Andrea Davies and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

[2014] AATA 578  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2013/1188

Re

Andrea Davies

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date 20 August 2014
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.......[sgd].................................................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – injury or disease – liability for right forearm strain accepted in 2009 – liability for bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome denied in October 2010 – repetitive movement claimed during mail sorting – complex medical history arising from craniopharyngioma of pituitary gland – cause of carpal tunnel syndrome multifactorial – work contribution material but not significant – decision affirmed

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 sections 5A, 5B and 14

Cases

Australian Postal Corporation v Bessey [2001] FCA 266
Comcare v Etheridge (2006) 149 FCR 522
Commonwealth v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369
Kennedy Cleaning Services v Petkoska [2000] 200 CLR 286
Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation (1998) 27 AAR 40

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

20 August 2014

  1. On 23 September 2009 the Australian Postal Corporation (Australia Post) accepted liability for compensation for a right forearm strain suffered by the applicant, Mrs Davies.  While the diagnosis of this particular condition fluctuated over the following 11 months, a subsequent diagnosis of probable bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) was made in August 2010.  Australia Post denied liability for this condition in February 2011.  Mrs Davies underwent surgical procedures on both wrists at her own expense in late 2010 and early 2011. 

  2. In October 2012 Mrs Davies lodged an incident report and a certificate of physical capacity following a recurrence of her bilateral CTS symptoms.  Mrs Davies lodged a claim for compensation dated 4 October 2012.  A claims manager of Australia Post rejected liability on 30 October 2012. Mrs Davies requested a reconsideration. A delegate of the respondent affirmed the earlier decision on17 January 2013, denying liability for recurrent probable carpal tunnel syndrome bilaterally. Mrs Davies sought a review of that decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal on 8 March 2013. 

  3. At the hearing Mrs Davies was represented by Ms Frederico of counsel, instructed by Ms Jacinta Lewin of Maurice Blackburn solicitors. Mr Ben Dube of counsel appeared for Australia Post and was instructed by Mr Nam Nguyen of Sparke Helmore solicitors. The Tribunal was provided with the documents lodged pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T-documents) which have been assigned the Exhibit number of R1.  Mrs Davies, Dr Leslie Sedal and Mr Murray Stapleton gave evidence before the Tribunal.  Both parties tendered further reports as follows:

    For the applicant:

    ·the applicant’s statement of 4 May 2014 – Exhibit A1

    ·the report of Dr Sedal dated 27 August 2013 – Exhibit A2

    ·the report of Dr Sedal dated 29 October 2013 – Exhibit A3

    ·the clinical records of the Willandra Medical Clinic – Exhibit A4

    and for the respondent:

    ·the report of Mr Murray Stapleton dated 20 March 2014 – Exhibit R2

    ·the report of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Andrea Davies and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 578
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Andrea Davies and Australian Postal Corporation, the applicant sought a reconsideration of the respondent's denial of her claim for compensation for bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). The case was heard before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The primary legal issues were whether Mrs Davies' bilateral CTS was an ailment, thus meeting the definition of a disease under section 5B(1)(b) of the relevant Act, and whether there was a significant contribution by her employment to the aggravation of the disease. The Tribunal needed to determine if Mrs Davies' condition was work-aggravated, considering the multifactorial nature of CTS and the various predisposing factors, including her medical history and work duties.

The Tribunal concluded that Mrs Davies' bilateral CTS due to median nerve compression in the carpal tunnel was indeed an ailment and thus a disease under the Act. It was noted that there was a requirement for any contribution to the aggravation of the disease by her employment to be of a significant degree. The Tribunal found that the temporal relationship between the onset of her CTS symptoms and her return to work on restricted duties indicated that her employment did contribute to the development of these symptoms. Specifically, her duties that limited her right-hand use were followed by the manifestation of symptoms in her left hand, and further symptoms in her right hand after her return to restricted duties.

Based on this evidence, the Tribunal determined that there was a significant contribution by Mrs Davies' employment to the aggravation of her bilateral CTS. The Tribunal's findings supported Mrs Davies' claim for compensation for the work-aggravated component of her condition. The Tribunal's decision provided clarity on the multifactorial nature of CTS and the specific circumstances under which employment can significantly contribute to the aggravation of a disease.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing Mrs Davies was represented by Ms Frederico of counsel, instructed by Ms Jacinta Lewin of Maurice Blackburn solicitors. Mr Ben Dube of counsel appeared for Australia Post and was instructed by Mr Nam Nguyen of Sparke Helmore solicitors. The Tribunal was provided with the documents lodged pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T-documents) which have been assigned the Exhibit number of R1. Mrs Davies, Dr Leslie Sedal and Mr Murray Stapleton gave evidence before the Tribunal. Both parties tendered further reports as follows: For the applicant:·the applicant’s statement of 4 May 2014 – Exhibit A1·the report of Dr Sedal dated 27 August 2013 – Exhibit A2·the report of Dr Sedal dated 29 October 2013 – Exhibit A3·the clinical records of the Willandra Medical Clinic – Exhibit A4and for the respondent:·the report of Mr Murray Stapleton dated 20 March 2014 – Exhibit R2·the report of Dr Kenneth Muirden dated 24 September 2013 – Exhibit R3·Australia Post Occupational Health and Safety Section’s publication titled ALL IN A DAY’S WORK – DELIVERY – Exhibit R4 ·clinical records of Mrs Melissa Radcliffe relating to Mrs Davies – Exhibit R5·the report of Mr Timothy Bennett, plastic surgeon dated 21 January 2010 – Exhibit R6·the report of Mr Timothy Bennett, dated 9 February 2010 – Exhibit R7·the clinical records of Dr Lyndsey Kabat – Exhibit R8·an article entitled: Personal and workplace psychosocial risk factors for carpal tunnel syndrome: a pooled study cohort – Harris-Adamson, C, Eisen, EA, Dale AM, et al. Occup Environ Med 2013; 70: 529-537 (the medical article on CTS) – Exhibit R9BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Mrs Davies started working at Australia Post in 1996 on a part-time basis. She obtained this employment as part of a disability service placement. Initially, she worked as an administrative officer at the Elwood post office and then in a mail sorting position at St Kilda, working 25 hours per week. She later transferred to Heidelberg West and has been there ever since. Mrs Davies cannot remember the time spent at each of these facilities. In 1992 Mrs Davies underwent resection of a benign tumour of the pituitary gland, known as a craniopharyngioma, after presenting with visual symptoms and signs of hydrocephalus. Prior to this presentation, she had given birth to her only child who is now an independent married adult. Mrs Davies’ cranial surgery was presumably a transphenoidal resection, although we have no information regarding this procedure. As a result of the resection of the pituitary tumour, Mrs Davies has since suffered from a hypo‑pituitary state and has required replacement hormonal therapy in order to attain normal adrenal, thyroid, and female hormonal levels and serum osmolality. She has proven hypothyroidism and hypo-adrenocortical function. She has also been in a menopausal state since her surgery and has diabetes insipidus. In addition, she lacks the normal satiety mechanisms controlled by the hypothalamus so that she overeats and has suffered from morbid obesity. While Mrs Davies has not been diagnosed with diabetes mellitus, she does have slightly raised blood glucose levels which may reflect a pre-diabetic state.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 8 January 2013 Mrs Davies lodged a request for reconsideration of the decision of 30 October 2012. She had not challenged any of the denials of liability previously. A reconsideration delegate subsequently affirmed the earlier determination. EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL Mrs Davies’ evidence to the Tribunal has been summarised under BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION. It is to be noted that she gave evidence under oath that she was seeing her endocrinologist at regular six monthly intervals and that all her monitoring blood tests had been normal. She also stated that she took all her medications as prescribed. Dr Leslie Sedal, Consultant Neurologist Dr Sedal provided two reports dated 27 August 2013 and 29 October 2013. Based on the history he obtained from Mrs Davies and the documentation with which he was provided, Dr Sedal considered the causation of Mrs Davies’ bilateral CTS to be very complex in that there were probably multiple contributing factors. In relation to the resection of Mrs Davies’ pituitary tumour in 1992, he considered that she had become prone to hypothyroidism despite replacement therapy, to a disturbance of growth hormone and to the development of morbid obesity because of hydrocephalic changes associated with the pituitary lesion. Dr Sedal regarded Mrs Davies as being at a high risk of developing CTS since 1992. Dr Sedal also considered that had there been a contribution related to sex hormones deficiency, the CTS would have become manifest many years earlier. He considered this given that Mrs Davies had undergone early menopause as a result of her surgery and menopause is a known contributory factor in the development of CTS. Dr Sedal concluded that while there were multiple predisposing factors in Mrs Davies’ case, work had also contributed and had been a major contributing factor. He understood that most of Mrs Davies’ work involved a constant flicking action of both her wrists. Dr Sedal considered Mrs Davies’ work was the triggering factor to her development of symptoms. He advised review by an endocrinologist, recommending Professor Richard O’Brien. He also advised Mrs Davies to contact her neurosurgeon, Mr Michael Pullar, who had performed the tumour resection in 1992, to obtain an opinion regarding the details of the pituitary tumour and the surgical and endocrine complications. Dr Sedal’s report in October 2013 related to his interpretation of the nerve conduction studies performed in 2009, 2010 and 2012. He advised that the initial study of 5 November 2009 demonstrated a mild CTS. However, by 25 August 2010 there had been a significant deterioration in the right hand from a mild to moderate degree. In the third study of 17 October 2012, conducted after the carpal tunnel release procedures on both wrists, he reported that there had been only minor improvement on the left side and minimal improvement on the right. In his evidence before the Tribunal, Dr Sedal maintained his opinion and in particular that a hypothyroid state was associated with an increased risk in developing CTS. The Tribunal informed him that Mrs Davies gave evidence that the blood tests and endocrinology reviews had been conducted six-monthly and her biochemical tests were all within normal limits. Dr Sedal said that this information made it far less likely that the hormonal consequences of her pituitary resection had played a role in the development of her CTS on both wrists.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the correct diagnosis of Mrs Davies' condition, and was it caused by her employment with Australia Post?
2. Does the condition meet the definition of a disease under s 5B(1)(b) of the relevant Act?
3. Was there a significant contribution by Mrs Davies' employment to the aggravation of her bilateral CTS?

Held
1. The court concluded that the correct diagnosis of Mrs Davies' condition is bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) of both wrists. This diagnosis is distinct from the original diagnosis of right forearm strain for which liability was accepted.
2. The court determined that Mrs Davies' bilateral CTS due to median nerve compression in the carpal tunnel qualifies as an ailment, thus meeting the definition of a disease under s 5B(1)(b) of the relevant Act. Consequently, any contribution to the aggravation of the disease by her employment must be significant.
3. The court found that Mrs Davies' employment with Australia Post made a significant contribution to the aggravation of her bilateral CTS.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Counsel for both parties acknowledged that CTS was multifactorial in aetiology. TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATIONSDIAGNOSIS The Tribunal agrees that the correct diagnosis of Mrs Davies’ condition is CTS of both wrists. This however, is not the original diagnosis made in relation to her right forearm and for which liability was accepted on 23 September 2009 and continued until 3 February 2011. The onset of Mrs Davies’ symptoms consistent with CTS was in May 2010. The Tribunal notes that a syndrome is by definition a collection of symptoms. Nerve conduction studies performed on 5 November 2009 as part of the investigation of her right forearm strain were aimed at determining conduction in the radial nerve as a possible diagnosis of neuropraxia of this nerve had been raised. These nerve conduction studies were performed only on the right upper limb. The only abnormality detected was a mild latency of conduction in the medial nerve compatible with mild right median nerve compression in the carpal tunnel. The only medical expert to see Mrs Davies at that time was Mr Bennett. Mr Bennett did not consider CTS to be the appropriate diagnosis for her then symptoms. Mrs Davies’ symptoms of pain and tingling of the fingers was first manifest in the left hand after she had returned to restricted work duties which limited her to the use of her left hand. Some months later she developed symptoms in her right hand. Based on the medical reports, the Tribunal differentiates between the original injury of right forearm strain and the development some nine months later of symptoms of CTS. The nerve conduction study performed on the right forearm in November 2009 indicates that mild carpal tunnel median nerve compression was pre-existing and asymptomatic at that time.IS THE CONDITION AN INJURY OR A DISEASE? The Tribunal finds that Mrs Davies’ bilateral CTS due to median nerve compression in the carpal tunnel is an ailment, thus meeting the definition of a disease under s 5B(1)(b) of the Act. As a result, there is a requirement that any contribution to the aggravation of the disease by the employee’s employment must be of a significant degree. The temporal relationship between Mrs Davies’ development of the CTS symptoms and her return to work on restricted duties indicates that these work duties did contribute to the development of symptoms in the previously asymptomatic condition. Mrs Davies was placed on restricted duties from 29 September 2009 until 23 June 2010, which consisted of normal working hours but with minimal use of her right hand. In June 2010 she complained of left forearm pain and Dr Tunaley restricted her use of both hands. Mrs Davies was off work from 25 August 2010 to 20 November 2010 and then again from 25 January 2011 to 8 March 2011. WAS THERE A SIGNIFICANT CONTRIBUTION BY EMPLOYMENT? Mrs Davies lodged her claim for compensation for bilateral CTS on 1 October 2010. Australia Post denied liability for this condition on 3 February 2011. Mrs Davies did not seek review of the decision and prior to the decision underwent bilateral carpal tunnel releases at her own expense. Mrs Davies’ symptoms improved post-carpal tunnel release but the duration of the improvement is not entirely clear. Mrs Davies describes her result as being good and enabling her to resume her normal duties. She dates the recurrence of her symptoms as 2 October 2012. Professor Muirden in his report relates the history given to him in which Mrs Davies said that the improvement lasted for only six months.