Andreas Klaus and Telstra Corporation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

[2014] AATA 200

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/5284

Re

Andreas Klaus

APPLICANT

And

Telstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member
Date 9 April 2014
Place Sydney

The decision under review is set aside and in substitution the Tribunal decides that Telstra is liable to pay compensation pursuant to s 16 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in relation to a right knee arthroscopic chondroplasty and removal of loose bodies performed by Dr Sorrenti on 27 June 2012.

..................[sgd]............................................

Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – claim for cost of medical treatment – whether treatment in respect of accepted workplace injury – decision set aside

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4, 16

CASES

Australian Postal Corporation v Burch (1998) 85 FCR 264

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

9 April 2014

BACKGROUND

  1. This is an application for review of a decision that Telstra Corporation Limited (Telstra) is not liable to pay for the cost of medical treatment obtained by Mr Andreas Klaus, which he contends relates to an accepted workplace injury he sustained in 1999.

  2. Mr Klaus has worked at Telstra, and its predecessor, since 1983 as a linesman and later as a communications technician. Mr Klaus sustained an injury to his right knee in 1994 while skiing and consulted a doctor at that time. He sustained a second injury, again while skiing, in July 1995 and had surgery in 1996 as a result of those injuries.

  3. Mr Klaus was injured at work in October 1999 while installing telecommunications cables in a new estate. This is not in dispute. He had surgery soon after the injury and the cost of his medical treatment was paid by Telstra. He was also paid for his time off work and in 2005 was paid a lump sum for permanent impairment.

  4. Mr Klaus continued working and skiing, apparently without incident, until about June 2012. After complaining of pain and restriction in his right knee, Mr Klaus had a further operation in June 2012 and made a workers’ compensation claim for the cost of the surgery. Liability was declined in July 2012. Mr Klaus requested reconsideration of this determination and by letter dated 23 October 2012, he was advised that the original decision was affirmed. This decision is disputed by Mr Klaus and he seeks an order that the reconsideration decision be set aside and substituted with a decision that Telstra is liable to pay for his medical treatment.

  5. This review relates to the rights and obligations created under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988 (Cth) (the Act). Under Part VIII of the Act, certain corporations may be granted a licence to self-insure and/or manage their workers’ compensation liabilities within the framework established by the Commonwealth under the Act rather than the various State workers’ compensation schemes. Telstra holds such a licence and, as such, its liability for workers’ compensation is covered by the Act.

  6. To establish…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Andreas Klaus and Telstra Corporation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 200
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Andreas Klaus was a Telstra employee who suffered a workplace injury on 19 October 1999. He sought compensation for this injury and for medical treatment in relation to this injury. Telstra denied that the arthroscopic chondroplasty and removal of loose bodies in Mr Klaus’ right knee on 27 June 2012 was treatment in relation to the workplace injury. The dispute came before the Workers’ Compensation Regulator, Queensland (the Tribunal) which had to decide whether the 2012 surgery was a medical treatment in relation to the 1999 workplace injury.

The Tribunal needed to determine the nature and extent of the 1999 workplace injury and whether this injury resulted in the need for the 2012 surgery. The Tribunal heard evidence from two medical experts, Dr Sorrenti and Dr Maxwell, who disagreed on the origin of the need for the 2012 surgery. The Tribunal needed to determine whose evidence was to be preferred. The Tribunal also needed to decide whether there was a twisting injury in October 1999 and whether this injury was significant enough to require anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.

The Tribunal accepted that Mr Klaus had suffered a significant twisting injury in October 1999. However, the Tribunal preferred the opinion of Dr Maxwell who found that the need for surgery in June 2012 resulted from problems arising from the non-work related skiing injury and the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in 1999. The Tribunal found that the need for the 2012 surgery was not in relation to the workplace injury. The Tribunal also found that Telstra was not liable for the cost of the surgery.

The Tribunal dismissed Mr Klaus’ claim. It found that Telstra was not liable for the cost of the surgery in June 2012.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The critical issue for determination was whether the arthroscopic chondroplasty and removal of loose bodies in Mr Klaus’ right knee on 27 June 2012 was a medical treatment “in relation to” the workplace injury in October 1999.THE EVIDENCE Mr Klaus suffered an injury to his right elbow and knee as a result of a motor vehicle accident in 1984. In January 1985, Dr John Bannister performed an arthroscopy of Mr Klaus’ right knee, which confirmed the presence of “retro patellar chondromalacia”. There was no evidence Mr Klaus sought further treatment for his right knee until July 1994, when he sustained an injury while skiing. Mr Klaus consulted his general practitioner, Dr David Chan, and orthopaedic surgeon, Dr John Harrison, about this injury in July 1994. Dr Harrison reported that Mr Klaus had twisted and fallen sustaining an injury to his right knee from an 8 foot drop. He further reported “antero-lateral rotatory instability” in the right knee but noted that Mr Klaus had opted for conservative care, involving exercise and physiotherapy. Mr Klaus again injured his right knee while skiing in July 1995 and consulted Dr Jay Dave, orthopaedic surgeon, in March 1996. Dr Dave performed an arthroscopy on Mr Klaus’ right knee on 23 May 1996 and recorded as follows:There was a large bucket handle tear of the posterior horn of the medial meniscus which was removed arthroscopically. The fragment had subluxed into the medial gutter. The cruciate ligament was scarred and there was an empty notch. The scarred portion of the cruciate ligament was debrided. There was grade (1-2) changes over the medial femoral condyle and grade (1-2) changes of the retropatella surface. The lateral compartment was relatively well preserved showing no evidence of degenerative changes. The lateral meniscus was intact. There was no record of further complaint or treatment by Mr Klaus in respect of this injury until he sustained the workplace injury on 19 October 1999. There are a number of different accounts recorded describing the circumstances leading to the injury and the symptoms experienced by Mr Klaus at the time. Telstra contends the injury was not as serious as Mr Klaus is now seeking to allege. He is exaggerating the nature and extent of the incident to support the claim he sustained a serious physical injury, the effects of which continued until 2012 and resulted in the surgery of June 2012. Counsel for Mr Klaus submitted that there is no material inconsistency between these accounts. The preponderance of the evidence is to the effect Mr Klaus sustained a serious frank injury during the course of his employment. Given this controversy, it is therefore relevant to examine these various accounts in some detail. According to a Health and Safety Incident Notification lodged by Mr Klaus’ supervisor on the day of the incident, it was recorded as follows:While Andy was kneeling on his knee pad forming cable in a P5 pit which was situated in a garden, the knee pad rolled on the garden edging causing an audible click in his right knee. Andy initially complained of stiffness in his right knee.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Sorrenti and Dr Maxwell gave concurrent evidence. Both adhered to the views expressed in their written reports but agreed that evidence of a twisting injury in October 1999 would be significant. Dr Maxwell said there was “no documented history of a twisting injury” and, in his view, any loose bodies in Mr Klaus’ right knee could only be secondary to the anterior cruciate ligament repair, which was not work related. He doubted there would have been loose bodies resulting from the October 1999 injury. He also queried the need for the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in December 1999. In Dr Maxwell’s view, it was more likely that the June 2012 surgery addressed problems arising from the prior non-work related skiing injury than any injury sustained on 19 October 1999. Dr Sorrenti disagreed. According to Dr Sorrenti, if there was a twisting injury, an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction was appropriate and reasonable. He remained of the view that the need for surgery in June 2012 resulted from the trauma and surgery in 1999.CONSIDERATION AND FINDINGS The critical issue in the case is the dispute about the nature and extent of the injury sustained by Mr Klaus on 19 October 1999. The question of whether this injury was a disease or a physical injury in the ordinary sense was ultimately not the key controversy. It is common ground Mr Klause ruptured his anterior cruciate ligament in 1995 as a result of a skiing injury but Dr Dave did not perform a reconstruction to repair this injury when he operated in May 1996. According to Dr Sorrenti, the injury was asymptomatic until Mr Klaus’ workplace injury installing telecommunications cable. It was submitted, and I accept based on the available material (which includes medical records summonsed from Mr Klaus’ general practitioner), that there is no evidence Mr Klaus experienced problems with his right knee for several years after the 1996 arthroscopy. Counsel for Telstra submitted that Mr Klaus’ recent evidence about the incident is inconsistent with contemporaneous notes and records at the time of the injury. His evidence that he fell forward, twisted his knee and felt a snap should not be accepted. Dr Sorrenti’s opinion is based on this history and the Tribunal should therefore prefer the opinion of Dr Maxwell. It could not be concluded the surgery was in relation to the October 1999 injury. There were other factors motivating the need for the surgery in June 2012 and these factors were not work related. Dr Sorrenti conceded that damage to the lateral compartment of Mr Klaus’ knee was significant and this was a new issue. To the extent surgery was required to resolve problems that had arisen from the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, these were also not work related. While this procedure had been performed in 1999 it related to an earlier skiing accident. It was irrelevant that Telstra had originally accepted liability for the injury and, to the extent there was inconsistency between the medical experts, Dr Maxwell’s evidence should be preferred.