Andreola v Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Andreola v Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic) [2002] FCA 728

MIGRATION - criminal justice visa - criminal justice stay certificate granted by authorised State official – granted on “subsistence undertaking” given on behalf of State prosecuting authority – difference between terms of undertaking and terms of certificate – visa granted on certificate – whether State entitled to refuse to pay expenses of visa holder – whether visa holder obliged to satisfy State authority that he had no means – whether Court has jurisdiction to deal with application

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 147, 148, 150, 155, 157, 158, 160, 161, 474(3)(g), 475, 476

Goldie v Commonwealth of Australia [2002] FCA 261 referred to

DANIEL M ANDREOLA v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS AND DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTION FOR THE STATE OF VICTORIA
V 228 of 2002

GRAY J
29 MAY 2002
MELBOURNE

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 228 of 2002

BETWEEN:

DANIEL M ANDREOLA
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
FIRST RESPONDENT

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTION FOR THE STATE OF VICTORIA
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

GRAY J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 MAY 2002

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The application be dismissed.

2.        There be no order as to the costs of the proceeding.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 228 of 2002

BETWEEN:

DANIEL M ANDREOLA
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
FIRST RESPONDENT

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTION FOR THE STATE OF VICTORIA
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

GRAY J

DATE:

29 MAY 2002

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Nature and history of the proceeding

  1. By an application filed on 22 April 2002, the applicant claimed against the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (“the Minister”) and the Director of Public Prosecutions for the State of Victoria orders in the following terms:

    “1.The Department of Immigration is in breech [sic] of the Commonwealth Migration Act 1958 under Division 4 Part 2.

    2.The Director of Public Prosecution [sic] has breeched [sic] the Commonwealth Migration Act 1958 under Division 4 Part 2, subdivisions B & C of the above mentioned Act.”

  2. The affidavit that accompanied the application indicated that the concern of the applicant was the payment of expenses to him whilst he is in Australia for the purposes of the administration of the criminal justice system.  That concern has been confirmed by the manner in which the proceeding has been argued today.  The matter came on as a matter of urgency before another judge of the Court on 26 April 2002.  On that date, the learned judge made orders in the following terms:

    “1.      The application, insofar as it was brought against the first respondent,
    be dismissed.


    2.        There be no order as to the costs payable as between the applicant and
    the first respondent.


    3.The further hearing of the application be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Andreola v Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 728
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Andreola v Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic), the applicant, a non-citizen, sought to enforce an undertaking provided by the Director of Public Prosecutions for Victoria. The applicant was in Australia on a visa when charged with offences under the law of Victoria. He was granted bail and subsequently a criminal justice stay visa was issued, allowing him to remain in Australia for the administration of criminal justice. The Director of Public Prosecutions provided an undertaking to support the applicant if certain conditions were met, including the applicant having no independent means of support.

The legal issues before the court included whether the Director of Public Prosecutions was required to provide the applicant with subsistence support and if the applicant was eligible for such support. The court needed to determine whether the undertaking was legally binding and if the applicant's claims for support were justified. The court also had to consider whether the application was valid and whether costs should be awarded.

The court found that the Director of Public Prosecutions was not required to provide the applicant with subsistence support as there was no legal obligation to do so. The court determined that the applicant had independent means of support, thus disqualifying him from receiving any assistance under the undertaking. Additionally, the court concluded that the application was invalid as there was no valid application before it. Consequently, the court dismissed the application and made no order regarding the costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. There be no order as to the costs of the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 161 provides for the effect of criminal justice visas. A criminal justice stay visa is permission for a non-citizen to remain in Australia while it is in effect. It has certain other effects that are not relevant to the present circumstances.The facts In December 1999, the applicant, who is apparently a non-citizen, was present in Australia as the holder of a visa. He was then charged with certain offences pursuant to the law of Victoria. He was granted bail pending his trial. Eventually, after his protests that nothing had been done, some action was taken to obtain for him a criminal justice stay visa. The first step that was taken was that the Acting Solicitor for Public Prosecutions in the Office of Public Prosecutions for Victoria gave a written undertaking, dated 17 April 2000, in the following terms:“MIGRATION ACT 1958 SECTION 148(c)UNDERTAKINGI, STEPHEN CARISBROOK, Acting Solicitor for Public Prosecutions for the State of Victoria, DO HEREBY UNDERTAKE that if a Criminal Justice Stay Visa is issued to DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA for the purposes of the administration of criminal justice in relation to an offence against the law of Victoria AND if the said DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA is not detained in custody AND if the said DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA has no independent means of support, the Office of Public Prosecutions for the State of Victoria will provide cash or services to the said DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA sufficient to provide basic needs including food, shelter and transport, until the cancellation of the said Criminal Justice Stay Visa.” I note that s 148(c) of the Migration Act, which I have quoted above, says nothing about the giving of such an undertaking. It does appear that a manual, issued by the Attorney-General’s Department of the Commonwealth at or prior to the relevant time, contains material suggesting that something called a “subsistence undertaking” was required pursuant to s 148(c), and that it should set out the following provision of a subsistence level of support if the non-citizen is not kept in detention:“This means payment of cash or services to the non-citizen of a level sufficient to provide basic needs, including food, shelter and transport, (if required).” On the same day on which the undertaking was given, the then Director of Public Prosecutions for the State of Victoria granted what was described in its title as a State Criminal Justice Stay Certificate pursuant to s 148 of the Migration Act. The certificate is in the following terms:“WHEREAS DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA a citizen of United States of America and Israel, born on 30 December 1945 is an unlawful non-citizen for the purposes of the Migration Act 1958; AND WHEREAS DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA is to be, or is likely to be, removed or deported from Australia; AND WHEREAS I consider that DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA should remain in Australia temporarily for the purposes of the administration of criminal justice in relation to an offence against a law of Victoria;AND WHEREAS I consider that satisfactory arrangements have been made to make sure that the costs of keeping DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA in Australia will be met by the Office of Public Prosecutions for the State of Victoria;NOW THEREFORE I, GEOFFREY RAYMOND FLATMAN, a person duly appointed by the Commonwealth Attorney-General as an authorised official for Victoria for the purposes of Division 4 of Part 2 of the Migration Act, hereby certify, pursuant to s.148 of that Act, the stay of the removal or deportation of DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA from Australia is required for the administration of criminal justice by Victoria.”The document is dated 17 April 2000.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
I should say also that counsel for the second respondent sought to invite the exercise of the Court’s discretion to dismiss the application, on the basis that the applicant had failed to comply with par 4 of the order made on 26 April 2002. This application was made in the context of a notice of motion, in which the applicant sought to enlarge the time fixed by that order. If there had been an application before the Court within its jurisdiction, I should not have been disposed to dismiss it in the exercise of my discretion for non-compliance with that order. Non-compliance with an order can be excused and the time laid down in an order can be extended. I have not considered whether it would have been appropriate to do those things in the context of the present case.Conclusion Since there is no valid application before the Court, all of the applicant’s motions in relation to the proceeding must also be dismissed. They will of course include the motion to reinstate or join again the Minister who was named as the first respondent in the original application.Costs I note that counsel for the second respondent has indicated that the second respondent does not seek costs in the event that the proceeding is dismissed. Counsel for the Minister has asked for an order for the costs of the notice of motion filed on 10 May, insofar as they affect the Minister. It appears that that notice of motion was sent to the Minister’s department, by facsimile. Whether this was sufficient service on the Minister is a matter of some doubt. In any event I consider that the Minister’s appearance by counsel was a matter of over-abundant caution. It was unnecessary when the Minister was not a party. If an order had been made, adding the Minister as a party, then directions as to the service of process on the Minister would have been given and the Minister would have had an opportunity to apply to strike out the proceeding so far as it concerned him. In the circumstances, I do not consider it to be appropriate to make an order for the Minister’s costs on appearance on the motion. The order of the Court, then, will be:1. The application be dismissed.2. There be no order as to the costs of the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J

On the same day on which the undertaking was given, the then Director of Public Prosecutions for the State of Victoria granted what was described in its title as a State Criminal Justice Stay Certificate pursuant to s 148 of the Migration Act. The certificate is in the following terms:“WHEREAS DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA a citizen of United States of America and Israel, born on 30 December 1945 is an unlawful non-citizen for the purposes of the Migration Act 1958; AND WHEREAS DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA is to be, or is likely to be, removed or deported from Australia; AND WHEREAS I consider that DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA should remain in Australia temporarily for the purposes of the administration of criminal justice in relation to an offence against a law of Victoria;AND WHEREAS I consider that satisfactory arrangements have been made to make sure that the costs of keeping DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA in Australia will be met by the Office of Public Prosecutions for the State of Victoria;NOW THEREFORE I, GEOFFREY RAYMOND FLATMAN, a person duly appointed by the Commonwealth Attorney-General as an authorised official for Victoria for the purposes of Division 4 of Part 2 of the Migration Act, hereby certify, pursuant to s.148 of that Act, the stay of the removal or deportation of DANIEL MICHAEL ANDREOLA from Australia is required for the administration of criminal justice by Victoria.”The document is dated 17 April 2000. The applicant was tried in the County Court on a number of charges of dishonestly obtaining financial advantage, or attempting to do so, and was convicted. His sentence included a term of imprisonment. He has apparently served the non-parole period of that sentence and is currently on parole. He has an appeal pending in the Court of Appeal in Victoria against his conviction. That appeal is due to be heard next Monday, 3 June 2002. The Office of Public Prosecutions has so far failed to make any payment by way of expenses to the applicant. The applicant wrote a letter to the Office of Public Prosecutions on 15 April 2002, in which he claimed to set out the expenses for which he required reimbursement. Among his claims was a claim for $175 per day for rent, which he said resulted from a long-term rental agreement into which he had entered. He also claimed $100 per week for food, and for miscellaneous expenses about $50 per week. He sought reimbursement of hospital expenses incurred in the year 2000 in the sum of $8,000, and ongoing support to the tune of $6,000 per month. Mr Bruce Gardner in the Office of Public Prosecutions communicated with the applicant by e-mail and requested from him information. In that e-mail Mr Gardner said:“4. … As stated above, the OPP has information that you presently have independent means of support. Accordingly, you are not eligible at present for any assistance pursuant to the subsistence undertaking. If and when you cease to have independent means of support and you are in a position to verify that fact, you should prepare a statutory declaration setting out the whole of your financial circumstances, including all assets and income available to you and all financial and other assistance which you are receiving or might receive from any third party.5. This Office has a duty to verify all claims made in any such application and accordingly may request the assistance of the police in the verification of any such claims.6. In the event of any subsistence payments being provided, such payments would be limited in quantum to the equivalent of the basic social security entitlements to which you would have access if you were a citizen of this country.”The effect of the undertaking and the certificate