 2004, whereby the defendant guaranteed the payment by Port Adelaide Wool Stores (SA) Pty Limited, a company of which he was the principal director and shareholder, of all amounts payable pursuant to a loan agreement entered into on the same day. The amount guaranteed was capped at $3,200,000, plus interest and expenses. The defendant argued that there was no consideration for the guarantee, as any consideration had already passed between Angas Securities and Parist, a transaction to which he was not a party. The defendant also argued that the 25 November 2004 agreement which he guaranteed was not executed by Port Adelaide Wool Stores, but by Paul Douglas Williams as the authorised representative of Parist Holdings Pty Ltd, and therefore was invalid. The court held that the appeal was in the nature of a rehearing, with the powers set out in Rule 6R 292. The court held that the defendant had an arguable case that the guarantee executed on 25 November 2004 was not supported by consideration and was therefore unenforceable. The court set aside the Master's orders made on 18 December 2006, and dismissed the plaintiffs' application for summary judgment. The court will hear counsel as to costs.